• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

who in your opinion is the true hero of Henry the fourth part 1

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Who in your opinion is the true hero of the play? Explore the ways in which it is fair to say Hal is the true hero of the play. In Henry IV debatably the main character of the play is Hal, the son of Henry IV. Hal is disliked by his father but earns back his right to the crown through the events of the play. Hotspur could also be viewed as the plays true hero; he is the leader of the rebellion and the enemy of the king. However my view is that Hal is the true hero of the play because he ultimately wins over Hotspur and corrects his flaws. Traditionally a hero is defined as mighty, filled with positive attributes, but also flawed, examples of this derive from Greek mythology, men such as Achilles, who's flaw was his heel. And Hercules who's flaw was the love for his girlfriend. Both Hal and Hotspur are worthy of the label of the traditional hero. However because Hal recognises his flaws and conquers them, 'so when this loose behaviour I throw off', (Act 1 Scene 3, line196) he sporns a new, modern breed of heroic character. Hotspur is better suited to the traditional hero. ...read more.

Middle

The audience prefers to believe Hal, because subconsciously we want him to succeed. We want Hal to succeed because he has many good qualities and he can detect when to be serious and when to be humorous, he is the opposite of Hotspur in many ways and the audience admires him. During the play Shakespeare switches from a scene involving Hotspur to a scene involving Hal. The two characters have a near equal balance of time with the audience, Shakespeare is creating the illusion that this is fair and that we have the free-will to decide which character we prefer. However Shakespeare uses comedy to attract the audience to Hal, and then he changes Hal, making him sincere and serious at the right time so that the audience has no choice but want Hal to succeed. Because generally success is linked with heroism, the audience wants Hal to be the true hero of the play. Falstaff is a major influence in Hal's life; he is arguably the cause of Hal's criminal conscience. Shakespeare uses Falstaff as a contrast, in order to exemplify Hal's heroic qualities. When Falstaff is around Hal often seems even more heroic. For example whilst Hal fights and defeats Hotspur, Falstaff pretends to be dead, only to resurrect and claim credit for Hotspur's defeat, 'I look to be either Earl or Duke, I can assure you' (Act 5 Scene 4 line 139). ...read more.

Conclusion

This means that any readers that admired Hotspur for being a serious hard-working leader will convert their loyalties to Hal. Towards the end of the play, the king offers Hotspur an exit from the rebellion, Hotspur knows he is going to lose and he continues despite of this, even though his own life is at risk. This could be considered as honourable, Hotspur sticks to his believes throughout, and will even sacrifice his own life for his views. However it could also be argued that this is a stubborn choice, Hotspur is unable to identify his flaws and this is the reason why he cannot be the plays true hero and the reason why he could not win the rebellion. His pride was his flaw and it eventually destroys him. However it could be concluded that Hotspur is the plays true hero as he sticks to his beliefs throughout but is destroyed by his flaws. In conclusion I believe that Hal is the true hero of the play, he recognises and conquers his flaws, he defeats his enemies and he achieves forgiveness for his wrong doings. Hal fits the label of the new modern hero who overcomes their flaws. Written by Jamie Skinner! ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Henry V section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Henry V essays

  1. The contrast between Hotspur and Hal is the main theme in Henry IV part ...

    " Give me life; which if I can save, so; if not, honour comes unlooked for, and there's an end" Falstaff's version of honour licenses him to do anything so long as his own life is preserved. If we are in doubt that Falstaff's honour is as dangerous and empty

  2. In his opening soliloquy, the true nature of Richards character is revealed, his villainy ...

    his wrongdoings, and that the evil in his nature is merely a by-product of the 'unfairness' of his physical appearance. Apart from the soliloquy, it would be difficult for the audience to grasp Richard's character as he scarcely exhibits such honesty throughout the play.

  1. Comment on and analyse the role of women in the King Richard 3rd?

    It is as if the repetition of the words represents the life that one of them has had which will then be repeated for the other one. Both parents named their son Edward, they knew they were both going to be or eventually become the Prince of Wales so once

  2. Taking into consideration of the language and structure of the play, how would you ...

    women in this play perceive as just before Richard enters, Anne has a monologue, cursing him, in which she says "Oh, cursed be the hand that made these holes / Cursed be the heart that had the heart to do it / Cursed let the blood that let the blood from hence."

  1. Examine closely the contrasting characters of Hal and Hotspur in King Henry IV, Part ...

    This contrast is shown clearly with the alternating scenes' having every scene being set on either Hal in Eastcheap and then the next with Hotspur in a knightly place. This helps with the development and change of the two characters as you can see clearly the rise of Hal throughout

  2. A comparison (up to the end of Act 3) of the 'courts' of Henry ...

    be commenc'd in stronds afar remote: No more the thirsty entrance of this soil Shall daub her lips with her own children's blood; No more shall trenching war channel her fields, Nor bruise her flow'rets wit the armed hoofs Of hostile paces."

  1. How Important Is Prince Henry (Prince Hal) in Henry IV-Part 1?

    Prince Hal had another idea, instead of praising Falstaff; Prince Hal thought it would be amusing to disgrace him. Prince Hal spoke out as the King, "Thou art violently carried away from grace. There is a devil haunts thee in the likeness of an old fat man."

  2. "Richard III is a study in evil." Discuss Richard's role as a tragic hero.

    They have sympathy for the character. And fear is when the viewer realises that if circumstances were different they would also be caught up in a web of tragic events and the viewer empathises with the character. There are many moments in Richard III when we feel pity for the protagonist.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work