• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Merchant's Tale - Marriage'

Extracts from this document...


To what extent do you agree that The Merchant's Prologue and Tale is merely a cynical attack on marriage? Geoffrey Chaucer's presentation of marriage throughout The Canterbury Tales is, indeed, varied, abstract and supplemented by dispute over the sincerity of specific works. This literary inconsistency is strongly evident in The Merchant's Tale, making it essential to address the disparity of its message on the topic of marriage. It could initially be assumed that the poem is not solely a cynical attack on marriage; Chaucer offers a somewhat objective overview of the issue, purveyed by the obvious difference in opinion of its characters, for example; the merchant in the prologue - 'we wedded men live in sorwe and care'1 - and Januarie's opinion - 'in this world it [marriage] is a paradis'2 - or the differing judgements of both Justinus - 'it is no childes pley'3 - and Placebo - 'Dooth now in this matiere right as yow leste'4 - after Januarie's consultation with them. By addressing the fact that the message fluctuates it could be argued that Chaucer offers multiple compatible interpretations. Should we interpret the opinion of Placebo in the same way as we should Justinus, or do the subsequent events of the Tale prove to us that we should primarily concern ourselves with the view of the more reasoned, objective character - the name 'Justinus' implies a judicial figure? ...read more.


Indeed, Januarie outlines that he intends to take a wife for the purpose of begetting an heir and engaging in sexual activity by pious and legal means, as opposed to his previous 'bodily delit on wommen'9 as a 'wyfless man'10: 'A man may do no synne with his wyf, Ne hurte hymselven with his owene knyf; For we han leve to pleye us by the lawe'11 Januarie here (seemingly contrary to Chaucer's own views as addressed later) seems to view, in hindsight, sex outside marriage as spiritually and legally damaging, through the metaphor of a stabbing. This statement is preceded by Chaucer's somewhat vulgar description of Januarie during his night with May, with 'thikke brustles'12 and 'the skin of houndfissh'13 - hinting roughness - as well as reference to 'his paradis'14 - suggesting that the pleasure lay solely with the male part. This is compounded by a loathsome image of: '...upright in his bed thane sitteth he, And after that he sang ful loude and cleere, And kiste his wif, and made wantown cheere'15 Which can easily be compared to a victory cry. Whether his joy arises due to a perceived redemption for his previous sexual activity as opposed to personal, appetital means is, of course, still open to debate. ...read more.


This is further supported by the fantastical, burlesque final scene, the ridiculous proposition of a sexual encounter occurring in a tree, the persistent mockery of Januarie, and the substitution of the Christian God in a garden for Pluto and Proserpina - their relationship incidentally comprising a non-consensual marriage and irregular relief, in parallel to Januarie and May. This instigates a fundamental question; is Chaucer's presentation of marriage in The Merchant's Tale meant to be addressed with any sincerity? Not only this but the fact that the Tale is narrated by Chaucer's assumption of character, the merchant, writing from an angle by which property and ownership is of sole importance, means that lines such as: 'Ne take no wyf,' quod he, 'for housbondrye, As for to spare in household hey dispence. A true servant Dooth moore dilligence'23 Must merely be seen as merchant's interpretation other than an actual purveyance of Chaucer's opinion towards the matter. Ultimately, The Merchant's Tale's message is too diluted for it to be by any means a planned, systematic attack on the concept of marriage. ___________ 21 Cambridge School Chaucer: The Merchant's Prologue and Tale, Edited by Sheila Innes, p. 107 22 Cambridge School Chaucer: The Merchant's Prologue and Tale, Edited by Sheila Innes, p. 107 23 The Merchant's Prologue and Tale, l. 84-6 ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Geoffrey Chaucer section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Geoffrey Chaucer essays

  1. The pardoners prologue and Tale show human nature to lack any redeeming virtues ...

    This is massively ironic on many levels as firstly, he is a member of the church and therefore should be learned in all sins, knowing not to commit any. Secondly, he preaches about this very sin to his congregation whilst committing it himself on a daily basis through the sale of fake relics.

  2. A sinister exploration of the nature of evil Discuss Chaucers poetic methods in ...

    The repeated suggestion of a brotherhood and addressing each other as brethren has underlying irony as each rioter is ultimately killed by each other's greed. It has been suggested that as the rioters are not named, and therefore are nt personally addressed, that they have been constructed to suggest the embodiment of sin.

  1. Chaucer creates humour by satirising values in religious and courtly love. To what extent ...

    Another aspect of courtly love is the 'Religion of Love' which basically means that the courtly lover must accomplish his lust in order to be cured. The Merchant shows his dislike of the idea and mocks May's decision to save Damian from dying of lust by granting him 'hire grace'.

  2. Themes and Ideas in The Merchant's Tale

    This is a story Chaucer's target audience would we have been aware of. The Merchant shows the Knight being fond of marriage, but at the same time is taking a dig at women for causing the downfall of mankind, and implying this is what will happen if the Knight marries.

  1. Analysis of lines 125 - 300 of The Merchant's Tale

    This passage was possibly included by the Merchant to subtle attack women while appearing to praise them. The imagery of nature in the tale such as the references to gardens and Januarie's comparison of himself to a tree 'I fare dooth a tree, that blosmeth er that fruyt ywoxen bee'

  2. Quotes from the Miller's Tale

    as cunning, secretive, courteous and charming since he is mostly cunning in this tale we can sense the Miller's approval of him through this word "Hadde lerned arte, but al his fantasie was turned for to lerne astrologie"p33 Knowledgeable and clever-fashionable at the time and was something Chaucer was interested

  1. Discuss how the concept of courtly love is represented in the Franklin's tale.

    The very concept of him lying on a bed weeping for two years is a clear exaggeration; this raises the idea that Chaucer meant this as a parody of courtly love, a way of mocking the overreactions and melodrama associated with it.

  2. Chaucer is successful in creating humour in the Wife of Baths prologue and tale.

    before marriage, as temptation to do so was as strong in those days as nowadays. It is witty that the wife of Bath uses this to justify her reason for marrying five times. She is implying to the audience that every time she wants to have sex with a man,

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work