• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far would you agree that Desdemona is established as a tragic victim in Act 4 scene 3?

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Olivia Clinton How far would you agree that Desdemona is established as a tragic victim in Act 4 scene 3? In 4.3 Desdemona is sent to bed by Othello with the instructions to dismiss Emilia and wait for his arrival. Desdemona is depicted by Shakespeare as both passive by being naive and also strong minded by being able to go against her father and make her own decisions. There is no doubt that Desdemona is a victim in ?Othello?, but whether she is a tragic victim is a matter of contention. In the scene, the brief appearance of Lodovico presents Desdemona with the type of man that she could have been happy and content with, and not endured the hardships she has suffered with Othello. Emilia and Desdemona have an age-old gossip about the ?very handsome man?[1] and Emilia knows ?a lady in Venice that would have walked barefoot to Palestine// for a touch of his nether lip.?[2] This suggests that a woman would do anything for this man. Because she specifies ?lady? the woman could be a lady of high status. It also highlights that Desdemona is almost a fool for disregarding Lodovico and marrying an ?improper? man; a black moor, Othello. ...read more.


A.C Bradley believes that ?He is to save Desdemona from herself, not in hate but in honour; in honour, and also in love?.[6] The two contrasting sides of Desdemona, the virtuous, gratifying, naive and angelic versus the confident and strong minded create the sense that she is not capable of such a controversial marriage. Throughout the scene, Shakespeare has created foreshadowing in Desdemona?s speech, an example being ?The Willow song?[7], a song sung by her mother?s maid, Barbary, whose lover had been proved ?mad? and she had died singing the song. Shakespeare makes the audience know that her death is soon as Desdemona tells Emilia that the song ?Will not go from my mind?. Desdemona and Barbary are in ways, very similar. Like Barbary, Desdemona is in love, and her husband, though not "mad," is insanely jealous and has emotionally forsaken Desdemona. Presumably, Barbary died of a broken heart while singing ?the willow song?, Desdemona will die at the hands of her love soon after she sings the same song. Desdemona's thoughts create a sense of foreboding, but she many not have any idea that she is about to die. She's depressed by losing Othello's love, and so the song comes into her head. ...read more.


Victor Hugo makes the point that ?To kill is to lull to sleep. ? And it is thus that Desdemona, spouse of the man Night, dies, stifled by the pillow upon which the first kiss was given, and which receives the last sigh.?[11] This highlights the dramatic irony that Desdemona is to be killed in the bed that she started her married life in, by the man she gave her life to. Hugo is almost leading us to believe that Othello?s method of murder is thoughtful and kind to Desdemona by suggesting that the killing is to ?lull to sleep?, and not a revengeful, gruesome death. Desdemona?s enduring love and unwillingness to defend herself with an argument she is easily capable of, is her tragic flaw, leading to her ultimate downfall. Desdemona is perceived by Shakespeare as a perfect woman but also as ironically foolish. Her undeniably great love for Othello, pulls the wool over her eyes to what is really happening around her; the every growing jealousy of Othello. She threatens her life by wanting to please, him but in a male dominated society, she is a victim of bitter lies and domination. Although she can?t help being a woman, there were many opportunities to defend herself against the prejudices. I believe that Desdemona is not a tragic victim because if she used her good judgment, which she undoubtedly has, she could have avoided Othello using the last resort to silence her. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Othello section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Othello essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Male Domination In Othello

    4 star(s)

    This is clearly the case for the fact that he could say it while talking to her father. Desdemona on the other hand, like almost every other woman in the Elizabethan period seems to have accepted the convention that women are inferior to men and are the properties of either her father or husband.

  2. How far do we see different attitudes to love presented in Othello?

    Moreover, any arguments that he makes about the relationships between Cassio, Desdemona and Othello are all full of the assumption that love is but carnal. He predicts that Othello's and Desdemona's love for each other will in time break down because they would be sick of each other's bodies: "It

  1. ACT IV-SCENE III- close analysis+ focus on Desdemona and Emilias contrasting views of marriage. ...

    by making the audience fully aware that Desdemona predicts her own demise and yet does not act upon this suspicion merely accepts it. Desdemona is submissive to the point she appears to think it treacherous to forge her own fate and will instead, quite literally as we find out later,

  2. Othello Act 4 Scene 3

    She feels abandoned as she sings and is aware of her impending death. This shows Desdemona as tragic as she knows what is going to happen inevitably however she still does not know why. The 'Willow song' is a dramatic device as willows symbolise disappointed love, which is exactly what she is experiencing.

  1. Explore the ways in which Shakespeare the character Othello, his relationship with Desdemona and ...

    This flaw allows space for Iago?s deceptions. He is obviously a bad choice of character, saying that ?Iago is most honest? (II.iii.7). This is ironic because Iago is anything but honest, and the audience knows this. Othello throughout the play makes ironic statements about Iago similar, such as ?I know, Iago, Thy honesty and love doth mince this matter? (II.III.251-52)

  2. With particular reference to Act one, scene III, discuss how Othellos tragic and heroic ...

    Even the senator refers to him as the ?valient moor?. Othello has many heroic and admirable qualities; he is in the army and a general, he is perceived to be very brave and consequently won Desdemona over with his tales of battle and bravery.

  1. Othellos jealousy and the speed at which it develops are absurd. How far do ...

    This quotation shows irony as Othello is denying that he will let himself be destroyed by jealousy yet although he is unable to see this, Iago is encouraging him to be jealous and convincing him into breaking his relationship with Desdemona.

  2. A tragic play centres on peripeteia. To what extent can Act 3 scene 3 ...

    This is a great contributor to the tragic outcome because it is Othello?s naivety and ability to trust others easily that makes him susceptible to being manipulated. Othello has great trust in Iago and values his opinions and thoughts. He constantly asks him to reveal them: ?What dost thou think??[4]

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work