• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Life on the Western Front - Sources Questions

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

History coursework - Life on the Western Front The First World War was a shattering experience for all Europeans, both soldiers and civilians. Memoirs show that soldiers expressed a wide variety of views on the war. Some soldiers enjoyed the war and some hated it, but most were unable to decide how they felt about it. In this essay I will be examining whether or not official accounts of the Western Front more accurate than personal accounts. I will survey several sources and try to draw a conclusion. Soldiers in the war were allowed little correspondence. Their letters and postcards sent home were censored to the point of very little detail. They were only allowed to write about family, friends and their health, as can be seen on the field service postcard, source A1. The honour clause was a statement all soldiers had to sign to confirm they were not writing about anything else other than private family matters. The honour clause also gave the officials permission to examine the contents of the postcard/letter e.g. 'Green envelope' source A2. The officials censored letters and postcards because they didn't want people back home to know too much and also because they didn't want the Germans to accidentally find out their plans. ...read more.

Middle

Sources B9-B13 are more gruesome compared to the sources in the official account. The reasons for the difference are officials wanted to conceal all the gruesome deaths that the British soldiers had and only took photos of their peaceful deaths. I think photos, official and personal, are quite accurate as source of information on the Western Front for a variety of purposes. Punch was a British humorous political magazine. It contained anti-German propaganda. The main purpose of political cartoons is to get a message across in a more entertaining way. I think source A10 is very useful to historians studying soldiers' attitudes to life on the Western Front because it shows that soldiers were pessimistic and found trench life difficult to handle. I don't think source A13 is reliable. This is because the cartoon was taken from a British political magazine and the Germans were the enemy so they would have wanted to make the Germans look bad. There are a few hints of bias in sources A14 and A15, for example "Our operations, in conjunction with the French, definitely stopped the German attack, and it has not since been removed." ...read more.

Conclusion

To prevent this from spreading the soldiers rubbed whale oil on to their feet everyday. Being bitten by lice was also very common in the trenches. They tried to prevent this by running a lighted candle along the seams of their clothing but this only killed the lice, not their eggs. The lice carried a disease called trench fever. I think sources A9, B3, B13 would be most useful to historians wanting to find out about the morale of the soldiers. The people today view the war a lot differently compared to the people who lived through it. When you step back and take a closer look at the picture you see things differently. Overall, I have a fairly accurate view of life on the Western Front from looking at personal and official accounts. I have found both, official and personal, accounts useful. I can't really put together an accurate picture of what life on the Western Front was actually like using personal accounts because the soldiers may not remember what happened to give an accurate description and would be bias against Germans. The official account has been censored so that also is not really reliable. Therefore I think that by looking at both accounts would give a clearer picture. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level War Poetry essays

  1. World War One Trench Warfare Sources Questions

    source G, because the dates on the sources are both in July 1916, and they both talk about the "Surreys" playing football. Source F & G showed that they were having fun (playing football), and so it raised the morale of the people back at home.

  2. Why is it so difficult to know what soldiers thought? ...

    that they would not get too wet although some of the trenches didn't have duck boards so the soldiers did get wet and sometimes it was waist high the water so they would also be freezing. We know how bad life in the trenches was because many soldiers had described

  1. What Was Life Really Like In The Trenches On The Western Front

    Ever now and again there were 'dead end trenches'. The entire trench system for the triple entente was dug in zigzags so that when enemy shells dropped onto the trenches it only damaged a little area and not a massive area that would wipe out several men. They were also dug in zigzags so that if enemy soldiers captured

  2. The western front - source related questions and answers

    In the source Coppard's mentions there being hundreds of dead bodies all over no mans land, I know that this really happened because in the first two days of the Somme over 50.000 soldiers were killed. Coppard also says that the plan was a bad Idea, that any ordinary British

  1. The Western Front.

    Inside The Trenches: The construction of the trenches varied. The front line trenches were usually about seven feet deep and six feet wide. The front of the trench was known as the parapet and the rear of the trench was known as the parados. The top two or three feet of the trench would consist of a thick line of sandbags to absorb bullets or shell fragments.

  2. The Trenches on the Western Front.

    There is only one word to describe the trenches in world war one is Disgusting. They were just gross and so unhygienic. The trenches were about the about 7ft tall. They had duckbords on the bottom to stop the soldiers from getting wet, this didn't work because the water level rose to the soldiers knee level.

  1. "Poems and stories; official accounts. Which of these give a more accurate picture of ...

    and soldiers attitudes to the war. I will use a wide range of sources including poems, official accounts, stories and soldiers' accounts. I expect to find that official accounts do not always give an entirely accurate picture, as they were produced by the government for propaganda purposes, with the intention of boosting people's morale back home in Britain.

  2. How Did the Blitz Affect Everyday Life in Britain?

    Gas masks on babies were frightening and they hated being inside. They were airtight. Somebody would need to pump oxygen into the mask. If they stopped at anytime, the baby could suffocate. Even new-born babies had gas masks. Mothers often worried for their child.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work