• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

My Perception of Portias Portrayal in the Merchant of Venice

Extracts from this document...


My Perception of Portia's Portrayal in the Merchant of Venice It is very difficult for a modern audience to see the Merchant of Venice as the Elizabethans did; we see this as a play mostly about Shylock, who is without question the most powerful role in the play, and one of Shakespeare's most fascinating characters. Portia's character is extremely debateable seeing as she is this supposedly innocent young woman who conforms to the patriarchal authority of her husband as well as her dead father, yet somehow manages to defeat the men at their own game in the dramatic trial scene and ring scene, in which she is the one who has the control, despite (or because of) the fact she is in disguise. There are a number of ways of trying to avoid confronting the apparent unpredictability in Portia's character. Portia has borrowed her courtroom clothes from her cousin Bellario in Padua, who is in fact a scholar, and at the end of Act 3 Scene 4, we see that she has also asked Bellario for some notes ('What notes and garments he doth give thee'), which could be her guide in the courtroom scene. You can then argue that the difference between Portia as we saw her earlier and as we see her in the courtroom is caused since 'The quality of Mercy' speech was written for Portia by Bellario and she is merely reading it, and that the same is ...read more.


Portia's rhetorical shift involves removing "mercy" from the realm of legal compulsion, and thus sidestepping his question. By allying "mercy" with "heaven", "God" and "kings", Portia takes it from the created law and makes it part of the metaphysical system which surrounded Renaissance ideology. She no longer has to argue over right and wrong in this individual case ("the justice of your case"), but claims to be dealing with issues of Right and Wrong on a larger scale, even Good and Evil. Read more at Suite101: The Quality of Mercy: Portia's Oration in The Merchant of Venice http://www.suite101.com/content/the-quality-of-mercy-a30269#ixzz15YovCOL7 Portia loses her whole impact in the play if we don't see who she is while she's giving this speech, and she surprises us, as we'd taken Portia for a bit of an dismissive and ignorant woman as is shown when she is mocking her suitors with Nerissa - 'How oddly he is suited!', whereas now we suddenly realize how intelligent she is. More intelligent than she realizes herself, I believe. Although Portia herself is almost a deus ex machina in the courtroom, since she has not been involved in the Shylock plot at all [previously, and we have had no previous reason to even suspect that she had any legal expertise (which to me does seem like a genuine flaw in the plot), I think that there is no other character available who could present the winning arguments in the courtroom in the same way. ...read more.


The one thing we see for sure from her comments in Act 1 is that she is definitely intelligent (or, at the very least, clever). And the fact that Portia surprises us in the courtroom scene and shows an unexpected depth is, in my opinion, part of what would have made the play comic. If the previous acts had shown Portia as wise and super-competent, then as I see it, the courtroom scene wouldn't have worked. In this case, watching Portia defeat Shylock would have been almost an unfair fight. Portia, like so many women, appears to be the victim of the belief that it's not a good thing for women to be intelligent. She downplays her intelligence at the start of the play, hidden it even from herself, allowed herself to express it only in socially acceptable forms, such as sarcastic banter. Her destiny is even controlled by her dead father, still a victim of her father's patriarchal authority and control. When there is the moment when she really needs that intelligence, and she has the right to use it because she is disguised as a man. To be acceptable to an Elizabethan audience, and even to a modern one, you need the comedy to disguise the feminism, which I believe is what Shakespeare was trying to do in his portrayal of Portia. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level The Merchant of Venice section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level The Merchant of Venice essays

  1. Compare and contrast the different worlds and different values of Venice and Belmont as ...

    The distinctions between Venice and Belmont may have been viewed differently in Shakespearean times from present day. The casket test was a common myth in Shakespeare's time and his linking this folk tale to Belmont emphasise it as a fictional, fairytale location detached from the rest of the world.

  2. Antonio and Portia comparison - Scene 1 and 2

    This Scene is similar to Scene 1 where Antonio is the one distressed, Bassanio can be compared to Nerissa as he is reliant on Antonio for money, he also discusses any issues that Bassanio may have. Portia's unhappiness at the prospect of having her husband chosen for her may be a way to show how smart she was.

  1. Who contributes more to The Merchant of Venice Shylock or Portia?

    Antonio shows a similar attitude towards Shylock by saying, "I'm likely to call you names again, spit on you again, and shun you again." Throughout the entire play there is a constant and intense battle between the Christians and the Jews.

  2. The Merchant of Venice

    The early Church believed that the Jews murdered Christ and were therefore in relationship with the Devil. Christianity convinced the public that anti-Semitism means that if a Jew converted to Christianity, as Shylock is forced to do in the play, then all will be forgiven as the repentant Jew is embarrassed by all merciful Christian God.

  1. Show how Shakespeare employs tensions and oppositions to present conflicting principals and prejudices of ...

    Love and hate are the central themes of the main plot they hold the story together. Many of Shakespeare's plays are also centred on the themes of comedy and tragedy. 'The Merchant of Venice' is a prime example. Shakespeare uses cross-dressing as a device to lay emphasis on the theme of comedy.

  2. Discuss the presentation of the Christians in 'The Merchant of Venice'

    It is also in Act 4 Scene I (the court scene) that we really see the Anti-Semitic views of Gratiano as he leads other people and Christians around him in shouting out insults such as "harsh Jew" and "inexecrable dog".

  1. An Exploration of the character Shylock in The Merchant of Venice

    We find further examples of Shylock finding need to correct himself throughout the play whenever his language seems poetic. In Act 2 scene 3 Shylock asks Jessica to close up the house so that "shallow foppery" does not enter. He tells her to "close his house's ears," and again he

  2. How has Radfords film version explored notions about value and culture in Shakespeares The ...

    It shows that we no longer find amusement in the belittling of the 'inferior' as some were once dubbed. Society has learnt to accept differences and has worked on limiting the out-casting of 'unaccepted' races and/or other subdominant parties. "In responding to the play, we should not suppress the awareness

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work