• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Many would argue that men hold the power in "The Colour Purple". Explore the opinions of critics Andrea Stuart and Mary O' Connor and explain your own view of what Alice Walker has to say about the power in "The Colour Purple".

Extracts from this document...


Many would argue that men hold the power in "The Colour Purple". Explore the opinions of critics Andrea Stuart and Mary O' Connor and explain your own view of what Alice Walker has to say about the power in "The Colour Purple". In the novel 'The Colour Purple' power is represented differently throughout. One way in which this power is shown is through men in the novel. At the beginning men dominate and are depicted as a higher authority figure to women, it seems the men rule the women's lives. However we can also argue that women are equally strong whilst others evolve into more powerful figures. Power through sisterhood is demonstrated through the fact that Shug gives Celie companionship, something Celie may not have felt since she was separated from her sister Nettie. Through Celie and Shug's relationship Celie has gained strength in herself and has been shown to stick up for herself. We see this when Shug announces she is taking Celie and Mary Agnes with her as Celie stands up to Albert. This shows us Celie is learning to become independent. This represents one aspect of female power in the novel and it also shows that by having friends to support them these women are able to leave their "lowdown dogs" behind and with the belief in themselves they can build their own future. Female solidarity is shown where we see Celie's protection for her mother and sister Nettie. Although she has no real proof on whether Nettie is alive and well, she never stops believing she will one day be reunited with her sister. From this we can see that if men had the will power and strength the women do in the novel, they would be able to make their hard and miserable life easier and more bearable. Celie after everything she has been through and all the misery she has been put through by various characters mainly male's, she still has hope and can see a brighter future for herself and to be reunited with her sister and become a family. ...read more.


The threat from Alphonso supports Stuart's perception that men are "mostly troublesome, sometimes cruel." Alphonso here has shown a psychological strength because by threatening her, he's forced her into not speaking to other people about any of her problems and teaching her to keep all her problems to herself. However he is not aware that Celie writing to god allows her to offload and share her problems with someone other than herself. O' Connor says that Celie's "existence to be denied" this explains that in her rape experience and also in the fact that she has a lack of voice she is therefore not able to share her bad experience with anyone. However I think she is able to express her feelings through writing so is therefore giving herself a voice and existence which goes against what O' Connor states. Walker shows Alphonso's psychological power over Celie in the beginning of her writing letters. Celie crossed out "I am". This is almost as if she is crossing herself out. She changes it to, "I have always been a good girl". It seems that Celie is taking the blame for what Alphonso has done to her. This is the first time we see an authority figure abuse Celie which reinforces male dominance in her life. The rape not only shows physical power strength and power but also emotional authority, due to Celie's naivety, for his own pleasure. Another time in the novel in which we see Alphonso's power over Celie is when he is trying to get rid of her by marrying her off. However it's more like he is selling her as they barter, he even throws in a cow. This again relates back and shows how black females in this time period were still being treated as slaves. O' Connor tells us her "feminist analysis is interested in the voices", as it's a male dominated conversation where Celie only gets in a few words on a highly important decision which can affect her whole life. ...read more.


It's all she knows and therefore she believes it's normal. Power and the placement of it is also shown in the African part of the novel and it is through these tribes we are able to compare Celie with the traditional African way of life. The Olinka's, one of the main tribes that are introduced to us, hold the power of life and death over their wives. The men are also looked upon as better than women in the tribe. The structure of power in that who holds it and who doesn't in the tribe is also shown in Celie's life through her being raped and that fact she is not able to enjoy sex with her partner Albert, "I know what he doing to me he done to Shug Avery and maybe she like it". The fact that she cannot enjoy it may be cause by Celie's feelings and emotions towards male's as she has been abused by them all her life. This is supported by Stuarts view that "men are never the source of emotional sustenance or long term happiness for women. However this is does not seem true for Shug as she looks happy with her male partners, this may be because she always seems to have control over her relationships. In conclusion I can say that in the beginning of 'The Colour Purple' it is the men who hold all the power, however as new characters' are introduced it is slightly more balanced as Shug and Sofia speak there mind and stand up to any man. Also later Celie and Squeak both stand up for themselves, they take control of the situation but also take away the power from the men and hold it themselves. At the beginning of the novel Celie writes to God, she then starts writing to her sister Nettie, this shows a change in her and in the end all her hopes pay off as she breaks away from her abusing husband and lives with her family; her sister Nettie and her kids with Shug. ?? ?? ?? ?? Amar Raithatha Page 1 of 7 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Alice Walker section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Alice Walker essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Alice Walkers depiction of men in The Color Purple has been controversial - Explore ...

    4 star(s)

    Brown then admits that some black men are like Walker's characters, he says they are but, "...sad examples..." He also says the book focuses only on the failings of black men, and that black men are being abused by a white mans movie.

  2. What are the main themes of Pleasantville and how does the director convey them ...

    Soon, the group have decided to tackle the 'problem'. The first sign of trouble is in the bowling alley, where Bob makes his first speech. Here, essentially racism is highlighted using cinematic techniques as Bob makes his speech. For example, the audience are aware that Bob is an important man because of the angle that the camera faces him.

  1. Examine the author's presentation of men, women and gender roles in 'The Color Purple' ...

    This style creates sympathy as she also writes with the rhythm of speech, which ultimately creates vast hatred and disgust toward the father, who is dominating and abusing an innocent child. Similarly Winterson also creates the innocence of the child protagonist in her novel, through the fact that she believe

  2. Gender roles in The Color Purple.

    Miss Beasley, one of Nettie's teachers, describes Africa as "a place overrun with savages who didn't wear clothes." (137). She portrays Africa as a dirty place, foreshadowing a place where subordination would exist. This statement is somewhat true to the clothes that women in the Olinka tribe wear.

  1. Explore how the Film 'Cool Runnings' Utilises Colour Imagery.

    Unity is shown mainly in Derise, Ul-brenner, and Junior. This is because they are the serious Olympic competitors. Unity through colour is shown very early on in the film in the Jamaicans Olympic 100m sprint try-outs. Together Derise, Ul-brenner, and Junior are sporting the Jamaicans flag colours.

  2. Alice Walker Uses Symbolism to Address Three Issues: Racism, Feminism and the Search for ...

    unattached to the "Black Power" movement held by her, purportedly educated, daughter Dee. Mama's daughter, Dee (Wangero), has a much more superficial idea of heritage. She is portrayed as bright, beautiful, and self-centered. Maggie is the younger daughter, who lives with Mama.

  1. Alice Walker's novel "The Third Life of Grange Copeland" - review

    in the transient embraces of strangers."(XI: pg20). Grange is unwilling to show any responsibilities to his family, he is free to move and do as he chooses. Margaret, however is portrayed as being trapped by her circumstances and responsibilities, she can not leave everything behind her and start again as he can.

  2. Maya Angelou - I Know Why The Caged Bird Sings.

    Even though this is possibly true and Maya questions this, she still defends her mother. It is Maya that makes the first attack on Dolores; Maya justifies her behaviour, which leaves her looking the better person. 'What did she expect if she called my mother a whore?'

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work