• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In King Lear Shakespeare creates a morally chaotic world. How far and in what ways do you agree with this statement? (with teacher's edits)

Extracts from this document...


Transfer-Encoding: chunked ?In King Lear Shakespeare creates a morally chaotic world.? How far and in what ways do you agree with this statement? Shakespeare presents a variety of ways in which moral chaos is brought about, including the disruption of the natural order and the characters possession of typically corrupted morals, even going as far as questioning the morals of his own society. However, having different principles in a modern audience, we tend to have different interpretations of ?moral chaos? to that of a contemporary audience. In king Lear, Shakespeare arguably does create a ?morally chaotic world?, particularly trough the notion of the ?natural order? being disrupted. The betrayal of the children against their fathers illustrates a significant disruption of nature, as it was considered natural and necessary for children to have unfaltering obedience for their parents, particularly their fathers. When Cordelia publicly refuses to obey her father?s wishes, she goes against the true qualities of a 17th century daughter in the natural order and it is arguably this initial rebellion that causes the suffering and tragedy throughout the rest of the play. According to feminist critics, Cordelia?s refusal to flatter Lear can be interpreted as an opposition to Lear?s authority and thus a direct challenge to the natural patriarchal order of the seventeenth century, the short emphatic sentence ?Nothing? stressing this assertiveness. ...read more.


From a New Historicist stance, critics such as Tennenhouse argue that Shakespeare illustrates what happens when there is a ?catastrophic redistribution of power?, therefore promoting the oppressive structures of the patriarchal hierarchy. However, other critics suggest that the tragedies occur because of society?s already ?faulty ideological structure?, particularly emphasised in the David Farr production through the skewed girders, broken windows, sizzling strip-lighting and the eventual collapse of the flimsy kingdom walls. Moreover, Shakespeare appears to be presenting a morally chaotic world through the way in which the characters can be seen as possessing seen corrupted morals, motivated purely by materialism as opposed to moralistic values. We see this in the elegant and superficial speeches of Gonerill and Regan who claim to love Lear ?Dearer than eyesight?, the hyperbole in these statements highlighting their manipulative nature and greed for worldly goods. Their actions throughout the rest of the play prove the fabrication of these initial promises. Johnson comments that King Lear is a play in which the ?Wicked prosper and virtuous miscarry?. I find this view accurate as the audience can witness how the Machiavellian characters such as Gonerill and Regan are rewarded for their materialism, and given total rights over the kingdom, whereas the virtuous characters such as Cordelia and Kent are punished for their honesty and moralistic values, consequently demonstrating a world of chaotic morals. ...read more.


Foakes comments "The optimistic thrust of Edgar's moralizing hints at the possibility of a happy ending.?? The play concludes with the moralistic character Edgar reigning over England, and although good characters such as Cordelia die, (which wasn?t received well by Shakespeare?s original audience), evil is ultimately eradicated whilst good triumphs. By the end of the play, Evil can even be seen to be eradicated by evil itself. Gonerill poisons Regan, and mentions in an aside after Regan feels the effects ?If not I?ll ne?er trust medicine?, the secretive nature of this aside presenting her murderous and calculating nature. Shortly after, she commits suicide, which would have been seen as a great act of sin by a Jacobean audience, but ultimately evil defeats itself, evoking a rebalancing of morals and a move back towards the natural order. The play clearly descends from the embodied values of medieval morality plays, which was a popular form of drama in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. These plays present a direct conflict between good and evil, and ultimately the evil and chaos must be destroyed, and a moral lesson is learned. Overall, there are many aspects of King Lear that evoke a seeming moral chaos, however by the end of the play, as in all morality plays, the chaos is removed and moral order is restored, resulting in catharsis for the audience. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Criticism & Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. Cold War Literature - the particular ways of thinking present throughout the Cold War ...

    concern, as the manipulation and deception of others by the Circus causes the readers to weigh up the ?ethics?. This is highlighted especially as it becomes apparent that the British are instigating the protection of a former Nazi, another scenario raising concerns of morality.

  2. Claudio in Much Ado About Nothing A Character Study of the Impulsive Lover in ...

    Well, it wasn?t really my fault." Weak sauce.) By the end of the play, he?s still a merry, foolish boy, and while he?s apologized, he?s never really come to terms with his own personal failings. His willingness to fall under a passion leaves him open to be easily manipulated and deceived by the merest suggestion.

  1. Compare the ways in which Philip Larkin and Carol Ann Duffy present the theme ...

    of his life and thus suggests it to be the beginning of the end. ?Ambulances? invites us to the idea that death is a private experience but this sense of intimacy can be misleading as it opens with the simile ?closed like confessionals?.

  2. Hamlet, King Claudius' Soliloquy

    The soliloquy begins with a palpable sense of despair. It commences with a loud wailing tone as Claudius is lost with no idea how to be cleansed of his sin yet his emotion changes from despair to one of self pitying and also self loathing.

  1. Examine how classes have different class conditions, communities and values in both North and ...

    As a result of these working condition it has left Higgins? daughter terminally ill; ?what wi' hard work first, and sickness at last, hoo's led the life of a dog. And to die without knowing one good piece o' rejoicing in all her days!?.

  2. To what extent does Shakespeare use comedy to explore the perceptions of love in ...

    In the same way that Orsino?s love for viola is amusing, Olivia?s love for Cesario is funny because the audience knows that Cesario is actually Viola. This is sort of a reversed version of Orsino?s situation with Viola. Because the audience knows that Cesario is a woman it is amusing

  1. Write a comparison of the ways in which ideas about female transgression is presented ...

    Forster combines love with the body, making them one, however the authoritative word ?must? is used to command Lucy to stifle it. This may make love and passion appear like a vital element of life, as it is a bodily need as well as an emotion.

  2. Comparing "That surprising Craig girl!" advert (Text 25), and the online news article "Why ...

    of ?surprising? numerous amounts of times which showed a change of perception of girls in sports. This is contrasted to Text 9, which was published in 2008. More modern features include that it is an online article, which means it is more accessible to a wider audience.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work