• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In what ways are Gatsby and George Wilson similar or dissimilar, to whom is Nick more sympathetic towards?

Extracts from this document...


In what ways are Gatsby and George Wilson similar or dissimilar, to whom is Nick more sympathetic towards? Fitzgerald purposefully contrasts his characters throughout the novel, in order to compare contrasting worlds that were present in American society. Although there are some clear differences between Gatsby and George, there are also superficial similarities between them that each man has to experience and put up with. Drawing upon the more apparent differences between these two characters, it is evident that they have differing wealth. Gatsby is depicted as being rich through the means of the 'Hotel de Ville' or 'mansion'(11) that he owns, and also by the way he holds lavish parties where 'champagne was served in glasses bigger than finger-bowls'(48). Considering that Gatsby lives in West Egg not only reveals the true extent of his wealth, but additionally it shows that he is 'noveau riche' rather than 'old' rich like those who inhabit East Egg. Gatsby has only recently acquired his wealth after migrating from the Midwest whilst following the 'New' American Dream. The original dream consisted of any American citizen having the right to pursue their goals and dreams through hard work and free choice. It was the opportunity to make individual choices without the underlying restrictions of class, caste, religion, race, or ethnic group, that once overshadowed people. Often, people followed the common saying, 'Go West young man!' where the land was uninhabited and extremely fertile. In the case of the 'New' dream, it was simply how the dream had become interpreted by the 1920s. It was a distortion from the original dream to the idea of 'Get rich quick'. Being of 'New' wealth, Gatsby tries to flaunt his wealth about. When Nick asks Gatsby whether he is going to go home that night following the vehicular manslaughter of Myrtle by Daisy, Nick describes Gatsby in chapter eight, as wearing a 'pink rag of a suit'(147).This description suggests how Gatsby wears these expensive, gaudy and colourful items of clothing in order to display his wealth ostentatiously. ...read more.


The way in which Gatsby was driven by his undying love for a woman is a reflection of Fitzgerald's own life and dreams too. He too joined the army (1917) and eventually fell in love with a seventeen year old girl called 'Zelda Sayre'. Zelda finally agreed to marry him, but her overpowering desire for wealth, fun, and leisure led her to delay their wedding until he could prove a success. Their relationship appears to be like Gatsby and Daisy's. The following quote reveals the point in the novel at which all of Daisy's charm and beauty is stripped away, leaving nothing but money to be admired underneath: 'That was it. I'd never understood before. It was full of money- that was the inexhaustible charm that rose and fell in it, the jingle of it, the cymbals' song of it.' (Chapter seven) Gatsby realizes late into the novel, how his dream has been ripped apart into dollar bills as he discovers that for years he has been in pursuit of not love, but cold, harsh money which is hidden behind the disguise of a human face. Following the death of Gatsby and the suicide of George, it becomes apparent that Fitzgerald is using the deaths of a rich man and a poor man who both set out to achieve their unattainable goals, to symbolise the death of the original dream on which America was founded. With consideration given to George, he too shares the American Dream with Gatsby; however he seems to be pursuing the 'old' American Dream and not the 'New' one like Gatsby. George reveals his dream in chapter seven, where he says: I've been here too long. I want to get away. My wife and I want to go West. She's been talking about it for ten years.' Clearly his dream is the opposite of Gatsby's. He wants to migrate West like the original settlers and wants to follow the idea to 'Go West young man!' ...read more.


Nick as narrator, appears to be far more lenient towards Gatsby. Following the deaths of both men, Nick only makes it his duty to sort out Gatsby's funeral and does not think of George's. In addition, when Tom wants Nick to meet his mistress in chapter two, Nick says how he had 'no desire to meet her.' This statement suggests how Nick feels he is being disloyal to Daisy. He does not think to consider how George would feel knowing about the affair his wife is having with one of his own acquaintances (Tom). Additionally, Nick seems to overlook Gatsby's criminal behaviours even though he has been given enough evidence to suggest that Gatsby is a gangster. Fitzgerald's portrayal of both men differs greatly, so much so that they appear to be direct opposites of one another. Gatsby is rich and has a more fulfilling life than George, who suffers the dullness of living in a dump (Valley of Ashes) and the lack of respect from his wife. The relationship between George and his wife is peculiar and goes against the historical view of a married couple. In the Victorian era, women would have had to stay at home in order to attend to maternal duties, whilst the husband would have had to provide the income. Usually the man had the authority over the woman, and in the case of the Wilson's, there has been a role reversal. However, these two men are linked superficially by their failure to achieve their unattainable dreams which they had been pursuing throughout life. Considering that Gatsby was originally a working class poor man in previous years, and that he and George both die in honour of their failed dreams, suggests that when a poor man tries to enter into a higher social status like Gatsby, their efforts are rendered useless. Not only does this circumstance reveal the divide in society but additionally it emphasises the moral decay of American society amidst the superficial impressiveness of upper-class profligacy. WORDS: 3,033 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The English Patient

    5 star(s)

    Important Quotations Explained "Most of you, I am sure, remember the tragic circumstances of the death of Geoffrey Clifton at Gilf Kebir, followed later by the disappearance of his wife, Katharine Clifton, which took place during the 1939 desert expedition in search of Zerzura."

  2. Marked by a teacher

    In what Sense can we connect the Ideas of the Idealised Self and the ...

    3 star(s)

    Yet we still say the same words in every relationship we are in. 'I Love You.' How can these words mean the same thing to two different people, relationships, and years, apart? In 'Finding the Words' Duffy contemplates this train of thought.

  1. English Lit Coursework (Comapring Othello, Wuthering heights and Gatsby)

    disregard to morals and any care for the effect on outsiders like Gatsby. Comparably, Fitzgerald presents the threshold between two worlds of class in Myrtle and George's relationship. Myrtle Wilson strives for a life of wealth, in order to be accepted into the party lifestyle.

  2. How do the two main characters in your comparison novels compare? (The Great Gatsby ...

    We are drawn so far into and entranced by this enigmatic character, it is hard to question or accuse him of being any different than perfect. The impression given by Henry is quite different, as he is 'large, square-jawed, with coarse pale skin'.

  1. Free essay

    Discuss the way in which the female characters are presented in the Great Gatsby

    is', suggesting Gatsby's realisation that Daisy is nothing in reality compared with what she was in his dreams. Fitzgerald develops various different examples of this 'new woman' or 'flapper'. Jordan Baker is a prime example of a 'flapper', as Fitzgerald provides the reader with outspoken descriptions.

  2. Examine how Forster and Dunant present melancholy through both George & the Painter in ...

    Mr. Emerson asks '...why does it distress him?' Ironically, George does not seem to be losing faith in God but is losing the faith to not believe in him. This suggests that George is confused much like the Painter. While they were growing up they were both taught to believe different but firm ideologies, however, when the Painter

  1. In both The Great Gatsby and The Kite Runner, Fitzgerald and Hosseini constantly use ...

    However, the fact that it is advertising spectacles and Nick describes it as having an 'eternal blindness' creates an irony of how this figure, seen implicitly as god by George Wilson before he kills Gatsby, is leading the inhabitants of the valley of ashes blindly.

  2. The Idea of Carelessness in "The Great Gatsby", Rosetti's poems and "The Rime ...

    there are underlying tones which hint at how fake her character is by blatantly ignoring the fact that she has a husband and being careless about the consequences which may arise from her meeting up with another man. These consequences also have an impact on Gatsby?s character, as ?he felt

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work