• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Re-read Act 2 Scene 6 of Murmuring Judges. Discuss Hares presentation of the position of women in the police force and the legal profession in this extract and the play as a whole.

Extracts from this document...


Re-read Act 2 Scene 6 of 'Murmuring Judges'. Discuss Hare's presentation of the position of women in the police force and the legal profession in this extract and the play as a whole. Throughout 'Murmuring Judges', women are portrayed in varying, often dichotomous ways, having either much or little power, and being either assertive or submissively coquettish. In Act 2 Scene 6, women are presented as having their own secret culture, running parallel to the dominant culture of the men pervading the police force. For example, after Sandra light-heartedly laments the fact that Irina has chosen to speak to a woman, the stage directions dictate that "For the first time they both smile." The fact that the first time they smile is inspired by Sandra's referring to a liaison exclusively between women evinces that the women have their own kind of female culture which they are aware of. In addition, the form of dialogue which is taken by the entire scene facilitates the presentation of a female secret culture as the only speakers in this scene are female, hence no males are involved, making this a purely female affair. ...read more.


Most clearly." The noun, 'assets', is commonly used as a euphemism for mammary glands, and Cuddeford's response palpably confirms this due to the superlative and adverb phrase, 'most clearly', which suggests the assets are primarily visual. This male-dominated, misogynistic discourse objectifies Irina, disempowering women in general since the masculine talk regards women as subservient. In the previously mentioned three scenes, Hare is granting more power to women by providing them with their own secret culture, and conveying the fact that the legal system was largely patriarchal during the late 1980's-early '90's. Therefore, the 1991 audience would comprehend the disparity in power between the superior white males and inferior females, hence Hare would have been successful in raising awareness about the gender inequality in the judiciary system. This effect would still be present in a contemporary audience, because, twenty years after the original performance in 1991, there are still sex- and race-related prejudices in today's police force and court system; for example the Telegraph newspaper reported upon a male policeman's misogynistic remarks about a female colleague recently. ...read more.


In Act 2 Scene 3, the two women in the scene, Sandra and Esther, can be identified into two stereotypes: Sandra is the archetypal assertive, apparently independent woman, and Esther, the flirtatious coquette of the males (for instance, she play along with Lester's 'vagina dentata' joke, declaring, "yeah, I've had fantastic bridgework"). However, Sandra's influence grows as the scene progresses into a dialogue between Sandra and Barry, akin but concurrently different to how Sandra and Irina engage in a dialogue in the focus scene, in that women hold power throughout that scene, whereas Barry's obstinacy born by his opinionated, monochrome views, causes a fluctuation in power between the man and the woman, reflecting a real-life power struggle between the sexes in the police force and in the courts. The fact that the power oscillates between Barry and Sandra is Hare's giving women more power than in reality they had, and still do have, albeit to a greater extent today, since men had more power than women in the courts and the police force, which consist of a greater proportion of men than women. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Play Writes section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

*** 3 STARS

Well written with some insightful comments. Takes into account setting and stage directions as well as dialogue. Explores the roles of men and women in the police force and is aware of how the playwright is manipulating audience reaction. Some repetition of words, phrases and ideas but overall the essay is an intelligent and thoughtful response to the question.

Marked by teacher Katie Dixon 07/08/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Play Writes essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    The History Boys. Consider the significance of finding your way in life, in ...

    3 star(s)

    All of the boys live in Sheffield, where the school is. For them to be accepted at Oxford or Cambridge would change their whole lives. It would also change the dynamic of the school. On their route to Oxbridge, the boys are taught by two entirely different teachers.

  2. Evoking the past is one of the most important strategies in the practice of ...

    This traditional ritual impels the characters to re-enact their history and the role played by slavery, taking them on a slave ship and to an auction through a series of flashbacks that awake a long and deep 'echo in the bone'.

  1. Re-read Act 1 Scene 7 of Murmuring Judges. Discuss the effects of Hare's use ...

    Similarly, in Act 1 Scene 1, lighting and staging are both used in synergy to achieve the effect of isolation of characters, a technique evidently common in the play. For instance, the sudden entrance of the lawyers, "Then suddenly from nowhere they're all there - the judge, the jury..."

  2. How does Bennett present different teaching styles in 'The History Boys'?

    When reflecting on the essays he has just marked, he remarks that the other boys and girls who 'have been to

  1. Troy Maxson, the main character in August Wilsons critically acclaimed play Fences, talks about ...

    At a mere age of fourteen, Troy finds himself becoming a man from a child. He realizes he has metamorphosed into a man from a kid when he and Maxson Sr. get into a fight. When his father finds him flirting with a girl when he was supposed to be working, they have a real go at each other.

  2. David Hare's criticism of the Legal System in Scene 1 Acts 1 - 4

    We are made to feel as the audience sad and sympathetic towards Gerard and so we begin to dislike the prison and legal systems. This achieves Hare's goal of criticising the legal system effectively in the in first four scenes.

  1. In the play Equus worship and passion are seen in many contrasting lights. In ...

    And when he's with Jill, preparing to have sex with her, he can't think about passion without thinking and hearing Equus. This shows just how inseparable these two ideas are to Alan. Also because of this, in Alan's mind his god is jealous that he might share passion with someone other than him, which is blasphemy to Alan.

  2. The play Cosi, written by Louis Nowra, supports the assumption that certain members of ...

    However, Justin definition of extraordinary is never made clear to the audience or Lewis as clearly some patients can become quite dangerous, such as Doug who attempts to set the theatres on fire twice risking the lives of all the cast members.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work