• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In what ways is The Merchant's Tale a response to The Clerk's Tale?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

In what ways is The Merchant's Tale a response to The Clerk's Tale? Chaucer's establishment of the Clerk in the General Prologue as a committed scholar who prioritises his academic studies over material wealth contrasts sharply with the description of the Merchant's 'bargaines' and his 'chevissaunce'. In placing The Clerk's Tale immediately before that of the Merchant and exploring similar themes within both, Chaucer introduces to his readership a likelihood of the second tale being a response to the first. The differing attitudes and outcomes of the tales, whilst having significant links in their subject matter, provoke comparison of the narrators in their personal discussions and the protagonists become the embodiment of their views towards marriage in the tales. Walter is presented by the Clerk as a largely stereotypical marquis, whose qualities of humility and understanding in his proposal to Griselda are linked to the distinct lack of irony in the introduction to his character. The Clerk narrates in praise of the protagonist, "Handsome and young and strong; in him were blent High honour and a gentle courtesy." It is then admitted that Walter did show certain faults ("He was indeed to blame...") although the fact that he is named so shortly after the beginning of the tale resounds importantly in the Merchant's prologue, where Chaucer admits to having forgotten the narrator's name. ...read more.

Middle

He cannot conceal the fact that she is only one of many potential brides, outlined where the Merchant narrates, "...As whoso tooke a mirour, polished bright, And sette it in a commune market-place." This illustrates that January is seeing a 'reflection' of the ideal of marrying a beautiful maiden - though not a reflection of his own physical appearance, which later detracts from May's comfort in their wedding bed. The Merchant neglects to mention her parentage and under what pretences she actually came to marry January, whose presentation as a senex amans - an old man marrying a young girl - carries a significant potential for mockery. The various references to May's 'tendre flesshe' serve as a reminder that the relationship on the knight's part is driven by sexual desire and obsession and there is a great distinction between the humorous presentation of January's appearance and the grotesqueness that is his later refusal to release her hand. A possible interpretation of the tale is that Chaucer intended it to be humorous to appeal to the reader after the more solemn words of the Clerk; on the part of the Merchant, January's character may be under ridicule in order that the same view may be brought about regarding marriage. These important contradictions of the previous tale, both in content and in attitudes, give the impression of the Merchant's words most certainly being a response to the Clerk. ...read more.

Conclusion

Despite the implications of being under constant surveillance by her husband, May eventually manipulates him in order to gain access to Damyan, which provokes the final comments from the Merchant in his conclusion that all women are deceptive. Conversely, Griselda has a great deal of speaking parts in The Clerk's Tale and formally promises her obedience to Walter in the lines, "...And here I promise never willingly To disobey in deed or thought or breath..." In this way, both tales are made distinctive through the exploration of a controversial subject of the time, namely the status of women, and the conclusions of the tales differ dramatically. Chaucer uses May and Griselda to reflect the personalities of their husbands, which has the effect of encouraging the reader to acknowledge flaws - especially the certain depravity of January's intentions and the Walter's preoccupation with testing the faithfulness of his wife. The narrative and events of The Merchant's Tale must certainly be considered a response to The Clerk's Tale simply for their proximity to one another in The Canterbury Tales and their highly similar, yet interpretable themes. It seems natural for the pilgrims to compete with each other in the telling of their tales for a desire to be the most entertaining, and the two tales become the two sides of a debate regarding marriage. It is in this context that the words of the Merchant become a finely timed and thorough response to the preceding words of the Clerk. English Literature ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Geoffrey Chaucer section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Geoffrey Chaucer essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    "A shockingly cynical picture". In the light of this comment, discuss the Wife of ...

    4 star(s)

    In leaping into the attack first she secured as much freedom as possible for herself. All this brings to light the wife's crafty character and her fierce determination to live life as she chooses. Furthermore, it must be said that the wife does not see marriage as an equal and

  2. Courtly Love and Damyan. Chaucer uses conventions of courtly love throughout the Canterbury ...

    When she "of this bille hath taken hede" she proceeds to "rente it al to cloutes atte laste, and in the privee softely it caste".

  1. English society of Chaucer's time

    It doesn't matter that the tales are chaotic and unfinished; what matters is that God's truth existed for Chaucer beyond the chaos of everyday lives and explanations. ^^^^^^^^^^CANTERBURY TALES: A NOTE ON THIS GUIDE Although Chaucer did not complete the Canterbury Tales, he managed to write 24 of them, plus the General Prologue and a Retraction.

  2. 'Merchant's Tale - Marriage'

    Januarie is blind to her cunning - in both a literal sense and a moral sense - as Adam is initially to the serpent's influence. Januarie is manipulated by his wife as Adam is by his. Chaucer also refers to the realisation of sin, as with Adam, Januarie becomes aware

  1. The pardoners prologue and Tale show human nature to lack any redeeming virtues ...

    In addition to this, he candidly states that he 'rekke never' of the pilgrims once they have died, for his only interest is taking their money and not their eternal souls, in which he admits 'whan that they are beryed, hir soules goon-a-blackberyed!'.

  2. A sinister exploration of the nature of evil Discuss Chaucers poetic methods in ...

    the fact that he acknowledges this suggests he is fully aware of his evil nature. Koff suggests that the pardoner is not so much evil as he is bold. This can be argued to an extent, as he does admit to being a ful vicious man, yet states that a morale tale yet I yew telle kan.

  1. Themes and Ideas in The Merchant's Tale

    The story of creation in Genesis not only explains God's creation of a woman to keep Adam company, but shows the how a woman caused the downfall of mankind, by being tempted to eat the forbidden fruit in the Garden of Eden.

  2. Chaucer is successful in creating humour in the Wife of Baths prologue and tale.

    ?That somme han slain hir housbondes in hir bed.? She proceeded to punch him in the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work