• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Macbeth a Hero or a Butcher?

Extracts from this document...


Is Macbeth a Hero or a Butcher? 'Macbeth', one of Shakespeare's shortest plays though often described as his best, was written in 1606 for the newly crowned King James I of England and VI of Scotland. It tells of a Scottish warrior named Macbeth who killed the King and eventually met his own gruesome end. But is Macbeth really the tragic hero he is made out to be? Does he really deserve to be glorified as a worthy and noble warrior? No. Macbeth was a brutal butcher who slaughtered his own people mercilessly and ruled his country tyrannically. First, let me clarify the definitions of the words 'hero' and 'butcher' which I will be using. A 'hero' is a man who is greatly admired for his exceptional qualities and achievements. A special kind of hero was the 'tragic hero'. The criteria for a 'tragic hero' were set by the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle and can be summed up briefly as a great man high up in society, with a fatal flaw which would eventually lead to his downfall - a man whom the audience will feel sympathy for when he falls. ...read more.


Macbeth went off at the end of II.i to murder King Duncan. If such an assassination were to occur today, it would shock the world and would probably be on the headlines of every major newspaper. The fact that this is murder alone already shows that Macbeth is a butcher. However, the Jacobean audience would have found the killing of a King even more shocking due to the fact that they believed in the 'Divine Right of Kings'. It was a Protestant belief (the religion in England at the time) that the King was God's representative on Earth and that killing him would be the closest you could get to killing God himself. Not only this, but King Duncan was in fact Macbeth's "kinsman" who had "honoured [him] of late" by promoting him to Thane of Cawdor. This proves that Shakespeare intended for Macbeth to be seen in a reprehensible way as only a villain of the most cruel kind could assassinate a King who is also his kinsman and his guest. Shakespeare portrays Macbeth in a very bad light in III.i - as a murderer of the worst kind. ...read more.


This act of murder enforces Macbeth's image as a butcher because he showed no compassion whatsoever for his victims and he therefore gains no sympathy from the audience. Shakespeare solidifies Macbeth's reputation as a ruthless killer in the conversation between Malcolm and Macduff in IV.iii. He is described as having ruled with "great tyranny", emphasising how cruel and unjust he has been as King. This is further developed when Macduff exclaims that "each new morn new widows howl, new orphans cry". Macbeth receives no sympathy from the audience as this statement implies that men are murdered every day under his tyrannical rule. Some people claim that Macbeth is an Aristotelian hero, his fatal flaw being his "vaulting ambition". However, this is clearly not the case as I have proven that he is not a great man at all but in fact a "tyrant" despised by the audience. He murdered a good king who was so "clear in his great office", and brought about the execution of not only his best friend Banquo, but also the entire innocent Macduff family. Macbeth was a man driven by ambition who was prepared to kill and butcher anyone in his quest for the throne. Michael Basaldella 10.2 HXR ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Macbeth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

This essay highlights the dangers of making a judgement before properly considering the evidence. The argument is quite powerfully presented but none of the complexities are acknowledged and the conclusion is only persuasive if all of Macbeth's soliloquies are ignored, as they are here. Similarly, the possible supernatural influence of the witches should be more fully considered.

Marked by teacher Val Shore 27/02/2012

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Macbeth essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    How does Shakespeare characterize the witches?

    3 star(s)

    They use aural and visual imagery to make it possible for the audience to feel the evilness of the witches chants and spells. Onomatopoeia is used in order to create the atmosphere around their concoctions; All Witches: double, double toil and trouble, Fire burn and cauldron bubble.

  2. Character Analysis of Macbeth

    on or actually do anything at all but non-the-less kick start his decline. Later on in the play when he reencounters the witches again they show him three apparitions one of which explain that he should ''Beware Macduff'' which influence him to order the killing of Macduff and his family

  1. How does Shakespeare Create Sympathy for Macbeth?

    Banquo is 'pleased to hear that, but doesn't want to get in trouble'. They are both as bad as the other in this scene, both going along with each other and sounding each other out, neither says to forget the meeting of the witches and to never speak of it again.

  2. Macbeth is a truly tragic figure because we see a great man brought down ...

    On the other hand if it was not for Lady Macbeth's persistence, Macbeth though very ambitious may never have murdered Duncan. This can be deduced in Macbeth's letter to Lady Macbeth when he says "...thou mightiest not lose the

  1. How does Shakespeare create and maintain tension and dramatic inpact in Act 1 Scene ...

    'Stay, you imperfect speakers, tell me more:' As William Shakespeare has made Banquo and Macbeth's reaction to the witches diverse, it helps the audience to see the two different ways of looking at the witches; and this is how

  2. Macbeth Essay: Who is responsible for the death of Duncan?

    It seems to be a regular outing for them, when one jovially asks ''when shall we three meet again?'' It is sensible to put the witches at fault because they act with no guilt or remorse because they do not know right from wrong as is evident by the phrase ''fair is foul, and foul is fair''.

  1. Is ambition the root of Macbeth's downfall?

    Moreover, the fear of losing the impending battle with England makes Macbeth start doing anything that will give him the edge in the final battle. Macbeth's fear is starting to consume him; he can no longer sleep and is ravaged by guilt over what he has done.

  2. Examine Macbeth's mental deterioration throughout the play.

    In this quotation a concept, as Fortune in the previous one, is personified by writing the name with an initial capital letter: Justice. Other metaphors and similies are present. The text, particularly detailed and written with a great number of literary devices, shows the importance of the passage as when

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work