• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is it possible to see Elizabeth Bennet as a feminist heroine?

Extracts from this document...


Is it possible to see Elizabeth Bennet as a feminist heroine? Elizabeth Bennet is perhaps the least conventional of Austen's characters, and certainly does not conform to what her society expected of her in the way of being submissive. Austen herself admitted that 'pictures of perfection ... make me sick and wicked', and so our lovable protagonist Elizabeth is set apart from the traditional heroine with her independence of mind, and courage to challenge accepted role of women. To the modern day reader her refusal to be the demure, submissive ideal woman of the conduct books written by such a Hannah Moore, insisting 'girls ... should early acquire a submissive temper and a forbearing spirit' allows her to appear a feminist heroine. By refusing two offers of marriage Elizabeth exercises her only available method of choice, as Henry Tilney of Austen's Northanger Abbey points out 'Man has the advantage of choice, woman only the power of refusal'. This demonstration of control earns our respect for Elizabeth as a heroine, and it certainly challenges the society's insistence on the significance of class distinction, appealing to the modern reader. Feminist critics Gilbert and Gubar assert that 'Elizabeth stands out as a young woman who has no intention of following the prescription of restraint and submission for the achievement of happiness'. ...read more.


Perhaps it is as punishment that Lydia's marital life shall be unfulfilled, as when Austen exiles Maria Betram in 'Mansfield Park', for running away with Henry Crawford despite her marriage to Mr. Rushworth - sent to 'another country, remote and private'. It seems she is also in search of attention, and Gilbert and Gubar's observation that 'marriage ... is the only accessible form of self-definition for girls in her [Jane Austen's] society' helps us to speculate that this may have been her ulterior motive for this relationship. In her letter to Harriett she confirms that she will find their surprise amusing, 'oh what a great joke it will be!', and her frivolous attitude towards her situation demonstrates her selfishness and compulsive mind, which Elizabeth view kindly. When rationally attempting to deter her father from permitting Lydia to accompany Mrs. Forster to Brighton, her sensible attitude is prominent as she analyses the danger she poses to the Bennets, explaining 'our importance, our respectability in the world, must be affected by the wild volatility ... which marks Lydia's character'. Her key phrase 'in the world' reminds the reader of the very different world inhabited by the girls, one in which it would not be possible for Lydia's conduct to be deemed acceptable. ...read more.


Darcy, 'Elizabeth conforms in the end to the feminine ideal of the helpmeet'. She is absorbed into Darcy's world, in which she will have little influence at all. But, we must not ignore the fact that it was, in the end her choice for marriage, and although she could not propose when she wanted it, she made sure it did not take place when it didn't suit her. Uniquely, our heroine stands out as a woman who feels she 'may take liberties with her husband', and to feel this way in such a time must not be overlooked by the modern reader as what is expected. Although Jane Austen herself would never have used the term 'feminist heroine', there is certainly debate about how she appears to the modern reader. Elizabeth Bennet is certainly appealing as our twenty first century heroine through the intelligence and courage to be independent, and Vivien Jones argues that she has the power to change the social order. However, as Marian Cox observes, 'though she mocks patriarchal structures, Austen must inhabit them', pointing out that despite Elizabeth's independace, she still must marry, for due to the laws of primogeniture she had no other option of maintaining wealth. This does mean Elizabeth can not be seen as a heroine however, as she still challenges her society, and marries a man she loves which is better than most women of the time. 7th December 2010 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

The writer raises several interesting and persuasive points about Elizabeth from a feminist perspective. The essay could be improved by more clarity and consistency about what is meant by 'heroine', more careful attention to spelling, expression and accurate quotation, and the addition of a bibliography to reference the critics quoted.

Marked by teacher Val Shore 17/06/2012

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Jane Austen essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Plot-Construction of Pride and Prejudice

    4 star(s)

    is drawn between the two romances-Edward Ferrars and Elinor, John Willoughby and Marianne. True to Elinor's cool, sensible nature the relationship between Edward Farrar's is conducted on the level of the mind, with both displaying hardly an emotion. The theme of sense is thus exemplified through their relationship.

  2. Free essay

    How does Michael Frayn Establish a Sense of Uncertainty in the Early Stages of ...

    As the story progresses, but still within the first few chapters, Frayn just creates more and more uncertainty, not only directed at the readers but also within the story. The use of oxymorons add to this sense of uncertainty, 'Everything was as it was, I discover when I reach my destination, and everything has changed.'

  1. Compare and Contrast 'Teresa's Wedding' by William Trevor and 'The Three Sisters' by Jan ...

    'Teresa's Wedding' is based on the line of true love and its value. William Trevor tries to exemplify that even though couples may be going through rough times, it always works out in the end if the love is still there, we are shown this by Teresa cheating on Artie.

  2. Pride and Prejudice chapter 19. In this chapter we see Elizabeths response towards ...

    class when actually she really meant that she didn't want to stay with him. Mr Collins also believes that he has high status in the society when he says to Elizabeth "your modesty" trying to make Elizabeth think that he is a great gentleman who respects her modesty in addition adds to her perfection.

  1. How effectively do Austen and Walker present the struggles that women face within their ...

    Marriage is on everyone's mind because it is quite simply a way of life; don't get involved and you're missing out. A lot of women want to get married purely for financial and security reasons, such as Charlotte, who decides to accept Mr Collins' proposal because she is in her

  2. What Does the Concept of Dignity mean to Stevens?

    Everyone is motivated by aspirations to climb higher, and Stevens' ultimate goal is to be acknowledged as a "great butler". He feels he comes significantly closer to his quest at a conference Lord Darlington, holds for the most important delegates in Europe.

  1. Humour in 'Pride and Prejudice'

    He shows that he has not considered her views or feelings and he is certain that his offer is an act of generosity. The scene is richly comic, but harsh realities underlie the situation. Collins reminds Elizabeth that since she has so little money to her name, she may never

  2. Sir Walter Scott's characterization of Two Drovers.

    Scott's Englishman, Harry Wakefield, also possesses his own national pride, yet the author brings it forth in a different way. Instead of using visual and oral descriptors, Scott characterizes the Englishman's nationalism through the events of the story. The most prominent event is the scene at the alehouse where Harry sits in company with his fellow Englishmen.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work