• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Feminist critic Anne K. Mellor argues that Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is an attack on masculine Romanticism. To what extent do you agree with Mellor's assessment?

Extracts from this document...


Feminist critic Anne K. Mellor argues that Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is an attack on masculine Romanticism. To what extent do you agree with Mellor's assessment? I believe that Mary Shelley's Frankenstein is an attack on the masculine Romanticism, thus, meaning my agreement with Mellor's assessment. In Shelley's novel, the ambitious Romantic hero, Victor Frankenstein, challenges the laws of nature by trying to dominate the role of the females. He attempts to do so by creating artificial life, however, his attempt to tamper with the "ever-varied powers of nature", is then the cause for his "destruction". One interpretation of the novel is that man must keep equilibrium between his ambitious "pursuit of knowledge" and "the tranquility of his domestic affections", not allowing one aspect to "interfere" with another. Shelley structures her novel in a way that Walton's framing tale is used as a warning to the readers who can relate to masculine characteristics, telling them to tame their ambition before it's too late. And through Frankenstein's narrative, Shelley hopes that the readers can "deduce an apt moral" being that over ambition corrupts. ...read more.


Throughout Frankenstein's narrative, vocabulary associated with isolation, religion and witchcraft is used to describe his story. Frankenstein described his work as the "unhallowed arts" which he created by "collecting bones in charnel houses", and "disturbed" them with fingers that he described as being "profane". The effect of using the word "profane" is that it shows his awareness of irreverence to God, and by using the metaphor "unhallowed arts" to describe his work, it indicates that he created something that he considers as being "evil". Another effect of Shelley's choice of vocabulary is that it introduces gothic themes, such as darkness and alienation; which is further emphasized by Walton's setting in the artic oceans, and Frankenstein's constant use of dominative vocabulary, such as "sole" and "one"; which also indicates obsessive behavior. By showing Frankenstein's awareness of his previous actions, Shelley is able to convey a sense of darkness and regret that was caused by his impulsive excitement, which led him to neglect the consequential factors. Frankenstein's character of being caught up in" passion" and "transitory desire" may have been influenced by Percy Shelley as his quote, "discoursing with increasing vehemence", reflects Frankenstein's eagerness, impatience and egoism to create something scientific based on an emotional judgment. ...read more.


At first, the light imagery in Frankenstein symbolizes enlightenment, discovery and knowledge. In the beginning, Frankenstein metaphorically phrases his ideas as being a "new light". An "ineffectual light" is then used to signify his hope for making his revolutionary idea a success. However, the light imagery which signified hope and discovery then changed into becoming a "torrent of light", which can be seen as signifying the light of knowledge's blinding intensity. Light is often associated with fire; and fire hurts the ones who try to 'penetrate' it. This then attaches a sense of harm to the light of discovery and knowledge which the scientists try so hard to grasp on to. Another way of seeing the association of the light imagery with fire is through the myth of Prometheus, who suffers sever punishment for introducing the knowledge of fire to mankind. Like Prometheus, Frankenstein 'tries' to introduce forbidden knowledge to the human race, but fails and is punished for it. This then leads to the message being that his hunger for 'glory' only led to his "utter destruction", which was foreseen during Frankenstein's account of the oak tree that inspired him to use galvanism to "animate...lifeless matter". ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Mary Shelly section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Mary Shelly essays

  1. Who is the real monster in Mary Shelleys Frankenstein

    Although the monster executed this murder, Frankenstein is the one responsible, as he had not taken into consideration the consequences of his actions when bringing his creation to life. After having murdered a person, the reader would assume that there is nothing more that could possibly affect the creature in a positive way.

  2. Compare and contrast the ways in which Frankenstein and one other Gothic novel explore ...

    'Yellow skin' that 'scarcely covers' muscles and arteries is the reverse of what should be expected, and anything that possesses a body like this cannot be natural, and moreover if the unnatural is monstrous, then indeed both of these creatures satisfy the criteria.

  1. To what extent is ''Frankenstein' concerned with the theme of education and what does ...

    It does bring up questions of who ought to be able to control life and death, which the creature then follows through killing, through controlling the manner and time of death of those that Victor held dear. However, despite the creature's education through learning from his surroundings, there is still some quality to him which is not human.

  2. [The] juxtaposition of the ghastly and the everyday suggests one of the defining characteristics ...

    and yet he too is killed by the monster. It soon becomes apparent that all of the characters suffer burdens or imprisonment, some of which are inflicted by the monster and therefore inadvertently Frankenstein himself. This could be symbolic once more of Mary Shelley's views of science as not simply

  1. In Frankenstein(TM) it is generally accepted that the female characters and their values are ...

    Elizabeth is a classic gothic female victim in that she is vulnerable and in distress to which only her hero, Victor Frankenstein, can help her with. Also classically gothic is that Elizabeth is under threat by a monster; something of hideous ugliness is here contrasted with a person of celestial beauty.

  2. Consider the ways in which Mary Shelley uses different Gothic settings to contribute to ...

    Yet this interpretation is not fully justified and it does not equate to Frankenstein?s warning to Walton, ?learn from me...how dangerous is the acquirement of knowledge?. Shelley?s voice perhaps is being heard, condoning the ambitious romantic values. Undoubtedly however, as with Walton?s letters, Shelley intelligently intertwines Romantic values, altruism, with Gothic ones.

  1. Analysis of Frankenstein Extract pages 101 103

    Finally, religion is a key concept in the extract due to the time period in which the novel was written. Religion was very prominent during the 1800?s and anyone going against Catholicism was publicly prosecuted. Hence, during the publishing of the book there was an outcry by the religious followers

  2. Human curiosity in "Frankenstein"

    The Creature discovered new thing that people called companionship, and understood that he was alone and nobody cared about him. Every living creature needs a companion in his life. Mary Shelley even started her novel with this idea; Robert Walton wrote to his sister that he needs friend, that ?when

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work