• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Comparison Of 'The Bodysnatcher' and 'The Blood Bay'. How Do The Two Writers Create Different Styles Of Horror Story?

Extracts from this document...


Charlotte Hobson A Comparison Of 'The Bodysnatcher' and 'The Blood Bay'. How Do The Two Writers Create Different Styles Of Horror Story? 'The Bodysnatcher', written by R.L Stevenson, was originally published in 1878. 'The Blood Bay' written by Annie Proulx, was first published in 1999, over one hundred years after 'The Bodysnatcher'. Set in Debenham, Kent, 'The Bodysnatcher' begins at its end, with its characters considerably aged compared to the main part of the story. Edinburgh is where the story takes place, a setting which had previously been the city in which Burke and Hare's infamous bodysnatching had taken place, upon which this story is based. 'The Blood Bay' was set solely in Wyoming, Texas during the years 1886-87. In this short-story, Annie Proulx portrays horror not only through the evilness of the characters but through 'animal nasties' as well. R.L Stevenson was well known for his plagued sleep and it is thought that the horror which he experienced during his unconsciousness provided the inspiration for 'The Bodysnatcher'. This horror story also has 'human nasties', however contains strong psychological components in the shape of Grays apparent resurrection. 'The Blood Bay' uses aspects of black comedy to produce an atmosphere of horror whereas R.L Stevenson uses descriptive writing technique to create tension. The evil acts carried out in 'The Bodysnatcher' are predominantly set during hours of darkness, '...it was bitter cold, windy, and frosty; the town had not yet awakened...' This gives the reader an impression of mystery, subtly in itself creating a sensation of horror. R.L Stevenson also uses many different contrasts to emphasise the feeling behind each setting, '...by the warm radiance of the bar-room window. The George thus brightly advertised itself to passers-by in the cold street.' This description shows the audience how inviting The George appears to the public outside on the winter evening, creating the feeling of welcoming warmth and hospitality. ...read more.


This is a clever technique used by R.L Stevenson in which a strong feeling of tension is the product. Another contrast between Fettes and Macfarlane is the way in which they handle the events which unfold. At the beginning, when Fettes' suspicions about how the bodies were provided in ample amount were first confirmed, he was haunted by his conscience, '...by nights of roaring blackguardly enjoyment; and when that balance had been struck, the organ that he called his conscience declared itself content.' Simply meaning that Fettes drank himself into a stupor to escape his guilt, and only when had that been accomplished, could he try and forget about the vile dealings he'd just been involved in. Macfarlane on the other hand appears to be calm and confident about the whole situation. '...if you're a lion, you'll live and drive a horse like me...' When Macfarlane makes this statement to Fettes, it is a clear message that Fettes must be confident as well to survive the ordeal. R.L Stevensons excellent use of animal comparison produces a successful atmosphere full of tension and mystery, the very basis of a horror story. There are however psychological elements in this story, many creating the essential fear needed for a good horror story. 'A horrible sense of blackness and the treachery of fate seized hold upon the soul of the unhappy student.' This fantastic quote shows just how plagued by guilt Fettes actually is. The full extent of his self-doubt is realised and the style of horror created is very effective. Mr K, '... a certain extramural teacher of anatomy' gives the story a sense of fear due to the fact the character is based upon Dr Knox, the employer of Burke and Hare. 'His name was subsequently too well known...skulked through the streets of Edinburgh in disguise, while the mob that applauded at the execution of Burke called loudly for the blood of his employer.' ...read more.


The fact that Gray was resurrected is the guilty conscience of both parties finally becoming too much for either to handle. Fettes, the long time sufferer of guilt tips over the edge as his mind gets the better of him. Macfarlane, the character in the story who always seemed so confidant, 'Seemingly Macfarlane was affected in the same direction...' The full extent of Macfarlanes actions suddenly catch up with him and the body of Gray is what I believe to be the guilt of both these characters following them. At the beginning of the story when Fettes and Macfarlane meet again, Macfarlane seems eager to make something up to him. 'We must do something for you Fettes.' Blatantly ignoring his own and Fettes' horrific past. 'Have you seen it again? The great, rich London doctor cried out...' This quote shows that Macfarlane is still haunted by his past therefore the confidant countenance he projected in his youth seems to have been permanently scarred by the events which took place. This is the skill required when writing a story, being able to make you're audience think further than the words you have written down. R.L Stevenson has this skill; the cliff-hanger ends the story in a very emotional scene thick with tension and fear. Proulx however does not allow her audience to think deeper into the plot of 'The Blood Bay'. The words on the page are all the reader can go by and in a horror story; this style of writing isn't successful at all. In conclusion, I believe 'The Bodysnatcher' to be a much better horror story than 'The Blood Bay' simply because R.L Stevensons book contains a raw talent of horror story writing. His book is actually scary; at some points in the plot the emotions are so intense for the characters that they are palpable for the reader as well. Proulx's attempt contains humor of a kind that does not belong in a horror themed story. The fact that I laughed at certain descriptions completely contradicts the purpose of horror. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Robert Louis Stevenson section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Robert Louis Stevenson essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The English Patient

    5 star(s)

    he would find it difficult to remember the color of her eyes. He only sees what he needs to see. He spends time with the English patient because he realizes that, though sick, the creature inside is noble, and has a memory that reaches far deeper than any of the others'.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    The strength of Much Ado About Nothing lies in its balance of contrasting elements

    4 star(s)

    Shakespeare has used this convention to full effect. The traditional wedding convention has been used heavily by Shakespeare in Much Ado about nothing. All romantic comedies include the suggestion of a wedding. The wedding is a way of dispelling all potential tragedy and assuring the audience that the characters will live happily ever after.

  1. Lord of the flies comparison

    The influence of society from the boys old life was initially evident, but soon they descend into an underworld of murky morals; "In his other life Maurice had received chastisement for filling a younger eye with sand. Now, though there was no parent to let fall a heavy hand, Maurice still felt the unease of wrong-doing".

  2. The Use of The Four Elements in The Wars

    "The flamethrowr is a potent weapon with great psychological impact on unprepared soldiers, delivering a particular horrendous death-being burnt alive."("Flamethrower") Findley vividly describes a scene where Robert's battalion was attacked by German soldiers bearing flamethrowers. "Men carrying tanks of fire on their backs came in advance of the troops and spread the fire with hoses.

  1. Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening by Robert Frost and If Sleep and ...

    The line "But I have promises to keep" is not as rhythmically insistent as the other lines of the poem. It also contains the poem's only three-syllable word, "promises." Just as the man attempts to shake off his dreamy attraction to the woods, we are brought up short with this jarring line.

  2. A Comparison of the imagery and symbolism in Birdsong and Fair Stood the Wind ...

    These really oppose the imagery of human flesh during sex: "She wanted the touch of his skin/ He kissed her from the small of her back over the pink swell of divided flesh." We never see this rigorous description from Bates unless describing the landscape around his characters.

  1. Compare the ways the writers of your texts create a sense of fear in ...

    or spoken about, much like in Dorian Gray, in which again, issues are eluded to but never specifically spoken about.

  2. How do the writers present sexuality and gender in Tales Of Ovid, Streetcar Named ...

    and her spirited leading the way out of the hell of her sister?s home creates a moving tragic catharsis for the audience... Blanche?s defeat has considerable aesthetic dignity?. Williams? literature was strangely unmoved by the issue of gay rights and the issue of homosexuality that was so prominent in his

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work