• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far and in what ways do the opening three scenes constitute a suitably problematic opening to Measure for Measure?

Extracts from this document...


How far and in what ways do the opening three scenes constitute a suitably problematic opening to Measure for Measure? Measure for Measure as a play is deeply renowned for being a' problem play"; that is to say, there are many unresolved items and unanswered questions throughout. Therefore in order to make the opening 'suitable ' for a play of this calibre, the opening must also be 'suitably problematic" in order to pique the audience's interest sufficiently to ensure that they will be just as intrigued by the rest of the play as they are by the beginning. The play's moral dilemma mainly concerns the Duke, who can be seen as manipulating others' lives without the slightest bit of regard for the consequences. It is unsure how we are meant to consider him, because even after these initial scenes enough doubt has already been raised about his motives to make the audience rather suspicious. In this play, the first three scenes contain just as many, if not more unanswered scenarios, which help to ensure that the play commences as it means to go on, and hints at the events to follow. At the start of Act 1 Scene 1, due to it being the very first scene, you would think that the play would have a clearly defined beginning, so that the audience are able to be fully aware of all the events taking place, and to a certain extent be totally omniscient of what is happening. ...read more.


Of course, the Duke is the one who makes the main decision, and regardless of what Escalus' opinion is, the Duke is the one who controls the entire situation. In this circumstance, his motives are deeply ambiguous, as they are indeed even in the rest of the play. It is confusing why he chooses to disguise himself as a friar, since at the time of the play being performed, Catholics were not usually trusted at all, let alone with the inner workings of someone's life. However here Catholicism is referred to throughout; whether it is because Isabella is a Catholic nun of one of the strictest orders, or because of marriage (which is another suitably problematic issue on its own), nonetheless it is a key fragment of the play's content. In Scene 2, we come across for the first time some of the examples which prove the existence of Vienna's underworld. Lucio, Pompey and the other Gentlemen are prime examples of this; however it is truly unclear as to what the audience are meant to think of them. By all means, they do use such coarse expressions as would be expected to be heard from the worst characters, such as "French crown" referring of course to syphilis. By the mentions of sexual diseases, the audience therefore presume them to be the negative characters of the play; however it is unclear as to whether all morally ambiguous behaviour should also be condemned. ...read more.


This is rather problematic because the audience is more used to the characters' motives being clear-cut and easy to understand, unlike Isabella's complex multi-layered personality. This is a problem play, but it can be seen that the characters being unable to be understood in one step too far from just the events of the play being problematic. Measure for Measure is a Shakespearian problem play, which sharply addresses some of the issues of the law of the day when it came to the balance between justice and mercy, or the attitudes towards non-witnessed marriage. However this play takes it one step further than there simply being difficulties to overcome; most of the play's background is in fact completely unknown. Whole conversations, except for their conclusions, are omitted, characters are not clearly described, reasons for peoples' actions are unknown, and even motives are unclear. However when these three scenes are put in context with the rest of the play, it goes from being overly problematic to in fact just suitably so. The issues raised here are not created just to confuse the audience, but to provoke a well thought out mental response from them, prompted by the characters' opinions. These problems are referred to constantly throughout the play, and help to give it the conclusion that it has; not completely resolved of course, but as much as could be expected from such a problematical play. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Measure for Measure section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Measure for Measure essays

  1. Discuss the theme of deception and disguise in the play "Measure for Measure."

    In Measure for Measure, Mistress Overdone walks around freely and it is common knowledge she runs a brothel and that it is very popular. The image of the "baby beats the nurse" makes another comparison with an unnatural situation as an indication of how far out of hand the situation in Vienna really is.

  2. "Measure for Measure is a play without any truly sympathetic characters". To what extent ...

    These actions could be perceived as contributing to a sympathetic character, but his second appearance in Act one, scene three of the play gives cause to the audience to probe further in to his actions, indeed one of the purposes of a problem play, but something which arguably detracts from

  1. Presentation of Escalus in Measure for Measure

    He asks the provost to "furnish (him) with divines and have all charitable preparation" (pg 61). If Claudio's fate were left to Escalus, his choice would be to let him free, showing Angelo to be a very stringent and cold-hearted character in comparison.

  2. Consider Act II of "Measure for Measure", with regard to ideas of Justice and ...

    It does take Isabella some time to get to this point in the scene since she begins rather hesitantly giving in almost saying things like "Just but severe law", saying that she believes that justice should prevail agreeing and resigning, only taking up the lance once again when Lucio beckons her to do so.

  1. The principalcharacters in 'Measure for Measure' are motivated by personal gain.' How far would ...

    Indeed the Duke advocates this opinion later, when trying to convince Mariana to sleep with Angelo. Perhaps Claudio is overstating this to try and convince Isabella, but his appraisal at this point seems more rational and Isabella's reaction seems like just a knee-jerk reaction to a distasteful proposal.

  2. What do you find dramatically interesting about Shakespeare's presentation of the Duke in the ...

    The Duke is truly seen as a opinionated figure because would lower himself to any means to achieve the desired outcome. At the end of the scene there is a turning point in the character of the Duke, the observer plays an active role in this scene as we see more then we are told.

  1. Consider the Attitudes To Women Demonstrated In the Vienna of Measure For Measure.

    He fails to see that this is not only Isabella clinging onto her 'eternal life' but also that this is her bid for independence. The strength of her female character is indicated in Act II Scene iv where she delivers the only female soliloquy in the play: Isabella: To whom should I complain?

  2. More than our brother is our chastity How far do you find yourself able ...

    For instance, in Act 2 Scene 2, Isabella's dialogue with Angelo expresses her quality of mercy, as although Claudio's sexual transgression is "a vice that I do most abhor", Isabella argues that Angelo "might pardon him, / And neither heaven nor man grieve at the mercy."

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work