• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Investigation into representation of gender through speech

Extracts from this document...


Investigation into representation of gender through speech Chiara Giovanni Introduction: The aim of the investigation is to find out whether gender affects speech features according to research carried out by theorists Lokoff, Holmes, Tannen and Fishman. Methodology: Primary research was undertaken. Three groups of Year 10 students were used: a control group consisting of three boys and three girls, a group with six girls, and a group with six boys. The students came from the top set single-sex English groups, which could be considered to be helpful, as not only have they had extensive experience of debating and discussion, but being in single-sex classes should have supposedly amplified the speech features affected by gender. Each group was asked to discuss the issue of which gender were more likely to choose looks over personality, a discussion topic which would theoretically be more relevant and approachable than a controversial issue like abortion or euthanasia, and more interesting and original than school uniform or smoking. Hypotheses: * Girls are more likely to seek approval from others in a group and "keep face"; boys are more likely to be confrontational and attempt to establish their individual identities rather than staying in a group * Girls are therefore more likely to use hedgers and fillers to soften their arguments and sound more hesitant and less sure of themselves than boys, who will ...read more.


maybe (1) maybe that's a bit stereotypical (1) but Girl: yeah but (.) some girls to be fair do say "oh I'm not pretty" Supports Lokoff's findings that women are more likely to hedge their opinions to soften a potentially harsh tone and gain approval from the group. * Boys more firm: Boy: well in my opinion lots of girls wanna look [inaudible] and they think they gotta lose weight and gotta buy new clothes and stuff Supports Tannen's theory that men prefer independence from the group, as highlighted by the first person construction used here. * Boys interrupt the girls more * Fewer fillers Boy: ...and they're just looking for someone to say, "no you're not, you're beautiful" Straightforward style of speech supports Fishman's findings that men do not employ as many attention-getters to change topic, as well as Tannen's belief that men prefer to report and lecture than to listen and establish rapport. Conclusion- both boys and girls displayed more stereotypically male or female speech traits in accordance with famous research when with the opposite gender 6 boys When in an all-boys group, typical "female" traits were more apparent: * Boys playing for time with hedgers Boy: hmm (1) I'm not really sure * Boys support each other with agreement features; are also more hesitant, use monitoring devices, less forceful with opinions Boy: well yeah (.) ...read more.


The support and rapport still remains the same. * Interruption/overlap is very frequent but seems to enrich the conversation rather than detracting from it or creating confrontation Girl 3: friends with benefits guys Girl 6: [laughter] Girl 5: [no way] Girl 4: [no] Others: [laughter] Girl: [you] Girl 6: [that's like you kissing [name]] Others: [laughter] Girl: [that's disgusting] Girl 5: [and my [inaudible]] Girl 2: and the conversation gets really awkward Others: [laughter] Girl 2: I suppose we Girl 6: [and now you think] Girl: [and guys] Girl 2: and now you said that (.) I was just Girl 5: [see like her little comment just] Girl: [and always like] Girl 2: [literally] Girl 3: [joking] Girl: [yeah let's just get back to whether girls are more picky than boys] Girl 3: [laughter] Girl 6: yeah we changed topic * Girls use fewer monitoring devices and hedgers here: they are not afraid to contradict each other, and it is not seen as negative when they do so: they do not feel the need to seek approval from others * Girls also went off on random tangents involving Glee and Hannah Montana Conclusion- girls do not feel the need to seek approval when only with their own gender: their hesitancy disappears and they are less afraid of moving away from the established opinion ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Class and Gender conflict in Pygmalion

    4 star(s)

    in the form of a statue and wishes that she be brought to life. Bentley draws the parallel between this story and Shaw's play, although highlights the fact that the transition from statue to human being has been inverted within the play, as shown in: `The Pygmalion of `natural history'

  2. Language investigation

    He goes on to say that women are likely to use more 'correct' language than men. He explains that this is true all over the word and in many different languages. This seems to be because Non Standard English is stereotypically lined with lower class society and therefore violence, crime and general miscreance.

  1. Investigation into Gender Differences in the Language of Personal Profiles on Dating Websites

    favorite things: Foods: Indian, traditional english, MEAT, subway! Colour: Blue TV: My name is Earl (my sister calls me Earl because I'm into Karma) Film: Rocky (cheese, but good cheese) Clothes: River Island Things I don't like: football, wasted people, chavs last read: Geeky computer stuff in that hopes that

  2. Free essay

    ENGA2 - Investigation into the representation of the May 2011 Alternative Vote Referendum in ...

    Adjectives are used to great effect in the third text to disparage the Alternative Vote system, the referendum on its use, the effect a yes vote would have on the UK, and the politicians who instigated the referendum. The writer calls supporters of AV 'fanatics' - an adjective often saved

  1. Language Investigation: Barack Obama Inaugural Address

    However, in the inaugural address, it was important that he emphasised less on himself and the historical consequences, and more on the future, and the crisis they faced. * Abstract / Concrete Nouns The majority of the nouns are actually pronouns, but outside this they are split between abstract and concrete.

  2. English investigation

    They discussed the game and also had background conversations. My third transcript is of three girls talking about the world cup football match very briefly while talking more about football and surrounding topics. I felt that my first transcript I recorded was not sufficient enough to be analysed well and in detail, I therefore recorded a further transcript to increase my data and to make a more intricate analysis.

  1. Language - symbolic representation

    Who said that a certain word is offensive? Its just a word, but it's the way people are taught from a young age that they learn what words are acceptable to use in polite society and what words are not acceptable to use in polite society.

  2. Language and Gender.

    Their research suggests that men feel included and women feel excluded, in some cases alienated. The generic 'he' is the theory that 'he' has gained common usage through history.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work