• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Elizabeth Gaskell is unfairly biased against men and blindly prejudiced against women in The Half-Brothers and The Manchester Marriage. Do you agree?

Extracts from this document...


Elizabeth Gaskell is unfairly biased against men and blindly prejudiced against women in The Half-Brothers and The Manchester Marriage. Do you agree? The Half-Brothers and The Manchester Marriage were written a long time ago in Elizabeth Gaskell's lifetime - which was in the mid-nineteenth century. Roles of men and women were different to what they are right now - they were (as you can expect) a bit more backwards to roles of men and women today. In order to elaborate whether Gaskell was prejudiced and biased against men and women, we need to see what the stereotypes of males and females were in that era. The Industrial Revolution had just started, so women had started to work (out of the house), but only just. Most women were expected to stay at home, do household chores, look after the children and be dutiful wives. Women of this role were probably stereotyped as being very 'feminine'- in a sense that they were shy, gentle, dutiful and possibly secondary to men. In some cases, they were seen as to being 'owned' by their husbands or fathers, and so were expected to be obedient creatures- at least towards men - and the image of men? Well, men were the 'breadwinners' of the family - house-husbands were unheard of. ...read more.


This reveals how the men like to handle the situations, even if it is the woman's affair, and even if the woman offers to do it. Men also like to be practical - Mr Openshaw demonstrates this by considering himself "too practical" to even have a wife. Even though he does propose later on in the story, when he does he hides any emotion, proposing in as an "indifferent voice as he could assume." Here, you see a man in the story being unemotional about a sensitive a matter as proposing! William Preston in The Half-Brothers also appears as unemotional - he "always kicked whenever he saw" his stepson's dog, and he would try to get his shepherd "to speak of [his stepson's] faults." Frank, from The Manchester Marriage, also seems to fit this generalization of men. Although he cares for his wife, his love is "violent", which gives the image of being the opposite of loving and gentle. Gaskell seems to be portraying men as unemotional human beings, but is she correct in doing so? Before that question can be answered, more areas of the different characters still need to be explored. Although uptil now in this essay it seems as though man and women in Gaskell's stories fit into categories, there is still another side to the characters... ...read more.


The title of the essay, the end of which reads, 'Do you agree?' leads me to form my own conclusions, which have to consider all the points explored. It seems to me that in some ways, one could say that the men and women have been portrayed according to the author's own opinion, and that the women have been stereotyped. To a certain extent, the title's statement is partly true, but I don't think that they are 'blind' prejudices or 'unfair' opinions. The author grew up in a time when men and women had very distinct roles in life, not as overlapping as they are now, and that some of the differences shown just reflects the view as society in that time perceived it. Women probably were more timid and submissive in those days - they didn't have any rights. As for the men, the same goes to them. They probably were less emotional and more authoritative - and the stories just reflect that. However, the stories also show that men and women are different and that women can have strong personality traits, and men can be gentle, so I think that Gaskell has portrayed them in a fair manner by showing the different characteristics of men and women, but at the same time allowing the readers to see that they are not all as they seem...so I have to say that I disagree with the title's statement. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Jane Austen essays

  1. In what ways does Elizabeth Gaskell (the Author), set the tone for the rest ...

    In a way, there is an element of mockery in the quote targeted towards Edith, making her sound not very bright; which is one of the early signs of Gaskell's themes in the book: people of poverty versus the people of wealth.

  2. How far do you agree with the critic that argues there are two Darcys?

    Not only is his reserved nature able to be classed as a result of society's intimidation, and naturally reflective personality, but perhaps also is a familial trait, as Austen makes much of Georgiana's shyness. We are told when we are introduced to her she 'would easily give to those who

  1. The Crucible: How is tension created and maintained between John and Elizabeth, and how ...

    John then walks in carrying a gun. This enforces stereotypical roles of a husband and wife and also gives us a sense of how long ago the play is set. We quickly notice a pattern of speech at the beginning of the Act. They speak little and in short sentences as though they are worried about offending the other if they say too much.

  2. "'Frau Brechenmacher' is a cry against the stupidity and brutality of men and the ...

    Herr Brechenmacher's uniform already sounds stunning with his 'polished... shoes' and buttons and his 'black satin necktie'. There are two main points in the text that shows how much Herr Brechenmacher has overpowered her - One, when they arrive at the wedding and he had forgotten his rights as a

  1. How are women presented in the 1900's

    We get her side of the story and her sense of freedom. Mrs Mallard says ""free, free, free" and this is when she realises she is free from her husband. At the end of the story she dies of the shock of seeing her husband again.

  2. Discuss the Relationship between John and Elizabeth Proctor and its Presentation. In What Ways ...

    The audience can sense the suspicion because they know of the affair with Abigail. John however also knows this, as he feels Elizabeth does not trust him. Personally, at this moment in the play I feel their relationship is very formal, because of the obvious emotional separation between them, which

  1. How Does Elizabeth Gaskell Create an Effective Ghost Story?

    The way tension is built up through out the story adds to the feeling of unease. The organ begins this disturbing atmosphere when the weather isn't good "someone "plays on the old organ but when Hester goes to look it's broken.

  2. "In Batiste's determination to continue the struggle lies the essence of Blasco Ibaez's optimism. ...

    The characters in the novel are frequently compared to beasts or animals throughout the story. We see them as "untamed" animals that, if pushed to far will murder. Copa's Tavern is described as: "la cueva de fiera"3 and even Don Joqu�n, the schoolteacher refers to his pupils as being "bestias"4.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work