• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Prospero a magnanimous ruler or an oppressive coloniser?

Extracts from this document...


AMDG JOSHUA GRAY - 14TH JUNE 2004. IS PROSPERO A MAGNANIMOUS RULER OR AN OPPRESSIVE COLONISER? At first glance Prospero seems like a well intentioned magician, a serene old man who only wanted to restore harmony and achieve reconciliation. But when you look closer into his character you see something else there, a character who is harsh and impatient, demanding and ambiguous, power hungry and deeply troubled. However, there is also a noble, kind and divine side to him. Ariel knows Prospero well and is one of the main characters and so has an advantage over the other characters about what he knows. Ariel calls prospero: ".....My noble master" However, Ariel has good reason to call him this. Prospero treats Ariel very well compared to Caliban often calling him names like "bird, "chick" and"...mine free spirit"....Ariel is under Prospero's control because he set him free from a tree which Sycorax imprisoned him for 12 years because he did not obey her commands. Although prospero is a much better master than Sycorax The fact still remains that he is still master and through out the play Ariel longs for "my liberty" but when he asks for it back Prospero becomes angry and threatens him with twelve more years. He has been extremely unjust and unfair against Ariel's wishes and has not realized this. ...read more.


".....So dear the love my people bore me" This treacherous act would indicate that Antonio does not have a conscience and is only stopped from anything worse because it concerns him what other people think... At no stage does he seem to repent his wrong doings and yet Prospero includes him in his general absolution, adding insult to injury Prospero never receives any thanks for this. For Prospero to be able to freely forgive would show his love and compassionate nature and with this evidence he would appear to have yet again the qualities of a magnanimous ruler. Alonso is a better person than Antonio, He shows that he is capable of remorse and possesses the desire to repent. However, he shows weakness in that he was easily swayed by Antonio's temptations, but compared to Prospero he appears inferior, e.g. he let Prospero and Miranda be left on a boat that he knew to be un seaworthy and allows himself to be manipulated by Antonio. But, he does show many redeeming qualities, he also loves his son, Ferdinand, deeply and persists in his attempt to find him. He also has a great sense of rightfulness and when Aerial points out his crimes against Miranda and Prospero he shows a very deep desire to repent and is almost driven to commit suicide: "...Ill seek him deeper than e'er plummer sounded, and with him there lie mudded" Alonso does admit his faults and shows his remorse for his wrongdoings but is there any part in the play where Prospero shows contrition? ...read more.


The worst use of his magic is that he uses it to control and manipulate all the main characters in the play except Miranda... Caliban and Ariel are enslaved under threats of cruel punishments by Prospero. Ferdinand's character is demeaned as he is forced to do menial tasks while he is Prospero's prisoner Alonzo, Sebastian and Antonio are driven into madness. Stephano and Trinculo are tormented by Prospero's spirits. The sailors are confined, fast asleep, below decks these are definitely not the acts of a magnanimous but a ruler who wants to colonise by power and not divine right. So, is Prospero a magnanimous ruler or a sadistic oppressive colonizer....? While prospero was in Milan he was the divine ruler, his people loved him and this was all done without the aid of magic to control people. However, when prospero arrives on the island he tries to take it by force off the original inhabitants and from Caliban, who is the ruler by right. The way in which he beats Caliban is cruel and the fact that he keeps everyone under control by force is an act of an oppressive coloniser. This is nothing short of what the European colonisers did to the native Americans. While Prospero is in Milan he has the divine right to govern and is a magnanimous ruler, but while on the island he thinks he is doing what is best, not what is right, and so has become in effect an oppressive ruler and coloniser who keeps people under his control force fully. . ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level The Tempest section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level The Tempest essays

  1. Character study of Prospero

    A good example of this is when he leaves his state to his brother: "and to him put The manage of my state;" Also another good example is seen when Prospero says: "The government I cast upon my brother." This is obviously very foolish as this is a lot of power to hand over to his brother.

  2. "The role of the teacher can often be a negative one" discuss…

    Whereas Caliban's only aim was creation, his purpose did not knowingly involve anyone being harmed. Prospero's treatment of Caliban might be more aptly equated with "a thing of darkness". Translations were written in 1980. It is set in Baele Beag and is written in a naturalistic style with symbolic elements.

  1. How Does Shakespeare Present the Realtionships With Ariel and Caliban

    has effectively given Ariel a second chance at life, by freeing him from the tree Sycorax imprisoned him in. However, Ariel has had to pay for such a chance by debt; whereas Caliban's generosity is rewarded with slavery. We know little about Ariel's life before Prospero arrived and freed him

  2. With reference to two or three episodes, explore Shakespeare's dramatic use and presentation of ...

    Hence Shakespeare presents Caliban in such a way that differs depending on the moral beliefs of the audience. Shakespeare's presentation of Caliban as being evil not capable of being anything other than evil is perhaps more believably shown in Act 4 scene 1, where Prospero is alone on stage, and

  1. Examine how Act 2 underlines the difficulties faced by a ruler such as Prospero?

    This idea of trust was raised in Act 1 Scene 2, where Prospero is explaining to Miranda the reasons behind his usurpation, "in my false brother/ Awaked an evil nature; and my trust like a good parent, did beget of him / A falsehood, in its contrary as great/ As

  2. The real monster in The Tempest is Prospero rather than Caliban" With particular reference ...

    This was done only ten years after The Tempest was written. Beginning with William Hazlitt (1818) many critics have seen The Tempest as a critique of European colonialism. Prospero is a colonist seizing the land of the natives and imposing European values, attitudes and the rule of European society upon them.

  1. "Prospero is a self-centred magician who demonstrates some of the worst qualities" Do you ...

    "This was well done my bird!" He has complete control over everyone on the island too: Miranda his daughter, Caliban his slave, Ariel his servant and all the courtiers and sailors he brought there with the help of the "tempest" he commanded Ariel to create. Everything that takes place on the island, he has knowledge of and is mostly in control of.

  2. European sense of superiority goes along with the ill attitude of the colonizer Prospero ...

    His treatment to Caliban and the spirits and his attitudes towards the island is highly condemnable in the present as it was in the contemporary time when this play was written. Prospero is crafty in his first attempt of survival and first step of colonization and used the rule of force.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work