• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does Anthony and Cleopatra present the contrast between the conquering west and the decadent east?

Extracts from this document...


Antony and Cleopatra Q: Shakespeare used as his source for this play north's translation of Plutarch's "Lives of the noble Grecians and Romans". Plutarch, along with other Greek and Roman authors saw an opposition between the conquering West, standing for moral and political virtue, and the conquering East representing luxury and decadence. How does Shakespeare's play present these oppositions? Shakespeare was deeply concerned with the meanings of the classical past. His play Antony and Cleopatra concerns itself with a major theme from Renaissance culture: The importance and continued thriving of Europe's Graeco-Roman culture. Yet in one sense, Shakespeare rebelled against the traditional portrayal of Rome by the narrator of his source Plutarch and his contempories. Whilst imperial historians and medieval poets like Chaucer shared Plutarch's view that glorified Rome, both as a virtuous political power and as a morally legitimate empire, Shakespeare refused to see Rome's motives as wholly honourable. He emphasised the themes of the decline of virtue and the pursuit of honour, which represent satirical work of the highest degree. Therefore this play cannot really be read as a propaganda piece for Western domination. On the other hand, Plutarch and his contempories saw the East as the manifestation of all that was extravagant and ostentatious; a place of desire and decadence infinitely inferior to the Roman empire and it's adherents, morally and even racially. However Plutarch, in his portrait of Cleopatra, stresses the East's ability to attract and does not underestimate it's witty skill to enchant. ...read more.


For example, when Plutarch documented that Octavius Caesar enjoyed sports and fishing as well having a weakness for women, Shakespeare probably found that his presentation of Rome as a rigid, stoic and disciplined culture would be faulty. Thus he conveniently leaves out this detail to enhance Caesar's image of a censorious, cold and abstemious character, whose primary aim is to serve Rome. Another extract from Plutarch that Shakespeare decided to do without is the one where Cleopatra is claimed to have demanded that of Antony not to send Enobarbarus' treasure after him. Shakespeare seems to want us to sympathise with the Queen and her culture and probably knew that this act would cause his Cleopatra to lose any admiration or appreciation she had aroused so far in the play. It might also have affected our interpretation of her oncoming suicide negatively. Including this detail would be allowing Roman virtues to triumph over Egyptian ones, something Shakespeare seemed to have vowed not to do before writing the play. In Antony and Cleopatra we find ourselves in the presence of grandiose personalities whose behaviour dismays or distresses us. Yet it is this characterisation that provides a vivid representation of the two antithetical cultures. Those who inhabit them characterize Western and Eastern poles. Octavius Caesar embodies the stoic duty of the west and is sometimes seen as the equivalent of James I of Shakespeare's own time. ...read more.


Shakespeare uses language to highlight the differences between Rome and Egypt. Act two scene five accurately reflects life in Egypt; one that is concerned with play " let's to Billiards" "put my Tires and Mantles on him, whilst I wore his Sword Philippan", pranks: "Did hang a salt Fish on his Hook, which he With fervency drew up", and Passion "Music, moody Food Of us that trade in Love" Shakespeare uses dramatic irony to cause the audience to anticipate Cleopatra's reaction to Antony's marriage with Octavia. Her theatrically manifests itself in her use of hyperbole and phrases that are rife with strong passionate imagery "Ram thou thy Fruitful Tidings in my Ears, That long time have been Barren" she says to the messenger, then "I'll set thee in a Shower of Gold, and hail Rich Pearls upon thee" If he tells her Antony is well, concluding with " The most infectious Pestilence upon thee" "...horrible Villain, or I'll spurn thine Eyes Like Balls before me; I'll unhair thy Head. Thou shalt be whipp'd with Wire, and stew'd in Brine, Smarting in ling'ring Pickle." When she discovers the truth of his mission. To conclude, Shakespeare organises the plot of Antony and Cleopatra around the struggle between East and West, which is not only between two geographically distinct empires but also between two diametrically opposed worldviews, by using all his literary tools to transform this historic story to a "divine comedy". ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Antony and Cleopatra section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Antony and Cleopatra essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Compare and contest the differing perspectives of Anthony and Cleopatra in act one.In your ...

    3 star(s)

    in love with her and has to be reminded of his mission. He then does the Roman thing and leaves for Italy to find the city Latium, which is to become the parent city of Rome itself. It is easy to see how Shakespeare has consumed information from all the

  2. How does Shakespeare use his contrast between Rome and Egypt to present the themes ...

    This is very effective as it shows what is happening in both countries. Antony and Caesar then sort pout their differences and it ends with Rome being happy. Shakespeare quickly switches the love and hate around so that love is in Rome and hate in is Egypt.

  1. Essentially Antony and Cleopatra is a story of power politics; its theme is not ...

    Mark Antony and Caesar also neglect the interests of Rome; they do not want another soldier eclipsing their glory. Ventidius is conscious of the fact that 'when him we serve's away', a soldier must not achieve too much, because the triumvirs will be unable to take the credit for it themselves.

  2. How does Shakespeare present the characters of Anthony and Cleopatra in act oneand how ...

    A good example of this is in scene one when Philo a Roman speaks of Cleopatra, 'the office and devotion of their view. Upon a tawny front'.

  1. Analysis of scene one - Antony and Cleopatra

    The battle is not merely between two geographically distinct empires but also between two diametrically opposed worldviews. As Philo and Demetrius lament Antony's decline, claiming that his "captain's heart" now serves as "the bellows and the fan / To cool a gipsy's lust," they illustrate a divide between a world

  2. Examine the contrast between Cleopatra and Octavia. How do they embody different aspects of ...

    we understand from the differences between Egypt and Rome and their understandings of each other, that Cleopatra embodies Egypt and all it stands for and so can't be controlled or categorised as a Roman can be. Cleopatra allows men who have grown up in a world where expressing sexual ideas

  1. Explore how Shakespeare develops the themes of duty

    his former Roman ideals and his new Egyptian way of thinking become clearer, his first line to Cleopatra as he enters the stage is "There's beggary in the love that can be reckoned", implying that his love for her is immeasurable and takes precedence above all, the fact this is

  2. Explore Shakespeare's presentation of Cleopatra in Antony and Cleopatra

    But to view Cleopatra as such is to reduce her character to the rather narrow perspective of the Romans, who, standing to lose their honour or kingdoms through her agency, are greatly threatened by her. Certainly this threat has much to do with Cleopatra's beauty and open sexuality, which, as

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work