• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the ways in which the two texts 'A picture of Dorian Gray' and 'Frankenstein' can be seen as works of gothic fiction.

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the ways in which the two texts 'A picture of Dorian Gray' and 'Frankenstein' can be seen as works of gothic fiction. A sense of the sinister and macabre is evident throughout the works of a traditionally gothic novel. Upon reading both 'A picture of Dorian Gray' and 'Frankenstein', one can immediately pinpoint common features traditionally associated with the gothic genre; the wild landscapes, stock characters, the supernatural and the obvious fascination with the past are perhaps the most vividly depicted features in both novels. However the most distinguishable element is the recognition of opposition and dualism, especially in the characters that encapsulates both novels. This duality present in most characters in both novels reflects an evil aspect about them common of gothic novels in which 'The villain was always the most complex and interesting character in gothic fiction'. Although Mary Shelley and Oscar Wilde employ the devices commonly associated with the gothic genre, neither produced a traditional work of gothic fiction. Both authors instead choose instead to subvert the gothic genre, forcing the reader to ask the question why and how does this subversion effect the reader's interpretation of both texts? Integral to any work of traditional gothic fiction is a defined villain, who will undoubtedly get there comeuppance at the end of the novel. However within 'Frankenstein' it is difficult to distinguish the real villain of the novel, the question at hand being, is the villain the creator, or the monster? The character of Victor is an isolated one, who chooses in the novel to sever ties with all friends and family on his uncontrollable quest for unattainable knowledge. ...read more.


Although at first the portrait doesn't appear to follow the traditional constraints of the gothic genre, ( ghosts and phantoms of the supernatural aspect for example), it can be seen to haunt Dorian in the novel resulting in him destroying it at the end, and therefore himself as one cannot exist without the other; just as society can't exist without corruption. Dorian is a Faustian figure which means a devil character is lacking in the novel, and the supernatural aspects of the novel are concentrated only in the painting. It is due to this therefore that the reader must consider the satanic aspects of society, as in 'Frankenstein', Dorian is a creation of Henry, who is a creation of society. It seems that both Wilde and Shelley were keen on pinpointing the criticisms to be made of society, circling around the idea that it is impossible to ever judge someone as evil, as it is difficult to distinguish between an innate sense of evil, or an evil that is simply a result of social conditioning. Wilde's highly sophisticated use of the supernatural continuously blurs the divisions between the natural and the supernatural obviously intended by Wilde to show how difficult it is to make a clear distinction between good and evil, and therefore how easy it is to move between the two. The presence of magical subtly mingled with reality serves a purpose in Frankenstein, with the monster given supernatural attributes. For example the monster is somehow able to know and be where Victor is at all times in the novel having the stalking presence of a ghost perhaps, with this sense of omniscience reflecting how he now governs Victor's life, and if the monster is said to reflect society at this point, it could be said to be representing a restricting society with negative consequences. ...read more.


the detailed parallels between the lives of Walton, Frankenstein and the monster emphasises the danger Walton is in if he continues his strive for knowledge, which can also be imposed upon everyone, including the reader who should therefore read 'Frankenstein' as a cautionary tale. 'A Picture of Dorian Gray' on the otherhand has a linear structure reflecting the continuous deterioration of his soul, with the third person being used by an ambiguous omniscient narrator which manipulates the reader into criticising the repressive Victorian society. Unlike 'Frankenstein', Wilde does not allow detachment to the characters as it is a criticism of society of a whole, whereas 'Frankenstein's' use of the first person and epistolary form seems to challenge the people of the enlightenment more then society. It remains arguable whether both 'Frankenstein' and 'A picture of Dorian Gray' can be considered a works of gothic fiction morsel then. However both authors skilled subversion of the genre results in a complete almost confusing blurring of distinctions. It is clear that both novelists wanted not the challenge the conventions of the gothic genre, but instead challenge the conventions in society used to restrict and repress people. It is for this reason that both texts can be read from a feminist, psychoanalytical, and Marxist view, as all reflect a fraction of society marginalized. The issue of universal ethics is clearly highlighted in both novels, suggesting that there are broader issues to be considered at hand. Although neither author produced a conventional traditional work of gothic fiction, it cannot be said that neither produced a work reflecting the sinister and the macabre, i an almost realistic way, which in fact seems to evoke more horror form the reader. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Mary Shelly section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Mary Shelly essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The English Patient

    5 star(s)

    He was moved from the Western desert to Tunis, then shipped to Italy. Because he could not be identified, and could hardly remember who he was, the British had a very difficult time trying to determine whether or not he was an enemy.

  2. A Critique of Society in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

    rather than the crime alleged against him had been the cause of his condemnation.' Safie's father, though yet again an innocent man, is sentenced to death because of his race, rather than his offence. Imperatively, it must be recognised that the only time in the novel that anyone is pleasant

  1. Compare and contrast the ways in which the writers of 'Frankenstein' and 'The Picture ...

    This impression is furthered with the first physical descriptions: the monster is as different as possible from Dorian Gray, with 'watery eyes' set in 'dun white sockets', a 'shrivelled complexion and straight black lips'5. If the same physiognomic criteria are applied as above, this negative description would imply that the

  2. Ambition in "The Duchess of Malfi" and "Paradise Lost"

    Satan instructs his angels to "awake, arise or be forever fallen", showing that if you understand what you truly want; you will follow your ambition, which in part is natural cause. Showing the angels who do not fall as being the "forever fallen" highlights ambition to be a persuasion of

  1. Compare and contrast the presentation of monsters in Bram Stokers Dracula and Mary Shelleys ...

    For the creation of Frankenstein, she uses motifs of Christianity to compare to his relationship with his creator. Through the use of his eloquent language he alludes to John Milton's Paradise Lost, one of the books the monster reads while living in the peasants' hovel.

  2. Comparing Macbeth to Victor Frankenstein

    The audience would feel empathetic towards Victor, because he commited an act of blasphemy, followed by an act of complete selfishness. The audience definitely feels pity towards both characters. Both characters display qualities of inability to understand human life and feelings.

  1. Focusing On a Clockwork Orange and Frankenstein compare some of the ways authors explore ...

    This shows his education of society, a possible trait picked from his 'hybrid' brain, or the backseat view of society and the need to understand a society to fit in, it enhances the Monster's knowledge of his own expulsion from society because he doesn't fit into the mould of such a society and never will be able too.

  2. In both Othello and The Merchant of Venice, however, Shakespeare presents female characters who ...

    However both of the marriages seem to deteriorate when the wives become merely possessions to their husbands. Othello loses his trust and succumbs to the ?green-eyed monster? (3.3.168) and Bassanio gives the ring away. This suggests that women initially have a status of power, but this is lost once they are handed from their fathers to their husbands.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work