• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How are the characters in The Miller(TM)s Tale(TM) punished for their actions and do they deserve this punishment?

Extracts from this document...


How are the characters in 'The Miller's Tale' punished for their actions and do they deserve this punishment? Of all of the major character in 'The Miller's Tale', only Alison is physically unpunished. Each of the other characters - John, Nicholas and Absolon - receives some kind of physical punishment for a flaw in their personalities or a mistake that they make. John receives punishment in the form of a broken arm which he obtains "with the fal". In the middle ages, medicine was nowhere near as developed as today, and broken bones would take a long time to heal. For John, a carpenter, use of his arms is vital to his livelihood, and so this physical punishment is a lot more damaging to him than one might expect. If his arm did heal, he would be out of work for a considerable amount of time. ...read more.


Nicholas' flaw that leads to his punishment is his arrogance. We are first made aware of this trait when Nicholas reassures Alison that he can fool her husband in order to sleep with her - "A clerk hadde litherly biset his while, | But if he koude a carpenter bigile". It is fitting that as a man of sexual appetites who has committed adultery with another man's wife, Nicholas' punishment is presented in quite a sexual way, "amidde the ers". This hints that the Miller considers the punishment to be just, which in turn suggests that the reader should be of this opinion. Absolon is punished for his affected nature, his effeminacy and his squeamishness. It is fitting that his punishments - kissing Alison's "nether ye" and Nicholas breaking wind in his face are made all the more unbearable because of these characteristics, especially his squeamishness. ...read more.


The ending of the tale suggests that all has turned out as it should. The Miller sums up very hastily in five lines, expressing how each of the male characters has been punished. The alacrity of the Miller's conclusion also hints that we are not meant to dwell on the fate of the tale's characters. The tale is not a sermon from which the reader is meant to draw a message or a moral, but it a lewd and bawdy story merely meant to entertain. We are not meant to dwell on whether or not justice has been served because these are not realistic portraits of characters, but merely caricatures. We feel no sympathy for any of them as the Miller has not presented them as complex psychological studies of human nature that we can identify with on a personal level. Instead he uses stock characters that are somewhat two-dimensional to create an engaging and vulgar story. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Geoffrey Chaucer section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Geoffrey Chaucer essays

  1. English society of Chaucer's time

    It is fitting that the Knight, "by cas" (by chance) picks to go first, as he is the highest in the social hierarchy on the trip. Chaucer is saying the choice seems random, but is not. This idea resurfaces throughout the Tales.

  2. To what extent are Nicholas and Absolon courtly lovers?

    not need a man who follows all of the conventions of a courtly lover. Nicholas is shrewd enough to realise this, and he is rewarded in her bed. Absolon, however, enjoys playing the role of a courtly lover, with all of its affectations and conventions, and gets nowhere.

  1. Analysis of lines 125 - 300 of The Merchant's Tale

    he will be unable to see May instructing Damyan to go up the tree. 'I fare as dooth a tree' also shows nature being described as powerful and is a subtle biblical reference to the tree that held the fruit of good and evil in the Garden of Eden.

  2. Is Absolon to be mocked or pitied?

    However most religious people would find this to be a mockery of their faith and be offended by Absolon's attempts. I believe this to be true of his attempts with women, he appears one to make gestures which he finds to be magnificent and grand, however I believe that his attempts would repulse women.

  1. Quotes from the Miller's Tale

    kissed he kiste her naked ers Ful savourly" p50 Emphasises scatological humour and change in Absalom in romance kiss was a powerful symbol and transforms eg Loathly Lady in authurain legends "Froteth his lippes With dust, with sond,with straw,with clooth,with chippes"p50 Shows him going into crisis the length of the

  2. Explore your relationship with the wife of bath

    Although I think that the wife is being clever by being able to manipulate her husbands, I feel that she is also being cruel and heartless by giving them grief just so she can get what she wants.

  1. Select two or three portraits from the General Prologue and discuss Chaucer's use of ...

    A prioress usually came form a upper class family, but even so this Prioress is over concerned with manners - even though the narrator seems to admire her upper class manners-, and by describing them at length her preoccupation which appearing upper-class makes her almost laughable; from her fake French accent through to her nasal singing.

  2. How appropriate is it that the character of the Pardoner tells the tale?

    It is ironic that the Pardoner, a member of the clergy, is so morally blind. He is the only person that is expected to be truly good. This could suggest that the pilgrims are naive and mindless to not realise how morally unjust he is.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work