• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

how cogent is the english language system?

Extracts from this document...


How cogent is the argument for changing the English Language spelling system? In this essay I will be studying the irregularities of the English language spelling system and give critical information of the problems. Also I will display obstacles within the language and display the difficulties of learning the language, whether being a toddler or a foreign learner. I will provide an in depth analysis of the spelling system and give examples of people who have attempted to change the system in the past. There are many arguments for the change of the English spelling system. However other people disagree with the change due to cultural reasons and the sheer disruption to an already educated person. The reasons for people wanting to change the system include the very poor phonemic content and the extreme foreign influence from other languages all over the world. One of the problems of the spelling system includes the phonetic content. . This can create a large learning barrier for one learning the language. Many words have silent letters and collections of letters to mean one sound. For example rough, though and thought all have the same letter combination but different sounds are made. ...read more.


Some people in the past have attempted to reform the system, however they weren't successful. Examples include Harry Lindgren who thought of the idea to amend the vowel sound. In 1969 he stated that the vowel sound in 'bed' is always spelt just <e>, giving 'meny', 'frend', 'lepard', 'hefer', 'gess', 'hemorrhage', 'hed', 'thret' and 'mesure' for example. This reform would only cause minor changes on a piece of text. The 'cut spelling act' in 1992 explained that misleading letters were cut out and shortening text by up to 10%. For example the new method would be written like this: 'cut spelling leves out most silent letrs. Another reformation attempt was in 1948. It aimed at total regularity but changes the look of language more radically, as here: 'In nue speling wurdz which sound aliek wood noe longger be distinggwishabl.' If we were to change the English spelling system several positive and negative factors would transpire. Initially the positive impacts would be that young learners of the language (3-6 years old) would benefit, as they will have a more systematic system by using phonetics to spell and following the phonetic alphabet. Also in order to make an impact on toddlers learning the language the best way is to introduce the new system as early into their academic start. ...read more.


I understand the low literacy levels in Great Britain but I think that this will increase literacy levels among the older generation and result in confusion. The argument for changing the system is strong in some ways but not in others. Changing the system would dramatically improve children's skill of reading and writing and make words easier to write and say. But there is the already educated people who will most certainly disagree to the change as they have completed their education and will not want to 'be at school' again. Also there will be an economical impact for the worse, as money will be given out to re-train teaching staff and the production of new reading and writing aids. The English culture may be diminished, the rapid change of words and letters (if phonetic symbols were introduced). Ultimately the change, in my point of view, is an enormous risk to take and will create confusion among the population. As you can see the negative points out-weigh the positive ones in this piece and therefore I believe that the change is definitely the wrong choice to make. I think the alternative would be to teach only the subject English until the age of four or five. Consequently the argument for changing the English spelling system is unquestionably not cogent. Blakesley Orr ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Investigating how language has changed in children's literature; in relation to interaction between ...

    5 star(s)

    The word 'vexed' in the place of 'angry' or 'unhappy' in School Girl Chums is a phrase which is more or less completely out of use today, and much of the language in "Cynthia's" and her friend's vocabulary fits with a stereotypical image of girls at private boarding schools, for

  2. How do Politicians gain support through language? AQA English coursework

    where all succeed equally - that is utopia; but an opportunity society where all have an equal chance to succeed; that could and should be 21st century Britain under a Labour Government." The relative subordinate clause "that could and should be 21st century Britain under a Labour Government" acts as

  1. Overcoming Culture Shock as a foreign student in the UK

    I have divided the whole process of research into 4 main parts. The first part was the most crucial one, because it was the most time consuming. It was the process of question designing. I needed to concentrate on culture related questions, because I did not want to hurt the interviewees by any of them.

  2. Early and Later Wittgenstein's conception of the world, ethics and later analysis of language.

    The critical point to realize is that for Sankara the Real is life, human life, as lived. This is what we count on in order to be conscious. The rest is imagination; all we can do with the rest is interpretation.

  1. Do you detect any general trend or trends in the pattern of English politics ...

    in a position to revoke a grant of land by the King Egbert of Kent;16 Wiglaf could grant land in Worcestershire;17 and Brihtwulf could do the same in Berkshire.18 This charter evidence is very important: it demonstrates that the kings of Mercia in this period claimed authority over other southern

  2. How Has English changed as a result of contact with other languages? What other ...

    The next major influence was a Danish one, from AD.787 until the 11th Century. The Danelaw boundary was worked out with King Alfred which saw co-operative trading and then 25 years of Danish rule from AD.991. The result was settlements with Danish names.

  1. The Influence of English Mass Culture on Estonia

    We should not be swayed by claims like - 'My country is right', 'My people are the greatest in history,' and 'My faith is the only true faith'. Who can legitimately speak for a particular culture? Whose voice counts? In whose name is the dialogue conducted?

  2. Language Change.

    A very few nouns - for example, ox, oxen - have plurals ending in -en. A few noun forms are unchanged in the plural: deer, sheep, moose and grouse. * Five of the seven personal pronouns have inflected forms for subject or object use: I, me; he, him; she, her; we, us and they, them.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work