• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Brief Encounter and Falling in Love - a story simplified and continued.

Extracts from this document...


UNIVERZA V LJUBLJANI FILOZOFSKA FAKULTETA ODDELEK ZA ANGLISTIKO IN AMERIKANISTIKO Anja Ambro�-Bizjak: Brief Encounter and Falling in Love: a story simplified and continued Mentorica: Prof. Tina Mahkota Kranj, 17.2.2003 Discussing David Lean's Brief Encounter (1945) is often conclusive to mentioning its remakes: Brief Encounter produced by Carlo Ponti in 1973 and the 1984 version Falling in Love directed by Ulu Grosbard. All three are beautiful, perhaps even text-book examples, of how a film or a story can develop through time, different cultural approaches, of how different aspects of a certain story are brought into focus at different times by different people, how different techniques are used, and ultimately, why one decides to make a remake rather than an 'original' film. To show that a remake is not merely a copy but that it is an original piece of work, I am only going to focus on the original Lean's Brief Encounter and on the last version Falling in Love. Moreover, the comparison of the two will show that the remake is largely culturally influenced and that the story itself may be changed to a great extent. First of all, the most apparent reason why remakes happen is economic - a remake as a 'presold' property. ...read more.


Moreover, another proof of how the way things are presented gives meaning to the film is the remake Falling in Love. A similar story line in Falling in Love is presented in a linear way, with no inner monologues - everything that is felt by the characters is said to their friends or not shown at all. The result of this is that the main characters in Falling in Love, Margaret Gilmore (Molly) played by Meryl Streep and Frank Raftis played by Robert De Niro, appear to be passive, indecisive and less 'real'. It is as though they are two people being involved in a love affair by a coincidence. And indeed, in this film coincidences are its weakest point. There are simply too many of them, Throughout the opening of the film the two main characters appear in the same locations (the train, public telephones at the station, the shopping centre, the book shop) but do not run into each other and do not know each other. Furthermore, they do not even notice each other until they bump into each other at the bookshop and by accident take each other's books instead of theirs. Later on they see each other again on a train a few months later. ...read more.


Obviously, the two versions differ in many ways and in my opinion Falling in Love is a simplified version of Brief Encounter with certain changes that are culturally as well as historically based. It is logical that the situations as well as trains and the stations in Falling in Love are different since the setting was the eighties in the USA and also there is no stress on social class since this could not be an issue in the American film of that time. And perhaps this is a remake, which meant to be entirely different from the original, as far as the plotline, character portrayal and technique are concerned, for it has a different title as well. And looking at it from that point of view, we can see that the films and the titles bear an important meaning: in Brief Encounter the story is actually only about an encounter which was brief and so was the affair which ended as fast as an encounter. But in Falling in Love we see the process of two people gradually developing feelings for each other and in a way we can see the denoument, in a way a positive continuation of Lean's story, which was sad and dark. Falling in Love, however, is a happy, sunny fairy-tale with a happy end. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level David Guterson section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level David Guterson essays

  1. Handmaid Tale by Margret Atwood

    has found some excitement in her life through the commander and now her, "I am so excited, I can hardly breathe..." (pg. 211) even though Offred was given a hope it is automatically shattered when a man is abducted from the streets by the Gilead's authorities.

  2. Yen Mah, Adeline. Falling Leaves. New York, New York., 1997Adeline Yen Mah, the author ...

    with the truth that not receiving the will was fine but knowing her father had noticed and loved her as his daughter was all she needed. Adeline in this story Falling Leaves was considered as a round character where she portrayed herself as a lonely and depressed little girl and

  1. In death, Carlo is described as 'the perfect figure of the perfect man.' To ...

    The incident has, of course, a non-metaphysical explanation in the shifting movement of the earth in the aftermath of a quake, but the actuality and symbolism of the moment leave a profound impression. 'No sooner had he begun the task of reburial than another judder unbalanced him, and the red

  2. What do we learn from de Bernieres portrayal of the relationship between Carlo and ...

    Whilst this relationship allows him to channel and harness his sexual energy for greater good, it can be seen to create immense inner strife. Clearly attracted to Francesco yet being unable to even acknowledge this for fear of discovery depicts a character being pulled in two directions.

  1. Explore the different forms of haunting in Toni Morrisons Beloved.

    Literarily, passages in 'Beloved' are highly similar to previously published slave narratives, such as Harriet Jacob's 'Incidents in the life of a Slave Girl'. The passage where Sethe speaks in the first person: "I stood by her bed waiting for her to finish with the slop jar.

  2. Snowdrops (short story) analysis

    Look at the opening: "Today Miss Webster was going to show them the snowdrops..." Immediately we are thinking of questions: Who is "Miss Webster"? Who are "they"? What is so special about showing snowdrops to "them" on this particular day?

  1. "'We Need to Talk About Kevin' presents us with unsympathetic characters who nevertheless attract ...

    Don't you ever, ever say that. Not once, not ever, not one more time!'" - She refuses to allow him to criticise Franklin, although she does it fairly often herself: "You tried so hard to be an attentive, affectionate father.

  2. English Literature Assessment Lucy Honeychurch and Stevens are two characters who represent the ...

    Italy also challenges the idea of beauty and delicacy being indistinguishable. Italy's attractiveness is sophisticated and exquisite, yet not at all delicate. The cyclical structure of A Room with a View is also important to recognise. The book begins and ends in the spring.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work