• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How does the Requiem reflect the elements of tragedy explored within Death of a Salesman?

Extracts from this document...


How does the Requiem reflect the elements of tragedy explored within Death of a Salesman? In 1949; whilst America saw the culmination of anti-communist feelings, fear of the unknown and the general hysteria which stemmed from the Cold War against Russia; playwright Arthur Miller published what was seen to be a personal criticism of the American way of life, his play, "Death of A Salesman". Death of A Salesman tells the story of Willy Loman, a lowly salesman slowly being estranged from society and increasingly led into confusion by his attempts to escape his own failure brought about by the great American Dream he has served so loyally. It was for this play Miller was brought in front of HUAC (house un-American activities committee) and charged with undermining American Values. Miller defended himself by claiming he simply aspired to "show the truth as [he] saw it". It is because Miller insisted on adhering to realism, that he chose a normal, "Loman", or literally, low man, to be his Tragic Hero. In doing so, Miller broke one rule- that of Aristotelian tragedy, which demands a "noble" hero, of high birth; and simultaneously abided by another, the rule of a Modern Domestic Tragedy which requires an ordinary person's story to be told. ...read more.


It is perhaps important to consider the role of 'ghosts' or past figures which appear throughout the play. Ghosts and figures from the past litter tragedy throughout the centuries. Indeed, the oldest surviving complete tragedy, Aeschylus's Persians (472 BC) features the ghost of the dead King Darius returning from the past to cast judgement over his son Xerxes, whom he deems to be failing in his role and pursuing the wrong dreams. This is not unlike the mocking presence of Willy's own father and his brother Ben, both deceased who continue to taunt Willy with dreams he cannot achieve. Willy's suicide is at once self-congratulating, misguided and selfless. He wants to escape the feeling he is "temporary" by truly leaving something behind, "something one can feel with the hand". This something is his "diamond" of the $20,000 insurance money, which will make him a "hero" for Biff to "worship" and helping Biff to start up a business of his own. Requiem holds no answers as to whether the premium was paid and through this and the melancholy despair that runs through the final scene, Miller shows how pointless Willy's death truly was. No matter how much money he leaves behind, it will never compensate for the loss the family has to endure. ...read more.


Everything reverting back to the way the play started shows how insignificant Willy's death really is. Capitalism does not crumble, life goes on. It is here that I believe Modern Domestic Tragedies are flawed, where Shakespearian ones are not. When Macbeth dies, the audience is certain that his Kingdom will mourn his loss, however warped he was, he was still their King. There will be a "massive" funeral, of the sorts Willy dreams of, and a Kingdom-wide expression of collective grief. It is this grief that I believe provides the catharsis of emotion for the audience, they know his death will continue to be felt after they leave the theatre and this assurance brings closure. This closure however, does not exist in Modern Domestic Tragedies. Willy's death will go unnoticed by most, and this does not bring significant catharsis to the audience. There is no final completion of raw emotion. To support my view I can only offer the words of Shakespeare himself, "The poor beetle on which we tread In corporal sufferance feels a pang as great As when a Giant dies." Or in other words, an ignoble death such as Willy's is just as pitiful as those of Shakespeare's noble giants and therefore I feel robbed of a glorious ending for Willy which would lift him to the level of Kings, as unfitting as it may be. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a star student thought of this essay

3 star(s)

Response to the question

This essay only begins to respond to the question half way through! When the question is specifically asking you about a scene in a play, you must begin your argument there, and then use other parts of the play to ...

Read full review

Response to the question

This essay only begins to respond to the question half way through! When the question is specifically asking you about a scene in a play, you must begin your argument there, and then use other parts of the play to back up any points formed. I would be wary of starting an essay on the whole play being a tragedy when the question is so specific. When the essay begins to look at the Requiem, there is some good discussion. Looking at irony and the cyclical nature of Willy's death are great ways to explore tragedy, but this needs to be taken further to discuss how the audience respond to this.

Level of analysis

The analysis here has potential. Comments such as "However, a few critics complain that Willy cannot be a tragic hero" are good, but I would note you should be careful not to give a balanced argument. It is much stronger at A-Level to acknowledge the counter-argument, and then explain why it is weaker than your argument. The paragraph on irony is strong, looking at the connotations of language used, but I would've liked slightly more focus on the tragedy of Willy. If I were doing this essay, I would've linked "Happy will continue to pursue it" to the helplessness of the audience to prevent Happy's similar downfall, showing the power of the American Dream in causing a tragic downfall. Catharsis is explained well, and this is a high level concept examiners will be pleased to see explored.

Quality of writing

This essay has an awful structure. As mentioned above, it doesn't really engage with the question until a few paragraphs in. The introduction is exactly what examiners don't want to see: a group of irrelevant contextual points with a short plot summary and no engagement with the task. Similarly, ending with a Shakespeare quote does nothing to your argument. In fact, it probably worsens your argument as you have lost the opportunity to end with a insightful conclusion. There are times where this essay uses the first person, and I would advise against this. A personal tone is not appropriate for A-Level, and it weakens your argument as it makes your views seem more personal rather than backed by evidence and analysis.

Did you find this review helpful? Join our team of reviewers and help other students learn

Reviewed by groat 29/06/2012

Read less
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Arthur Miller essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    To what extent is Willy Loman a tragic hero?

    3 star(s)

    Willy's constant reluctance to live in the present is another cause for his demise and the fact that he does not learn from his mistakes which ultimately makes him a tragic hero. He never comes to terms with reality and appears to live in the past which is what clouds his judgement in the present.

  2. Biff (of his father): He had the wrong dreams. All, all, wrong. Discuss Biff's ...

    in part motivated by the fact that Willy knew nothing of and received nothing from his father. However, Willy's decision to make his family "rich" through his death and the insurance money is a wrong dream; he does not let go of his fantasy and face his failures as a salesman, husband and father.

  1. Character Analysis - Willy Loman

    He says that "Someday I'll have my own business". This is a little ironic, as we know that this does not happen, and he does actually become less successful. We are then told the basis of Willy's belief of what makes a man successful. He uses the example of Charley to show this.

  2. How does Millers handling of time and memory add to our understanding of tragedy ...

    Disorder and order are part of Aristotelian convention: the fact that in a tragedy, disorder is after the catastrophe, yet order will try to be maintained (e.g. in Othello, Lodovico will try to maintain order in society after the death of the moor).

  1. "Willy is a good father and husband. Do you agree?"

    Although the latter points direct us to show Willy as a good father the bad points drag this view down. It is clearly seen that Willy favours Biff over Happy during his flashbacks to when his sons were teenagers, Happy-"I'm losing weight, you notice, Pop?"

  2. To What Extent Does Death of a Salesman deal with modern issues such as ...

    Biff inherits his father's idealistic view of the 'American Dream' owing to his being fed Willy's opinions. Happy calls Biff a "poet and "idealist" as he reveals his desire to live and work with nature, just like his father had.

  1. Willy's First Flashback (Death of a Salesman)

    He tells Linda just shortly afterwards: 'They seem to laugh at me...I'm not noticed...I talk too much...I'm fat...' � See other examples. There are many!! What qualities define success for Willy? � Being 'well-liked' � Being masculine - having physical strength and good looks, excelling in sport...

  2. Miller presents Will Loman as a failure in many aspects of his life. To ...

    again in his mind, and it is his failure to let go, his failure to realise that he already has what he needs to be happy - a loving wife, children, his own house and car - that, in Linda's words, he's "doing well enough", which underpins his failure as

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work