• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In both In the Suburbs and Richard Cory, the poets present the concept that having money is not the most significant aspect of life.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Rob Ranson 15 February 2011 Misery or Happiness? The Influence of Wealth Considered by many to be their most prized and sought after possession, money is rather the capital for survival. For years, the concept of materialism has consumed society. The thought that money and majesty can make one happy has been a commonly shared notion throughout various cultures, causing people to seek happiness through tangible assets and higher social statuses. These seekers of happiness may never find it by achieving wealthier statuses, while others find satisfaction in modest lifestyles. It is the idea that money does buy happiness that is reflected in the poems "In the Suburbs" by Louis Simpson and "Richard Cory" by Edwin Arlington Robinson. Although the authors of both poems shed light on different perspectives of the socio-economic spectrum, the themes in both of the pieces are similar: purpose in life cannot be purchased. Both poems also give rise to the definition of the true American Dream is, since both a wealthy person in "Richard Cory" and a suburbanite in "In the Suburbs" seem to be unhappy with their lives. ...read more.

Middle

In "In the Suburbs," the tone shifts from pessimistic to submissive by Simpson's addition that "others before you / Were born to walk in procession" (5). In "Richard Cory", the tone shifts from one of pride and cheerfulness to one of sorrow. Nonetheless, both poems suggest that someone's life may not always be as it seems, and that life can be filled with emptiness despite all the possessions and adequacies that one may have. In Simpson's "In the Suburbs," the reader is introduced to the idea of dreadfulness with the line "There's no way out" (1). This line creates suspense for the reader - something that both Simpson and Robinson do effectively in their poems - by implying a prison-like lifestyle. Both poets create suspense through their use of similar syntactical strategies such as anaphora. For example, Robinson uses anaphora when writing "And he was always quietly arrayed / And he was always human when he walked" (5). He does this to emphasize to the reader that Richard Cory is not condescending or snobby, which evokes curiosity in the reader as to wonder why Cory seems to be so composed and humble, despite his obvious wealth and power in society. ...read more.

Conclusion

Though Gatsby-like Richard Cory seems to have it all, the theme conveyed by Robinson is that happiness cannot be purchased or acquired with a higher social status. When Simpson's "In the Suburbs" was written over half a century later, the idea of the American Dream shifted to the suburbs of white America where life was dull and mundane, despite people's middleclass status and sufficient amounts of money. In the suburbs of 1950s American, money was unable to buy the individuality and happiness that its residents sought for, which caused them to have miserable existences. Essentially, "In the Suburbs," and "Richard Cory" present discrepancies between what appears to be true and what actually exists: the suburbs are portrayed as offering a comfortable life even though suburbanites are unhappy, and Richard Cory appears to be joyful when he is actually depressed and empty. The characters of both poems clearly enough wealth, yet they still remain discontent. Both poems convey the influence of money and status. Both poems also show that life is not always at it seems. Though they contrast in their structure, style, and tone, "In the Suburbs" and "Richard Cory" share the thematic message that happiness comes from within oneself, and not from having money or material goods. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Comparative Essays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Comparative Essays essays

  1. In The Snack Bar by Edwin Morgan

    the start of the poem and highlights one of the poem's main themes, that of the fragility of the human condition. Like a child, the man must depend on the goodwill of others to fulfill his needs. He is denied basic human dignity because of this dependence, and his sense

  2. The poem "Miniver Cheevy" by Edwin A. Robinson paints an interesting picture of a ...

    Something about having too much money and power would either cause him to be evil, or he feels that money causes sin in people's lives. In the sixth stanza he reverts to negative thoughts about his life. "Miniver cursed the commonplace," states Robinson as he speaks of the character's mediocrity and how it angers him.

  1. Compare the way Larkin and Plath present human relationships in their poems.

    Afternoons opens with the suggestion of time passing, of the summer drawing to a close, which is shown by the line 'the leaves fall in ones in twos'. The use of the words 'ones' and 'twos' show that the fading of the summer which is a barely noticeable event which

  2. Compare and contrast the ways in which Philip Larkin and Penelope Lively present ...

    It is history repeating itself over and over again, generation after generation. Just like Penelope Lively, Philip Larkin believes that we have a choice of changing history. History can be repeating but does not have to be so necessarily. "My hands on misery to man, It deepens like a coastal shelf.

  1. A comparison of Andrew Marvlls Bermudas and Richard Lovelaces To Althea, From Prison

    This implies that the paradise described is fictional, perhaps even unobtainable. This could represent Marvell`s opinion of the puritans attempts to find somewhere less corrupt than England, as there is debate regarding whether Marvell was truly a roundhead (and consequently whether he was a puritan), and it has been suggested

  2. How does Rodger McGoughs Poetry support the concept that nobody wins nuclear war?

    can win nuclear war, as it is so filled with horrors and destruction, that there is no room for survival. Directly opposed to this emotionally charged poem's imagery, is that of the poem, "Icarus Allsorts", which depicts an arrogant and ignorant general starting a nuclear war.

  1. What are the concerns in Sonnets 116, 130 and On Monsieur(TM)s Departure and how ...

    Or is he in fact saying that the young man's love for the poet has increased after hearing about his inevitable demise. The first quatrain sees the line 'bare ruin'd choirs' which is a reference to the ruined churches, the remnants that were left after monarchs at the time destroyed

  2. How have the poets choice of diction effect the readers

    She leads the girls inside, and takes Pecola to the bathroom to talk with her and help her to get cleaned up. That night, while the girls lie in bed, Pecola is awestruck because she has been told that the bleeding means she is now able to have a baby.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work