• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Murmuring Judges

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Re-read Act 2, Scene 5 and discuss how Hare uses Sir Peter and Irina to convey the judicial system David Hare's play 'Murmuring Judges' examines the legal system in Britain as it was at the end of the eighties, beginning of the nineties of the last century, by looking at the trial, conviction and appeal of Gerard McKinnon, a getaway driver, from several viewpoints: that of the police, that of the barristers and judges, and that of the convicted man himself. In Act 2, Scene 5 we see how Irina Platt, a junior just starting to make her way in the legal profession, finally stand up to her silk and mentor, Sir Peter Edgecombe, over the impending appeal of their client. Sir Peter Edgecombe represents the Establishment, and is extremely happy with the status quo. Irina, a young black woman, has throughout the play been trying to reconcile her ideals and principles with making her way in her chosen profession. It has been made clear to her by Woody, the clerk at her chambers, that it will be much easier for her to progress and flourish if she plays the game. In this scene she decides that the price for always remaining silent is too high, and she confronts Sir Peter with some damning accusations of complacency and prejudice. The scene opens with Irina telling Woody that she has been trying to track Sir Peter down but he has been very elusive. ...read more.

Middle

He says, patronisingly 'Irina, you have been my dinner date. You simply cannot be this na�ve.' He goes on to tell her that the police will simply close ranks, that a better name than police force would be police club, because that's what it is. The implication being that as a member of this 'club' your first loyalty is to your fellow members, rather than to any idea of 'justice.' This shows Sir Peter's cynicism. He explodes when Irina talks about what's right but seems to view the idea of an essentially corrupt police force with equanimity. At this point in the scene Irina, who has always been courteous and even deferential to Sir Peter, raises her voice and accuses him of not believing Gerard's account of what happened. He freely admits that he doesn't, as 'he's fighting for his life,' and so will do what he must, and say anything that will help his own case, 'then find someone who'll swallow it whole.' He is implying that Irina has been manipulated by her client. He underlines the wealth of his own experience by telling Irina that he has 'represented dozens of people like him.' We see Irina's anger increase when she sees how Sir Peter doesn't view his criminal clients as individuals but as a 'type' - which he defines as 'an ordinary, slightly sub-average human being who had landed himself in a damn stupid mess.' He smiles at her outrage at this immensely patronising and snobbish evaluation as for him this is just so much enjoyable sparring, but Irina refuses to ...read more.

Conclusion

Irina's race and gender mean she is not part of the old boy's club to which most barristers and judges seem to be a part of. So she can look at them with objectivity. She has been prepared to try and blend in, to play by the rules, but in this scene she can bear it no more and challenges the lazy orthodoxies that Sir Peter tries to defend. He in his turn finds her idealism hopelessly na�ve. He is not a completely appalling character: we can see that he is genuinely fond of his pupil, and he has never made any sexual advances towards her, he just enjoys his colleagues assuming that he has. Hare is too subtle a writer to make him corrupt. Sir Peter does not need to break the rules, as he does very well by them: it is the system itself that is flawed. As Irina makes clear, civil cases, such as libel, pay massively better than criminal ones, so it pays the barristers to prepare well and at length. The rewards being not so great, in spite of Sir Peter's protestations, criminal clients are not as well represented. Irina shows her integrity when she risks losing Sir Peter's favour and patronage by standing up to him and challenging his attitudes. She has been silent long enough and now she must speak out. This is a powerful scene because we see a strong and intelligent woman stand up for the underdog from within a profession where, Hare suggests, complacency and privilege seem to be still very much the norm. ?? ?? ?? ?? 3 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Play Writes section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Play Writes essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Re-read Act 2 Scene 6 of Murmuring Judges. Discuss Hares presentation of the position ...

    3 star(s)

    the audience members' minds throughout, hence the mistakes which the audience remembers are caused by males, influencing them to form an inclination, conscious or unconscious, against the males, who tend to be corrupt and self-serving. It is the two focal females in 'Murmuring Judges', Sandra and Irina, who actively try

  2. Discuss Hares use of Sir Peter as a criticism of societys legal system in ...

    evinces his overly conservative mind-set and obstinacy to accept modern views and facts. He "points to her", which, needless to say, would be judged as rude by the audience, hence making evident Sir Peter's volatile temperament and stubbornness when faced with what is, effectively, pure truth.

  1. Explore the ways R.C. Sherriff presents the attitudes of key characters in 'Journey's ...

    them enough when they were at home, which is how May feels about Tom, and, in a way, how Eva feels about Ralph. Even though Eva is able to form the outline of Ralph's entire body just using her hands, she somewhat regrets not becoming closer to him earlier, and

  2. Discuss the view that Tony Lumpkin in "She Stoops to Conquer"is nothing more than ...

    This drama is recurring throughout the play which shows Tony?s determination to become financially independent and ?be made a fool of no longer? since currently he is only able to go to ?the alehouse so often? because he has ?a key to every drawer? of his ?mother?s bureau?.

  1. The Presentation of the Legal Establishment in "Murmuring Judges" by David Hare.

    lawyer, and therefore stands that one pace behind, as a mark of respect for her employer as she is yet to gain from him. The element of controversial sexism is apparent throughout the play. In Scene Three, Woody gives Irina the proposal as instructed by Sir Peter, ?You?re to go and take in a little Mozart, he said.

  2. In Murmuring Judges, David Hare uses Barry to represent the stereotypical bent policemen that ...

    but is also evidenced in his corruption, as no-one else is portrayed in this manner. The fact that Barry is shown to be ?relieved at the change of subject? from his corruption could suggest that he is ashamed, as he is ?able to relax? once they are discussing something else.

  1. Examine the ways in which the relationship between the public and the police is ...

    but here the police are shown to have grown more tired of the public and are more irritated, ?do you have any idea, you stupid arsehole, how bloody boring it is for us?? However, the public only further underlying frustration, as the Criminal Evidence Act of 1981 made policing more

  2. The Representation of Post-war Britain in "Look Back in Anger".

    ?If you could have a child, and it would die ? if only I could watch you face that.? This is a moment of both dramatic irony and foreshadowing. It is ironic because the audience already knows that Alison is pregnant.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work