• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

However, 'The Drum' does demonstrate an extremely similar view of war to that conveyed by Owen in 'The Send-off'. Both depict strong anti-war attitudes, presenting their respective ideas about the wasteful sacrifice

Extracts from this document...


Section A Basing your answer on Extract A and Extract E, you should: * Write a comparison of the ways the writers present ideas about slaughter and sacrifice * Say how far you agree with the view that Scott's poem is more effective than Owen's in communicating its message. The subject of War is one that rouses many varying attitudes amongst writers, which is evident through their respective compositions of literature. Throughout the duration of World War I, many soldiers who originally harboured enthusiasm towards the notion of fighting for one's country to attain honour became incredibly cynical and satirical of the war. One such writer was Wilfred Owen, writer of 'The Send-off'. Owen joined up in the First World War, as many did, with a view that had been manipulated by the propaganda portrayed by the media of the time. Thus, he was keen to fight to defend his country in order to obtain glory. However, he soon formed his own opinion of the reality of War and became bitter and angry towards the depiction of war conveyed by the media on the home front, and those supporting it. ...read more.


For instance, the final stanza consisting of, 'May creep back, silent, to village wells Up half-known roads' speaks of the harsh reality that only few soldiers, if any will return from the war, and that those who do, will merely be shadows of their former selves, and thus the places they return to will not seem the same to them. The shrill implication of this stanza is aided by the reversed rhyme from the stanza preceding it, in addition to the pause that is induced before it. Thus, Owen and Scott demonstrate how fundamental facets of poetry can be utilised to achieve differing effects. Both Owen and Scott convey developing, well structured arguments throughout their poems, rather than displaying an undeveloped attitude. Scott manages this incredibly effectively by inducing a change of tone between stanzas. His first stanza conveys how the 'drum's discordant sound' appeals to the na�ve 'thoughtless' young men, to whom the media pleaded to join up. Certain aspects of the language in this stanza strongly exhibit Scott's unequivocal cynicism towards the common act of glorifying war and the act of fighting for one's country. ...read more.


a futile War, is clearly conveyed, in conjunction with the fact that these men didn't speak of the terrors they knew they were about to encounter. The development of Owen's argument leads him to talk of his belief that, once they have gone, their 'grimly gay' faces the last thing seen of them by those at home, only a few, if any will return, '...too few for drums and yells'. Both poets speak extremely effectively of the waste of War, exhibiting cynicism towards the attitudes of those who have not first hand experience of its terror, and therefore do not know of the true brutality of it. Whilst these poets convey similar anti-war attitudes through their poems, I believe that the original form and structure of Owen's poem, in conjunction with the effective use of language and systematic development of his argument, results in a greater impact being made on the reader through reading his poem, rather than Scott's. Despite this view however, I also believe that Scott delivers his argument extremely effectively, although his use of a more conventional form and structure leads me to think that his poem is not as effective as Owen's in communicating his message. ?? ?? ?? ?? Bethany Weston ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level War Poetry essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Compare 'The Drum' by John Scott and 'The Send-off' by Wilfred Owen

    3 star(s)

    The second stanza is used to shock the readers so they can understand the true horrors of war. By using two contrasting stanzas, Scott effectively presents his criticism on the way people perceive war. Another way John Scott presents his ideas is by creating strong and powerful images.

  2. The poems Joining the Colours and The Send-off both discuss, young, guileless boys marching ...

    This poem is broken up with odd lines, which gives the reader more of a chance to think about the previous line, and therefore has more of an impact. The other poem is broken up by lines and words but still flows.

  1. Explore the different ways in which "The Send Off" and "Joining The Colours" reveal ...

    just three lines which empathises the death more and they are so short, they do not directly say the soldiers will die, as the boys are so young, so they cover the terms with imagery instead, Hinkson tries to soften the words.

  2. How is the horror of war, and the poets'criticism of war conveyed in the ...

    In this essay I will be discussing three poems, Exposure by Wilfred Owen and two poems by Siegfried Sassoon, Base Details, and Suicide in the trenches. The poems mentioned in this essay are restrictive. For the sake of realism, the poet can only be in one place at one time

  1. The Send-Off

    He describes, and criticises indirectly the "dull porters" who are very unconcerned and disinvolved with the soldiers' departure. Even a most insignificant "casual tramp" shows egoism and selfishness, in fact this beggar is only feeling sad for the soldiers' departure because he will miss out on the food and money

  2. Write a comparison of the ways Wilfred Owen and John Scott present ideas about ...

    John Scott talks about the pathetic reasons which people go to war. He explains how the young are almost excited by the surrender of the opposition. 'To sell their liberty for charms'. This line suggests that people would rather sell there independence for money.

  1. What attitudes to war have youfound in your reading of war poetry?

    People began to question the leadership, decision making, the role of the press, and the wisdom of war. Ordinary people had lost their loved ones, a generation of young men lost their lives; to what purpose? Back then a human life wasn't worth much, merely a statistic.

  2. Basing your answer on three of the poems write a comparison of the ways ...

    and this enthusiasm is mirrored in a large amount of literature written at the start of the first world war. Roland in 'Letters From a Lost Generation' describes war as a 'fascinating thing' and Brooke compares soldiers going into battle as 'swimmers into cleanness leaping' capturing the determination and the idea of purification.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work