• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is the plot of Measure for Measure a happy one? Does act 5 make it any happier?

Extracts from this document...


M.Judge 4 alpha/a Is the plot of Measure for Measure a happy one? Does act 5 make it any happier? Today 'comedy' can describe any number of productions or acts. We have a good understanding of satire, sarcasm and alternative comic methods and subversions. We are great fans of black humour and find almost anything funny if it is different and fresh. In Elizabethan times, however comedy was expected to adhere to particular traditional patterns. It usually comprised of a number of slightly manic, zany and indeed foolish characters juxtaposed with either the perfectly normal or humourless hard faced individuals who were usually mocked or taken advantage of by the other characters. The plays were usually based around a light hearted comic plot in which confusions or complexities were resolved before the end. This almost standard formula was often used by William Shakespeare. The other conventional aspects of traditional comic plots (inherited from classical Rome) involved young lovers, represented by Claudio and Juliet in Measure for Measure, who would overcome adversity to eventually marry by the final act. Although in this play Shakespeare, in Measure for Measure, deliberately uses elements of a traditional comic play but forces them together with a more serious insight into our notions of morality and indeed the questioning of law, justice and mercy. From the beginning of Measure for Measure we are shown a man who has been sentenced to death as he has got his girlfriend pregnant and has therefore had sex before wedlock. The situation of these two young lovers is used to raise questions concerning the justice system, law and morality. ...read more.


Angelo's morals are then placed under scrutiny as he who is supposedly the keen upholder of the laws is suggesting to a nun that they should have sex out of marriage which is precisely the thing the he has been trying to deter people from doing. This sudden turn in opinion not only makes us laugh due to his hypocrisy but also makes us question whether any character is this play has half decent morals and can uphold them. Next, though, the man that we feel great sympathy for due to the dire situation he is in, Claudio, pleads with his sister to sleep with Angelo when she returns saying that she will not and asks her to throw away her life as a nun making him, the object of our sympathy, seem as bad as Angelo in his moral reasoning. It shows him to be hugely selfish. All of this is comical in its content and indeed makes us laugh due to its idiotic logic but when we find ourselves laughing at this situation we realise that this is not a laughing matter at all as the characters are playing with a man's life and losing almost every piece of moral standing which at first we thought he had. There actions may appear comical but the consequences of these action are very serous indeed. In setting up this situation Shakespeare forces us to decide in what way we would deal with it and indeed if we have empathy with any one of the characters. We must decide as to what the morally right thing to do is. ...read more.


This is hugely ironic as the whole play is based around the grave situation that he is in and how severe the situation is for him but at the end of the play he goes free and is given exactly what he wants an incredibly is punished the least. All of these things make us shake our heads at the foolishness of this conclusion and indeed the Duke's perverse way in dealing with everybody. All of the other marriages seem to punish the people who either have good intentions, Mariana and Isabelle, and reward the crooks, the Duke and Angelo. Lucio, however, appears to be punished fairly in a very ironic way as he, the bawd, is forced to marry a woman of equal moral dubiousness and is therefore punished to spend a life time with the person that he used for sex. Ironically he will have a life time of sex with this person which strangely seems far less appealing after they are married. The final straw in the Duke's massive foolishness and naivety is the point where he assumes he can marry Isabella. Completely out of the blue this leaves us open mouthed as the curtain closes. Shakespeare in this play has taken a serious plot and turned it into a farcical mockery of all comedic plays. Then act five does not make the play a happier one. The skilled way in which Shakespeare forces a very serious issue of morality into a comedic frame not only make us laugh but does something more. It makes us question our views on morality and upholding the law without seeming deliberate or overt. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Measure for Measure section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Measure for Measure essays

  1. Discuss the theme of deception and disguise in the play "Measure for Measure."

    through lack of concern it was never used to its full power and now it is mocked because people know they can get away with anything. The people "pluck justice by the nose" implying that because they are seemingly free to do what they want they can laugh at the principles of law and order.

  2. 'A complex character deserving of sympathy'. To what extent do you agree with this ...

    into trusting him enough to give him power over Vienna and then immediately condemns Claudio to death for impregnating his lover, despite his genuine love for her.

  1. In measure for measure,the characters of Angelo and Isabella are similar.discuss

    the play is only allowed to come to an end only at the moment of exact equivalence between Isabella and Angelo. It only ends s when Isabella has really become the thing she has argued for in Act II, merciful' (against all sense" the duke points out).

  2. "Measure for Measure is a play without any truly sympathetic characters". To what extent ...

    strict restraint upon the sisters stood, the votarists of Saint Clare", would have been seen as a sympathetic and admirable trait to members of Shakespeare's early seventeenth century audiences, particularly in the more academic circles to which this play was more commonly performed.

  1. Consider the Attitudes To Women Demonstrated In the Vienna of Measure For Measure.

    the two women results in his exultation and their continued lack of choice, as he marries Mariana to Angelo and demands Isabella's own hand in marriage. This lack of respect for women's own abilities to make choices renders them powerless over even their own lives.

  2. In Measure for Measure, Shakespeare forces questions to be asked about a wide range ...

    However, these preconceptions of Lucio are as quickly demolished by Shakespeare as they were established, and the true character of Lucio is rapidly revealed. He talks of the 'sanctimonious pirate' who conveniently erased 'Thou shalt not steal' from the Ten Commandments, and surprises the audience with a 'worldly realism (-Rachel Redford)'

  1. The principalcharacters in 'Measure for Measure' are motivated by personal gain.' How far would ...

    altruistic move, or because he does not wish to lead the country into any more corruption, or has he deliberately put his opposite in power so people learn to appreciate his permissiveness? Isabella is the pillar of restraint in the town, an ironic contrast to her brother Claudio, who is being sentenced to death for impregnating his girlfriend.

  2. What do you find dramatically interesting about Shakespeare's presentation of the Duke in the ...

    This scene reveals a private side to the Duke's character; we see that the Duke acknowledges his flaw and weakness in his governing of Vienna. We also see a more devious and manipulative side to him, his testing of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work