• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11

"In Batiste's determination to continue the struggle lies the essence of Blasco Ibaez's optimism. La barraca is a novel of protest, not of hopelessness" (G. Cheyne). To what extent do you agree with this statement?

Extracts from this document...


"In Batiste's determination to continue the struggle lies the essence of Blasco Iba�ez's optimism. La barraca is a novel of protest, not of hopelessness" (G. Cheyne). To what extent do you agree with this statement? I do not fully agree with the above opinion given by Cheyne. I do think that what he says is partly true but to say that the novel is lacking the theme of hopelessness would be wrong. It is more apt to say that the novel displays both a sense of protest from its characters and also a sense of hopelessness. In this essay I intend to explore the themes of hopelessness and of protest, discussing how they interact and thereby provide a sense of fate in the novel. Furthermore I will talk about what devices Blasco uses to emphasise these themes to the reader. From the beginning of Batiste's arrival in the huerta, the fields in which he works and lives have a sense of doom attached to them. Piment� assures the huertanos that Bastiste's farming of the fields will not be successful and his efforts to do so would be stopped: �l, lo �nico que podia asegurar es que el tal sujeto no coger�a el trigo, ni las habas, ni todo lo que hab�a plantado en los campos de Barret. Aquello ser�a para el demonio.1 I would say that the way in which the whole of the village side against Batiste is a negative value of society that Blasco wishes to display through the device of the undefined group of people that exist within the village. ...read more.


The general circularity of the novel suggests that the same story that we have read could occur again and again. Batiste and, in fact the peasant population of Valencia will struggle against the perils of life for eternity. I agree with Medina in saying that the pauses in the main story, such as Roseta's love affair with Tonet are important. As Medina says they offer us "...momentary hope, but collapse in tragedy."9 This would not, as the title quotation suggests show an essence of optimism from Blasco but rather pessimism. The moments of joy for the characters in the novel are purely fleeting. Chapter eight is also important structurally in the novel. It makes the reader feel a sense of hope for Batiste and his family and displays compassion from the villagers. Blasco creates this sense of hope for the future of Batiste and his family in order to induce the reader into a more dramatic, emotional climax to their reading of the novel. However, Blasco tells us at the end of chapter eight that Batiste's hope for the future is na�ve: "Batiste, siempre inm�vil, miraba como unidiota las estrellas..."10. Still Blasco maintains the fa�ade of optimism at the start of chapter nine: "Todo era alegr�a, trabajo gozoso."11 The happiness has ended by the end of chapter nine and alcohol is the direct catalyst to the downfall of Batiste, as it was for t�o Barret. The story of Barret introduces the theme of doom to the fields that Batiste will later come to work on. ...read more.


This contact with the ghost could be interpreted as a symbol of an outside force ruling over the huerta that fits in with my previous idea of mysticism in the novel. Moving away from the idea of outside forces in the novel, the existence of the tavern in Alboraya is directly the most significant, physical aspect of it. It could only be said that Blasco sees alcohol as having a negative affect on the men in the novel. Both Barret and Batiste go to the Tavern before committing their violent acts. Alcohol plays an important part in the lives of the huertanos as it is a way of escapism from their brutal and hard lives but its abuse inevitably leads to violence. Interestingly both Barret and Batiste are sober men but their brief entry into the Tavern causes them to lose their inhibitions towards violence.22 The alcohol that they drink causes them to become animal-like and uncontrollable. In conclusion, in my opinion the novel is one of protest and of hopelessness. Batiste does display great determination throughout the novel but the important fact to remember is that by the end of it, he has come back to where he started, with nothing. I believe that Blasco Ib��ez's displays nothing but pessimism for the factors that cause Batiste to fail in the Valencian lands. There is a sense all through the novel of hopelessness and I think that Blasco intended the reader to instinctually know that Batiste was not going to be able to protest or struggle enough in order to succeed against all of the obstacles put in his way. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Jane Austen essays

  1. Explore the presentations of Keith's mother. How important is she to the novel Spies ...

    The description of Mrs Hayward here with her hands covering her face shows she feels scared and guilty about the situation which she is in.

  2. To What Extent Is Northanger Abbey a Gothic Novel?

    gothic novels as Isabella says "When you have finished with Udolpho, we shall read the Italian together; and I have made out a list of ten or twelve more of the same kind for you" Catherine upon reading these books, is influenced so much by them that she believes herself

  1. The Mayor of Casterbridge - Chapter Summaries

    She tries to keep her mother away from the furmity tent by saying, "It isn't respectable"--despite our belief that Elizabeth-Jane came from the same improper conditions within the tent, with her working-class parents. Hardy also includes a few elements of suspense into the story.

  2. Argue that the theory of common sense structures provides an important and hitherto unappreciated ...

    programme. For common-sense reasoning can mean: (1) formally rigorous and precise reasoning about the world of common sense (reasoning on the properly theoretical level about the world that is grasped pre-theoretically); (2) reasoning as actually practised by humans in their everyday, non-theoretical lives; (3) a philosophically motivated reconstruction of either (1)

  1. How far do you agree with the critic that argues there are two Darcys?

    at it seems not so much that 'there are two Darcys' but that sometimes his conduct is a result of how he is regarded. Perhaps, with his knowledge of his every action being analysed with 'a truth universally acknowledged, that ...

  2. Contextual Factors in Pride and Prejudice(TM) influence the characters. Do you agree?

    Money can also influence the appearance of characters on the surface, as when Mr Darcy is introduced in chapter 3, he is described as being very favourable, based only on his social standing and his financial status. The fact that Darcy earned 'ten thousand a year' meant that people looked at him "with great admiration for half the evening".

  1. Thoughts on binary oppositions and ideologies.

    So, we can say that this constitutes a binary opposition where the terms are mutually dependent upon one another. Good cannot have meaning without bad and bad cannot possess a sense without its antithetical counterpart, good. It is very clear now that binary oppositions display how meanings are formulated out

  2. What is the dramatic significance of Act 2 to the play as a whole? ...

    Shaming himself in a way, once the respected Mr Proctor could now possibly be most disrespected. It's a risk he has got to take now with the arrest of his wife a massive event in his life. The bigotry of the leaders in Salem is also reinforced as the truth is constantly questioned throughout this act.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work