• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"How far do you agree that we are moved to sympathy, even to admiration, by Richard's journey to awareness?"

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"How far do you agree that we are moved to sympathy, even to admiration, by Richard's journey to awareness?" Because King Richard is the eponymous character of this play, it is his emotional journey which readers follow in details. Through the play, numerous traits of his personality are clearly exposed, giving readers plenty of evidence on which to form opinions. In the opening scene of the play, Richard at first comes across as an authoritative ruler, with full control over the situation and an evident sense of fairness and justice. This gives readers scope to feel admiration for him, because he is apparently displaying vital qualities in a good monarch. However, it is not long before Richard slips up and allows his weakness to be exposed. After regally announcing, "We were not born to serve, but to command", he immediately falters and adds "Which since we cannot do..." This shows from the beginning that Richard is not a king capable of impressing us with authority and strength of mind, which I found to weaken the chance of me admiring him. ...read more.

Middle

I cannot, however, feel admiration for Richard. The way in which he hands over his reign, with no logical reasoning, is enough to make me see him as clueless, overreacting, and not in control of his own mind, let alone a country. The quick changes of emotional outlook, for example when he moves from hopelessly speaking of "the deaths of kings" to announcing his divine rights and believing himself to be capable of anything, make him appear over-the-top, false, and insincere in his apparent strong emotions. In the director Mark Rylance's interpretation of the play, he played Richard as a dithering idiot, encouraging the audience to laugh at him like an indecisive child. While many viewers and critics of this performance disapprove of this characterisation, I thought it was effective in making us realise how hopeless, lacking in authority, and frankly idiotic Richard acts in various scenes of the play. In Act V, Richard's soliloquy while locked up alone, stripped of all power, should have the potential to make readers feel sympathy for him. ...read more.

Conclusion

Shakespeare would have written this play to be performed before Queen Elizabeth I, not only as an educational history lesson but most likely also as a lesson in successful monarchy. His portrayal of a king would have shown her how NOT to act as a reigning monarch. Richard is easily defeated, confused by reality, and all too often wallowing in self-pity. Ultimately, Richard is only human, and his vulnerability makes it impossible for me not to feel a certain amount of pity for him, at times. Therefore I agree that his journey moves readers to sympathy. However, as well as being a human, he is also a ruler of a country, which should make him authoritative, confident and in control. In my opinion he is none of these. A fool with no grasp of reality is dangerous when given power. Richard has too many weaknesses and flaws which are revealed in this play, traits which do not provoke respect. Therefore I cannot agree that I am moved as far as admiration for Richard. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Richard II section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Richard II essays

  1. Explore Shakespeare's presentation of Kingship in Richard II

    draw the audience's attention to the relationship between being "royal" and having "noble blood". Richard's comment "let's purge without blood" also suggests his keenness to prevent some sort of conflict between him and Bolingbroke. This could be interpreted as showing his pacifistic side as demonstrated in the scene of the

  2. Richard II. John of Gaunts patriotic assault on the unpopular Richard would appeal greatly ...

    These are Richard's first words as he enters the room and thus it has a profound effect. Richard's popularity in the eyes of the audience is repeatedly dealt heavy blows by the words of Gaunt. He implies that Richard doesn't care about England and is not good enough for "this other Eden".

  1. What do we learn of the motivations & characters of both Richard & Clarence ...

    the sea (lines 16-19), the theme of prophecies or dramatic ironies has been repeated here, and was introduced in the previous scene with Queen Margaret. Both Queen Margaret and Clarence hold the "truth" of the play, and they are expressed in the form of prophecies, this nightmare itself serves as another witness to Clarence's virtue by seeming clairvoyance.

  2. How does Shakespeare portray the character of Richard?

    of London that helped people know his location and subsequently help them plot Richards death, "They love not poison that do poison need, nor do I thee: though I did wish him dead, I hate the murderer, love him murdered.

  1. Write about the dramatic methods used by Shakespeare to portray the character of Queen ...

    the effect this ordeal has on those close to him, but mainly acts as a visual reminder of Richard's fallen state. This is of significant relevance to Isabel in that it gives rise to her next speech which proves to reveal a lot more in terms of Shakespeare's intentions for Isabel's character and her contribution to the play.

  2. Power and Betrayal in Shakespears Power and Betrayal.

    of heart To his most royal person, hither come Even at his feet to lay my arms and power, Provided that my banishment repealed And lands restored again be freely granted.

  1. RICHARD II KEY LITERARY ELEMENTS SETTING Richard II is located in ...

    When his involvement in the conspiracy against Bolingbroke becomes known to his father, he gallops to London at the pleading of his mother to beg forgiveness before York can accuse him. Queen Isabel - The Queen stands on the periphery of events and appears only four times in the play.

  2. 'Richard II' by William Shakespeare

    If Richard was balanced and listened to the wise advice from Gaunt and York, he would have certainly kept his crown after this episode.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work