• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far do you agree that the ending of Henry IV (part 2) is more tragic than triumphant?

Extracts from this document...


Jan 2006 (a) How far do you agree that the ending of Henry IV (part 2) is more tragic than triumphant? In the course of your answer: * Explain clearly how Shakespeare presents the ending of the play; * Comment on what the play suggests about the significance of Hal's becoming King. The ending of Henry IV Part 2 can be seen as more tragic than triumphant. We can look at Falstaff to try and answer this question as to whether the play is seen to be more tragic than triumphant. Falstaff is portrayed as a comical character which the audience sympathises with, when Hal rejects Falstaff and leaves him with little it shows us that the audience can see Henry Iv part 2 ending with as tragic. However, some people may argue that the ending may be triumphant for Hal as by rejecting Falstaff he is getting rid of immoral vices which shows us that he can become a great King. ...read more.


Hal publicly humiliates Falstaff and Falstaff's reaction this this creates a sense of pity and sorrow. However, at the beginning Falstaff tries to believe that Hal is joking, Falstaff begins to realise that maybe this isn't the case and we can see that Falstaff is hurt by how Hal has treated him. We begin to sympathise Falstaff and some people would say that the ending is tragic because of this. Others may believe it to be triumphant as it showed us that Hal had the strength to prove to the Lord Chief Justice that he is capable in this new position which he has. It also shows us that England now has the chance to start recovering from everything which had happened in the past from whether it have being from his father and the guilt he witheld but also the disease which had spread over England and was portrayed through many of the characters in the play. ...read more.


From genre of History at this time Elizabeth was unsure of who was going to become the next heir to the throne. This shows us that although they are uncertain of who is next to reign that there will be a great leader. In conclusion, to a certain extent I agree with both sides as to whether this play can be seen as triumphant or tragic. However, in my opinion I would have to say that the play can be seen as triumphant as it showed that Henry V was going to be a good king and that the decision he would have to make later on during his reign would be one for the whole England as he would understand what other people's opinions would be rather than just the courts. Although, for many the play can be seen as tragic as Henry V does reject Falstaff and Falstaff is seen as one of the most known characters in Shakespeare's history plays he will never be forgotten. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Henry V section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Henry V essays

  1. The contrast between Hotspur and Hal is the main theme in Henry IV part ...

    The King says that Hal must have been sent by God to punish his own "mistreadings." The King can't understand why in spite of his royal blood Hal is so attached to vulgar pleasures with his unfavourable companions "such barren pleasures, rude society".

  2. Coriolanus is a man of action who is finally defeated by words. To what ...

    ill-schooled / In bolted language', which clearly shows that the reason he lacks the skill to speak like a true politician is because he has been brought up as a soldier, and soldiers need only to think of their actions and how swiftly they execute them.

  1. Comment on and analyse the role of women in the King Richard 3rd?

    even contemplates the thoughts of going with him "To his new kingdom of ne'er-changing night." as she cannot tolerate the thought of being without him. The language that Shakespeare uses in this quote can be seen as though Elizabeth is dragging the fact that the King is dead out even further as though she cannot really believe it.

  2. A comparison (up to the end of Act 3) of the 'courts' of Henry ...

    This is throughout Act 3 Scene 2. An example to show this will be in lines 18-28, "So please your Majesty, I would I could Quit all offences wit as clear excuse As well as I am doubtless I

  1. Consider How Shakespeare Presents and Develops the Character of Prince Hal and Hotspur In ...

    has been. "A banished woman from Harry's bed." Kate obviously loves Hotspur, she pleads with him to share with her what he's planning but Hotspur refuses, We see how Shakespeare develops Hotspur's character in Act 2 Scene 3 he reveals the flaws in his character.

  2. To what extent does the tragedy of Titus Andronicus unfold from the protagonist and ...

    Titus has a crippling incapability of doing anything but making Tamora suffer, the only time we see him in any other manner is as the family sit to eat and Titus must feed Lavinia, their relationship draws out his paternal nature, but his character is still not redeemed of earlier


    This past life clearly has an influence on Hal, as it truly demonstrates to him the danger of straying far from the path that one would expect him to take. It seems fair therefore to assume that without this seemingly negative section of his upbringing perhaps he would not later have become a responsible ruler.

  2. To what extent does Falstaffs role transcend that of a buffon in henry IV ...

    He is a member of the upper class, responsible for law, order, and good government. His subversive qualities would be far less powerful, were he simply a fat common layabout. But he has the same rank as, Sir Walter Blunt, and is entitled to join all the commanders in the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work