• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Explore Shakespeare’s Presentation of Caliban; a product of nature or nurture?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Aaron Jackson 12ES English coursework Explore Shakespeare's Presentation of Caliban; a product of nature or nurture? In Shakespeare's "The Tempest " the character of Caliban is portrayed in a puzzling and thought-provoking manner. He is a complex character as at times he displays savage like qualities and at others he displays an appreciation for nature and expresses his love for his habitat using poetic devices. Through Caliban Shakespeare explores the themes of nature and nurture. The question raised is, whether Caliban is the product of inheritance and is innately savage or whether his characteristics are a result of his social environment and the cruelty channelled towards him by the islands newer inhabitants. Within this essay I will be exploring the two opinions, the first one being that Caliban was born bad because of his parents also being bad, and the second being whether he appears bad because he does not fit into the mould of a civilised being which was created by his islands new arrivals. The name Caliban is an anagram of "cannibal" which was often spelt with one "n" in William Shakespeare's day, or it may derive from "Cariban" since Shakespeare would have been familiar with stories regarding savage "Carib Indians". Either way the name's origin would immediately provide the audience of the time with the expectation of baseness. Caliban was born as the son of "the foul witch Sycorax". The first description of Caliban shows him as animalistic and misshapen: "save for the son that she did litter here, a freckled whelp, hag-born- not honoured with a human shape". Every character in the play calls him by derogatory names. He is called a "tortoise", "monster", "filth", "poisonous snake". ...read more.

Middle

It is set on an "isle" apart from normal society and all the action takes place within four hours. It examines the contrast between supposed uncivilised and civilised beings and the results of colonialism. In spite of all the disorder portrayed it ends on a note of triumph. The older generation have found reconciliation and the younger have found love. Even Caliban is seeking " grace." The title, "The Tempest" could refer to the physical storm that occurs in the play and which cuts the characters and action off from the normal world. However it could also refer to the turbulent passions of the characters. In particular Caliban undergoes an amazing storm of emotions throughout the play from the poetic love of his island to hatred at enslavement to acceptance and peacefulness at the end. The form and structure of the play allows Shakespeare to concentrate on exploring the above themes. Caliban is a representation of the conflict between nature and nurture between the power of civilisation and instinct. Shakespeare vividly portrays through Caliban and the other characters interactions with him the conflict that was going on in Elizabethan society regarding colonisation. He can be seen as a representation of the noble savage. Wordsworth and Colderidge wrote about similar themes in their poetry. Coleridge wrote that " Caliban is wonderfully conceived: he is a sort of creature of the earth- Caliban is a noble being : a man in the sense of the imagination". Despite having had to learn a new language from Miraanda and Prospero , Caliban's poetic speeches are equal to theirs. ...read more.

Conclusion

Therefore whether baseness is inherited or develops is not really the issue at hand. Perhaps Shakespeare wishes us to recognise a little of Caliban in our selves, not completely corrupt, showing some fine qualities but being very human in responding to both good and bad in his environment. In conclusion Caliban is a thought provoking character who depicts the nature of humanity being influenced by both nature and nurture. Finally I would say that throughout the play the character of Caliban gives us confusing signals to his nature. At times such as when he is extremely impressionable around Stephano and Trinculo he shows himself to be a product of nurture but at other times such as when he attempts to rape Miranda he proves that his base instincts will conquer all others. I would conclude that it is open to interpretation whether he is a product of nature or nurture as he displays qualities which link to both theories, I also think an audiences opinion of Caliban's nature depends on the way in which the director of the play chooses to present him. The character provokes an extremely varied set of reactions. I feel that modern audiences would react differently from the Shakespeare's contemporaries to the character of Caliban, Post colonisation and post holocaust audiences would be well aware of the dangers of prejudice. It is now impossible not to sympathise with the enslaved Caliban although Shakespeare's audiences would not perhaps have shared this sympathy. It is a tribute to Shakespeare's greatness as a dramatist that the play allowed the Elizabethan audiences to consider such an important theme, which is still relevant in today's world. ?? ?? ?? ?? Explore Shakespeare's presentation of Caliban; a product of nature or nurture? Aaron Jackson 12ES ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level The Tempest section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level The Tempest essays

  1. How does Shakespeare present Caliban in TheTempest ?

    Which he has obviously spent along time planning over and over in his mind. By planning these crimes it gives him an amount of power. He does not really want to kill prospero but by imagining what he would do gives him power, as his mind cannot be controlled by Prospero as he is over powered.

  2. Nature Versus Nurture.

    Trying to achieve their goal, Stephano and Trinculo act just like Antonio and Sebastian do when they try to kill Alonso. Therefore Stephano and Trinculo show nature being more influential in their Pemberton 3 development than nurture. One more example of a goal affecting development can be found with Prospero's

  1. The Tempest has been called a tragi-comedy. Show why you think this is an ...

    But some events in the play clearly belong to comedy. The sub-plot concerning Stephano, Trinculo and Caliban from Act II onwards is grotesque. The three servants of little moral and dignity meet and conspire to take over the island by murdering Prospero.

  2. Compare the presentation of Ariel and Caliban in the play

    Iris, Ceres, Juno, Nymphs and Reapers. Ariel is a plot device that makes the story happen. Where as Caliban is seen as a comedy factor that is used in the sub-plot which mirrors the main plot. Ariel has a lot of power within the play compared to Caliban who has no power at all and is controlled by everyone.

  1. Discuss the presentation and significance of Caliban in 'The Tempest'

    Prospero treats Caliban and Ariel very similarly when they disobey him "I will rend an oak and peg thee in his knotty entrails till though hast howled away twelve winters" (Act 1, Scene 2, L295). Prospero threatens both Caliban and Ariel when they don't obey Prospero's orders.

  2. Shakespeares 'The Tempest' as a Study of Colonialism.

    Prospero, the former Duke of Milan, after being removed by his brother, arrives on an island.

  1. Explore Shakespeare's presentation of the theme of power in the "The Tempest"

    Ariel is the eyes and ears of Prospero on the island. However all the magic power that Prospero gains on the island is let go of towards the end of the play. This is because when his plan is finished and has worked he no longer sees the need for

  2. How does Shakespeare present Prospero's relationship with Ariel and Caliban throughout the course of ...

    (5, 1, 275) Skura also notes this point in her commentary. Caliban is a threat to Prospero's supremacy on the island. In this respect, Caliban is akin to a New World native threatening European supremacy. But, quite aside from that, Caliban, like Prospero's dark side, does hold a threat to Prospero.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work