• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"The Poplar Field" by William Cowper "Binsey Poplars felled 1879" by Gerard Manley Hopkins - Write an essay comparing and contrasting the two poems.

Extracts from this document...


James Lee 11ME 17th September 2004 English Literature Mrs Firth Pre 20th Century Poetry "The Poplar Field" by William Cowper "Binsey Poplars felled 1879" by Gerard Manley Hopkins Write an essay comparing and contrasting the two poems. The first thing that is noticeable is that both the poems are about a group of trees alongside a river. The other general similarity between the poems is that they are then later cut down and so the writers are now deprived of their enjoyment in the "cool colonnade". However there are many differences between the poems. Firstly we notice that Hopkins uses far more complex rhyming schemes to capture the reader. He uses an erratic rhyming scheme and irregular stanzas. The rhyming scheme that Hopkins uses in the first stanza is of a simpler scheme than that of the second stanza. Using letters, I have noted down the rhyming scheme for the first and the second stanza. This is the rhyming scheme for the first stanza: ABABCBDCC. This row of letters represents the rhyming words at the end of each sentence. In the first and the third line, Hopkins uses "quelled" and "felled". ...read more.


This implies that even though they are cut down they are still useful even though he preferred them as a form of shade. In the third stanza Cowper writes how the death of the poplars have affected the wildlife. He specifically writes about the blackbird having to find refuge in an other habitat. In the fourth stanza Cowper describes that he is getting older and will soon die just like the poplars. This implies that he is more concerned with his life and that he, one day, will have "turf " on is "breast, and a stone at" his head, meaning that he will die soon like the poplar trees. He cleverly uses the trees as a way of thinking about human mortality. In the fifth stanza he continues to reflect about himself approaching death which prompts him to think of the "perishing pleasures of man" and ironically says that man's life is short, his enjoyment of the poplars lasts shorter than he. Over looking Cowpers poem, this all ads up to meditation on human life and how short life is, the fragility of life and the fact that life can end suddenly and unexpectedly. ...read more.


The trees were their friends and they are sad to see them go. They look wistfully back on the trees remembering the positive images of them being with the trees. Cowper in the concluding verse writes that he must move on and just remember the good times he had in the presence of the trees. Hopkins on the other hand has a more negative approach to the cutting down of the trees. He shows that he was very attached to trees and how he wishes that mankind would not be so destructive. I think that in terms of reading, I found that William Cowper's "The Poplar Field" was a lot easier to read and understand. The poem was a lot simpler to understand because there wasn't as much imagery put into the poem that might have mislead the reader. However I thoroughly enjoyed reading "Binsey Poplars" by Gerard Manley Hopkins because of the vast amount of thought provoking ideas that came into the poem. It had a very nice texture to it with all the metaphors and alliteration. The alliteration certainly had a great effect on me in terms of me imagining the scene where the trees grew. Hopkins has showed me how poetry should be written; going over the top to create a picture to help the reader understand what the poet is trying to convey. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Philip Larkin section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Philip Larkin essays

  1. Poetry and Melancholy in Sheers Examination of Welsh Identity

    Sheers explores these flimsy, transient relationships through the use of poetry as art; 'The Sarabande still played within her. The fragility of its sadness had turned her chest to shivered glass.' This quotation from Resistance exposes Sheers' technique of presenting poetry as the precedent for an elegiac note, as it's

  2. Wild Oats & Afternoons: A Comparitive Essay

    Indeed, Larkin drains the young mothers' lives of the romance they must once have had - their wedding albums lie abandoned by the television (which presumably receives more attention than they do), and there is perhaps a bitter pun on the word 'lying'.

  1. Comparative Poetry Essay - "The Thought Fox" and "Digging"

    The undignified image of his father's "straining rump" reveals how Heaney feels about his father in the present; what seems to be a mixture of distaste and embarrassment. He then slips back into a time "twenty years away", a time when he was presumably quite young.

  2. Compare how each poet writes about nature in "Spring" by Hopkins and "How the ...

    These structures can emphasize the regularity of the sunset and of spring, which will always come back without fail. In How the old Mountains drip with Sunset Dickinson in the last stanza compares a simple sunset to Italian painters. This suggest that even the most talented of painters are unable

  1. ComparativeCommentry of Two Passages

    that the people are very tired and are struggling to wake up the next day after doing a lot of things like party on the new year eve. Whereas there is no paradox and personification used in the second passage, but there is another stylistic device called anamatopia used in (line 29)

  2. This essay will attempt to offer a close, detailed comparison of the following pair ...

    The poem uses imagery of light/warmth and dark/cold for contrast. The first five lines of this poem describe a journey, and from the poem's title, we know that those travelling are Magi (The word Magi is plural; the singular form is Magus.)

  1. Comparing And Contrasting The Poems The Trees by Phillip Larkin and The Trees Are ...

    Mew symbolizes a dead rat to emphasize her message that spring is a time of new life, stating, ? But at least, in May, even a rat should be alive? (11). Mew believes that it?s very un-natural for anything to be dead in the spring. It ?unmakes the spring? (19)

  2. Sir Philip Sidneys poem The Nightingale and Amy Clampitts poem Syrinx are two very ...

    I feel thorn represents pain and anguish and the speaker is once again saying how Philomela may have been raped yet it is over now and she is no longer in pain.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work