• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"He wasn't just another hero, was he? He was more complicated. Poor Carlo."What is your response to the presentation of Carlo in light of Pelagia's final comment?

Extracts from this document...


"He wasn't just another hero, was he? He was more complicated. Poor Carlo." What is your response to the presentation of Carlo in light of Pelagia's final comment? Carlo Guercio is perhaps one of Louis de Bernieres most complex characters. From the second he is introduced to the novel the reader is presented with a character that breaks stereotypes, asks us to question our morals and indeed evokes a huge amount of emotion within us. In Carlo, de Bernieres presents us with the theme of transformation, "I would know that I was dross which some inscrutable alchemy had transmuted in to gold." It is around these words that I feel the story of Carlo revolves. Carlo Guercio is introduced to us in chapter 4, "L' Omosessuale". It is in this chapter that Carlo begins his journey in the novel. Carlo tells us of him being a homosexual and his reasons for joining the army. Carlo is a character who de Bernieres uses to break the stereotypes of this time. The first being that Carlo is not only homosexual, but that he is a 'giant' as well. A modern day reader might expect a comical and rather camp portrayal of a homosexual character, but feel that de Bernieres specifically chooses to create a serious character out of Carlo in order to make the later portrayal of him all the more poignant. ...read more.


The use of the literary technique is prolific in de Bernieres work. It allows the reader to feel great empathy for a character, it is personal and it seems almost as though you are diving into someone's deepest and darkest thoughts. De Bernieres uses this technique with Carlo to present to the reader the idea that Carlo has two sides, similar to the two sides of a Greek that Dr Iannis tells Captain Corelli about later on in the novel. The first of his two sides is the one presented to fellow army members, the one that Corelli see's and believes to be true. This side is the typical hero, follows orders and acts like a man of war. The second side is the one that appears in the letters that Carlo writes, the 'true' side to Carlo. He is sensitive, scared, has low self-esteem and is homosexual and 'different'. De Bernieres is an incredibly skilled writer and the use of these two sides induces the complex character of Carlo within the confines of the novel. Carlo's character is developed throughout the novel and comes to a climax in chapter 56; "The Good Nazi" This chapter is the one prior to the massacre. ...read more.


In the chapter "Surgery and Obsequy" the reader is shown the return of Carlo's body to the doctor and his daughter. They then bury him in their back garden. The fact that although Carlo is 'technically' and enemy and yet they still choose to bury him with all the dignity they would have given one of their own people shows the love and admiration that people had for Carlo. Carlo is a character evokes emotion and questions our principles; he is honourable, brave, passionate, loving, intelligent and above all a true hero. Although society defined what a hero was, and Carlo didn't really fit the mould, de Bernieres breaks the mould of many ideas using Carlo, so why not this? Carlo is a gigantic gay, a gentle soldier and a kind hero! He doesn't believe in the war, or his leaders but he believes that what he is doing will make himself a better person. He is an admirable character who acquires the admiration of many throughout the novel, and who, in death will be remembered fondly and with great admiration. A hero is defined by the person and not the leader, had Carlo followed the norm he may well have ended up a brutal rapist, however he is a character who defines himself through his actions and through this becomes a true hero. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Authors section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Authors essays

  1. Consider Frayn's presentation of Mrs.Hayward

    Frayn delivers these lines as if to reflect the state of confusion Keith's mother will face in the novel, as if to show she will do something to make this happen, as if it is unexpected. The end words, "'My mother', he said reflectively, almost regretfully, 'is a German spy'" from Keith, adds a tone of suspicion towards Mrs.

  2. In A Passage to India the Marabar Hills and Caves possess a powerful symbolic ...

    The effect that this claim has on the relationships between the British and the Indians in Chandrapore can be compared to the effect that the Amritsar massacre had on the relationship between the two nations. From Forster's narrative, it is clear that both Adela and Mrs.

  1. Analyse Barkers presentation of the love between men in the novel Regeneration.

    As the novel goes on it shows more and more about the discrimination against homosexuality in 1917. In chapter seven Graves tells Sassoon about a homosexual boy who was being sent to a psychiatrist to be 'cured' of his sexuality and this is easy to believe as you get to

  2. Discuss the relationship between Keith and Stephen that is presented in the first Six ...

    He was 'surprised' by Keith's announcement and 'immediately excited' as he could see all possibilities opening up such as investigating, hiding and dressing up in disguise kits but also felt admiring jealousy as it was another demonstration of Keith's 'unending good fortune.'

  1. Janet Frame Towards Another Summer" Chapter 15 Analysis Essay

    Though this abundance of thought may seem harmless, throughout the novel and in this instance also, her almost obsessive thinking and observations juxtaposes with her minimal syntax of speech, for example her reply of "-Yes". This suggests not only social awkwardness, but attributes much to Grace's mental illness, the novel's most pervading theme.

  2. To what extent do the main characters in a Room with a View and ...

    behave in a certain manner especially in the presence of his employer lord Darlington. At the beginning of the novel Stevens seems to believe that only particular convosation primarily his job is appropriate when in lord Darlington's presence, under new employment when lord Faraday tries to banter with Stevens he

  1. There is always another side, always(TM) How does Jean Rhys demonstrate her understanding of ...

    The beginning of the Wide Sargasso Sea, which plunges the reader into the hostile landscape of Jamaica after the Emancipation Act, gives an account of a young Creole girl commenting from the outside. 'They say when trouble comes close ranks, and so the white people did.

  2. In her essay "Flight," Doris Lessing illustrates the story of an old man who ...

    This is disrupted by the appearance of Ralph. The grandfather, mother and child have more than just a blood bond but, that of the loss of his wife and son-in-law, both close to himself and his Grandson. ?Swift? uses imagery with the use of an invisible cord that he uses

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work