• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Marlowe's Mephistophilis is a brilliant but ultimately unsatisfactory creation because Marlowe cannot decide whether to make him a gleeful medieval devil or a romantically suffering fallen angel

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Marlowe's Mephistophilis is a brilliant but ultimately unsatisfactory creation because Marlowe cannot decide whether to make him a gleeful medieval devil or a romantically suffering fallen angel." Discuss the presentation of Mephistophilis in the light of this statement. Mephistophilis is a striking central character in the play 'Doctor Faustus', written by Christopher Marlowe in the late sixteenth century. His role in this flamboyant yet tragic play is ultimately to aid Faustus' downfall from renowned scholar to foolhardy prey of Lucifer. However, Mephistophilis' motives are perceptibly ambiguous throughout 'Doctor Faustus'; he seemingly alternates between a typically gleeful medieval devil, and a romantically suffering fallen angel. Mephistophilis first appears in 'Doctor Faustus' in the third scene, when he is summoned by Faustus' experimental necromancy, as taught to him by Valdes and Cornelius. Faustus becomes intrigued by the notion of employing dark magic to supply him with what he most craves: knowledge. Mephistophilis first appears to Faustus in his true, terrifying form (suggested on the Elizabethan stage by a lowered dragon). This wholly terrifying image is in keeping with the medieval concept of the devil as a hellish supernatural being that encapsulated horror. Mephistophilis' appearance shocks Faustus to the extent that he implores him to return in a different form, this time as an "old Franciscan friar". This embodiment epitomises much of the confusion concerning the devil's character: although the costume of a friar is seemingly unpretentious and reassuring (and, for Marlowe's contemporaries, a daring anti-catholic joke), in a stage performance of 'Doctor Faustus' the raised hood and floor-length robe is ominous and chilling. ...read more.

Middle

tells us he: "...Did mount him up to scale Olympus' top, Where, sitting in a chariot burning bright Drawn by the strength of yoked dragons' necks, He views the clouds, the planets and the stars..." On stage, Faustus largely uses his powers for simple jokes, with Mephistophilis acting as a gleeful sidekick. Together they dress as cardinals and fool the Pope by snatching his food at a banquet, even boxing him on the ear. This highlights the wickedly jovial aspects of Mephistophilis perfectly, as he gleefully wreaks havoc on the Catholic figurehead alongside Faustus. In terms of the structure of the play, this provides entertainment for the audience (who would find anti-Catholic jokes amusing considering the anti-Catholic mood of the general public in England at the time of publication of 'Doctor Faustus') in the middle of a relatively long play that raises many serious issues. Other examples of Mephistophilis' gleeful disposition are when together with Faustus he plants horns on Benvolio, and when they trick the horse-courser by selling him a horse that dissolves into hay when it comes into contact with water. This idea of the devil as comic relief is very much in keeping with the medieval tradition. 'Doctor Faustus' is of course, in one basic sense, a morality fable, and it is a characteristic of such plays predominantly to feature characters that are personified abstractions (such as the Seven deadly Sins or the Good and Bad Angels) ...read more.

Conclusion

Hell hath no limits, nor is circumscrib'd In one self place, but where we are is hell, And where hell is, there must we ever be." This, in fact, is another inconsistency in Marlowe's presentation of Mephistophilis and the concept of hell, for in the final scene of the play, Faustus is physically dragged, not to this metaphysical hell, but to a vast perpetual torture-house" where there are "tossing damned souls on burning forks" and "ever-burning chairs". This striking difference is supplemented by Mephistophilis' reversion in the final scenes of the play to the simply and utterly terrifying devil Faustus first encountered in his initial necromantic experiments. This sharply contrasts with the gleeful and mischievous Mephistophilis seen throughout the middle comic scenes of 'Doctor Faustus', and adds to the ambiguity of the character. In conclusion, I feel that Mephistophilis is a wonderfully multi-dimensional character, developed in an intriguing manner that makes the devil intensely unpredictable and thrilling. The sharp contrast between his fiendishly gleeful qualities and the aspects that suggest a romantically suffering angel fallen from grace, in my opinion, make the character much more absorbing. Perhaps Marlowe realised that the most captivating characters could never remain one-dimensional. Although many critics are unhappy with the apparent inconsistencies, I think it is the combination of the gleeful and tormented aspects of the character that make him the central masterpiece of 'Doctor Faustus'. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Christopher Marlowe section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Christopher Marlowe essays

  1. Doctor Faustus -a morality play? we will discuss how the Renaissance tragedy Doctor Faustus ...

    concurs with the Bad Angel about Faustus' damnation, suggesting the opportunities for repentance and hence salvation have, for the most part, slipped Faustus by without him choosing to repent. Thus unlike in the traditional Morality, where good triumphs over evil and salvation proves more powerful than damnation, Faustus' death and damnation are the closing notes of the play.

  2. Comment on the relationship between the comic and serious material in Dr Faustus.

    Because of the severity of this scene and the shocking effect it would have had on the audience, the small amount of comedy at the end of the scene may have been welcomed. During Scene six the two Ostlers, Robin and Rafe plan to use a magic book that they

  1. Faustus epitomises the dangers of knowledge without morality. Do you agree?

    confuses the spiritual with the intellectual world with regard to the reason for his damnation in his vow to redeem himself, 'I'll burn my books!' He still does not appear to recognise the nature of his sins. Faustus purports to know the nature of faith as a teacher of theology,

  2. Would You Consider Doctor Faustus to be a Medieval Morality Play or a Renaissance ...

    In the medieval era that preceded the Renaissance, the focus of scholarship was on God and theology, so the Prologue locates its drama squarely in the Renaissance world, where humanistic values hold sway. The Chorus insists, we will focus not on ancient battles between Rome and Carthage, nor on the

  1. How far would you say that the novel is not so much about Brighton ...

    Prewitt, although successful has become ill and discontented, he tells the boy that his possibility of conviction is nothing compared to Prewitt's present life: "The worst that can happen to you is you'll hang. But I can rot." Prewitt is portrayed by Green as the effect of staying in Brighton to gain power (like Pinkie is doing)

  2. What does the play show us about attitudes to sin and damnation?

    There are some things in the text that might point to a more unconventional reading. Marlowe could be showing God to be judgmental and someone you can't turn to for comfort. We can explore the attitudes towards damnation by looking at how hell and damnation are represented in the play.

  1. Discuss the presentation of Faustus' inner conflict in Act 1 scene 5 of Doctor ...

    Towards the middle of Scene 5, the "Good" and "Evil" Angels make their last appearance until a later stage in the play. The "Good" Angel tries to make Faustus repent, whereas the "Evil" Angel tells Faustus that "if thou repent, devils shall tear thee in pieces".

  2. "In Dr Faustus Marlowe is only incidentally concerned with the state of Faustus' soul: ...

    (I, 45). At the time Dr Faustus was written there were a number of different religious beliefs on how to seek pardon from God. The Calvinist belief was that God condemns people from birth, and only the chosen ones can seek repentance, on 'the other hand, the Catholic church and

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work