• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

More than our brother is our chastity How far do you find yourself able to condone Isabellas point of view

Extracts from this document...


?More than our brother is our chastity? How far do you find yourself able to condone Isabella?s point of view John 15:13 says: ?Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends?. In the traditional Christian Elizabethan society; this sentiment would have been revered; Shakespeare?s Puritanical and Catholic audiences would have loved the ideas of self-sacrifice and the immediate ascension into heaven. However, in Measure for Measure, Shakespeare manages to challenge this verse; he manipulates the situations and then causes the audience to digest the complexity of the verse, and causes the audience to question whether Isabella?s estimation that fornicating to save the life of another is not only morally wrong and a direct rebuttal of Jesus? sentiment; but a damning sin. Isabella?s introduction into the play arouses intrigue in audiences and readers, as she is described as having a ?speechless dialect/Such as move men?; so it is expected that audiences and readers would be waiting with bated breath fro Isabella to meet Angelo; and Shakespeare does not disappoint. The scene is written in blank verse, with unrhymed lines of iambic pentameter; Isabella first line is not quite metrically even; the word honour cannot be properly stressed, and that falter changes the rhythm of her speech. ...read more.


The Duchess is portrayed as sensual and aware of her sexuality, but is still able to become the embodiment of Christian virtue. In some ways Isabella and the Duchess are strikingly similar, but where The Duchess is overtly sexual, Isabella ? like Angelo, has a moral compass that causes her to view situations as either Black or White, with no in-between {Insert quotation here} Isabella may therefore represent the difficulties of being a model of virtue, and of holding strict values of chastity and restraint whilst upholding sometimes contrasting principles of mercy and compassion. These themes would have been relevant in Jacobean society, as puritan values ? which Isabella's devotion may represent ? were becoming increasingly influential politically and socially, for instance the theatres of the suburbs were at times closed by puritan intervening. Furthermore, the play's genre of problem play allows for moral dilemmas to be raised and viewed from both sides. Therefore although seems to Isabella demonstrate a struggle to become ideally virtuous, it cannot be said definitively whether she succeeds as Angelo brings to light an equally challenging view ?Is there no charity in sin?? However, it could be argued that modern values make it difficult for todays? audience and readers to full grasp the gravity of Isabella?s situation. ...read more.


The imagery of the "unsoiled" name implies that Angelo's power stems from his past reputation, in that no one would believe that he would be capable of succumbing to the same weaknesses as other's. This point is mirrored in the "Duchess of Malfi" in which the Cardinal places his power in his reputation as no one expects him to be a fornicator as his position supposedly attests to his morality. In conclusion, Isabella's conflict in the play has a deep moral centre. She wants to become a nun, but can only save her brother's life by surrendering her chastity to Angelo. When she says, "More than our brother is our chastity? I believe she is not being cruel or selfish, but trying very hard to adhere to an ingrained sense morality, and unlike many characters in the play, she sticks to her values and her faith; and this might seem foreign even to some Elizabethan audiences, as in some cases, representations of women of this time can be seen as being limited to idolised virgins, or sexual women who were often demonised as whores. So, because Isabella is not a perfect religious ideal, but as a woman with flaws who is placed in a difficult situation, and tries to achieve the best outcome; it is easy to respect her. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Measure for Measure section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Measure for Measure essays

  1. Measure for Measure: The fault of Isabella is that she is excessively pious and ...

    Isabella shows how serious her spiritual life is to her when she becomes distraught as a result of Claudio's proposal to agree with Angelo's demands. 'O you beast!

  2. Consider the Attitudes To Women Demonstrated In the Vienna of Measure For Measure.

    Juliet: I do confess it, and repent it, father. Although the Duke is here posing as a friar, either he is adopting the attitude of the church he is representing, or he is following his own moral code. By going along with the church's belief Shakespeare is using him to show the patriarchal set-up of the religion in Vienna.

  1. William Shakespeare - The Comedy of errors - Dromio concludes the play - "We ...

    His two sons (twins) both named Antipholus. "A joyful mother of two goodly sons, and which was strange, the one so like the other." These twins are two extremely important characters creating the main aspect of confusion of identity throughout the play.

  2. What might modern audiences find dramatically interesting about the presentation of the Duke in ...

    This is when the Duke begins to try and convince Isabella to "help" Mariana. He says: "It is a rupture that you may easily heal" and tells her it is in her best interests, and her brother's, to do so.

  1. Comment on Shakespeare's conclusion to 'Measure for Measure'

    After provoking much humiliation in the major players, the Duke marries Angelo to Mariana, reunites Claudio with Juliet and proposes to Isabella. I will now explain how the conclusion to the play and characters in the conclusion are relevant to the whole play and why Shakespeare ended the play like this.

  2. Is the plot of Measure for Measure a happy one? Does act 5 make ...

    He asks if we would prefer to let Claudio go free, thus breaking a clearly stated law, or have him killed which seems highly extreme. He puts us into a situation where in essence we must decide if we agree with the loose keeping of the law by the Duke

  1. An investigation into the death of the Duchess of Ferera

    We then talked to Miss Smith as she will be able to help us determine the character of the Duke and we thought that she could have committed the murder because she was jealous of her. We interrogated the count as he could help us determine the character of his daughter, Miss Smith.

  2. Compare at least four poems from the ones you have studied where a strong ...

    We learn that the Duke is very particular about who sees the portrait of the Duchess and we wonder if this has significance in the reason for the Duchess murder. Although we assume from the poem that the Duke murdered the Duchess the Duke never says unambiguously or openly that

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work