• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Sir Philip Sidneys poem The Nightingale and Amy Clampitts poem Syrinx are two very different poems

Extracts from this document...


Compare and Contrast the two poems paying particular attention to their versification. Sir Philip Sidney?s poem The Nightingale and Amy Clampitt?s poem Syrinx are two very different poems. The Nightingale is a poem based on the mournful song of a bird, as it expresses grief and pain: ?And mournfully bewailing/ Her throat in tunes expresseth/ What grief her breast oppresseth.? (lines 5-7) Whereas the Syrinx is a poem based on how the sound of words, have no real meaning and are simply just sounds. The Syrinx can also be defined as a water reed which prohibits birds from singing: ?syrinx, that reed/ in the throat of a bird,? (lines 7-8) The abrupt stop at the end of the line, is a technique used by Amy Clampitt, to make the reading of the line feel like choking on the words, like a reed in a birds throat would cause. Therefore there are many comparisons and contrasts between the two poems, thus in order to examine what these are I am going to look at the use of rhyme, imagery, diction, structure and metre in each of the poems to try to identify the similarities and differences between the two. The Nightingale is divided into two stanzas of equal length, whereas Syrinx is divided into two stanzas of equal length, then a final short verse paragraph. ...read more.


Therefore the later mention of a thorn: ?Thy thorn without, my thorn my heart invadeth.? (line 12) Could be seen as a biblical reference to Christ and the crown of thorns. This image of a thorn represents pain not just physical but emotional. As if the speaker possibly Philomela?s sister, feels betrayed by Philomela, like how Jesus was betrayed by the Jews. Therefore the speaker does not just refer to the imagery of a sharp thorn causing great physical pain. Instead the mention of a thorn is as a biblical reference symbolising betrayal and emotional pain, which creates strong imagery as to the grief and anguish the speaker is suffering. Syrinx on the other hand, presents a different view of the meaning behind a bird?s song than The Nightingale. Amy Clampitt has made it clear in her poem Syrinx, that she is not interested with metre and rhyme. Instead she has purposely made her rhyme, metre and layout all irregular to emphasise that a bird?s call can mean nothing at all. The Nightingale focuses on a deep meaning behind a bird?s song. However, Syrinx focuses on the fact that a bird?s call is meaningless, yet it is the sounds that are important. The first three lines express this: Like the foghorn that?s all lung, The wind chime that?s all percussion, Like the wind itself, that?s merely air (lines 1-3) ...read more.


However, when the speaker then says, ?my thorn my heart invadeth.? We picture Philomela?s sister telling us that her pain has come from her own blood. That her sister Philomela has ruined her marriage and invaded her heart leaving an eternal pain of heart break. In summation, Sir Philip Sidney?s poem The Nightingale and Amy Clampitt?s poem Syrinx represent two very contrasting views. The Nightingale is a very well ordered poem; it is laid out in two stanzas of equal length and has a regular rhyme scheme and metre. This all helps emphasise the deep and meaningful song of the Nightingale as it expresses grief and anguish. However, Syrinx is a very irregular poem, it is laid out in two equal stanzas with a final short verse paragraph and it has no rhyme or predominant metre. This is all emphatic of the meaning behind the poem, that a bird?s song has no real meaning it is just a set of sounds and nothing more. However, despite this, both poems have links to classical mythology, as well as both being about birds and their songs. Both poems also seem to have some roots in the subjection of females to the threat of rape by overbearing males. Hence they lose their voice literally but also with regards to personal freedom. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Comparative Essays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Comparative Essays essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Presentation of Suffering in Dulce et Decorum est and The Sentry

    4 star(s)

    My friend, you would not tell with such high zest / The old Lie: Dulce et Decorum est / pro patria mori." This shows the capacity of war to change a person's perspective on life, and that someone who has not fought, simply cannot understand the truth of war.

  2. ComparativeCommentry of Two Passages

    In contrast the writer in the second passage has described the environment created by the snowfall so beautifully. Like in the beginning of the 'second paragraph' which says ''It clung quickly ...eyebrows above...making beard...what a beautiful street it seemed! Compares the snowfall with the human's feature.

  1. In what ways, and how, does Elizabeth Barrett Browning convey deep and eternal love ...

    She is herself virginal and chastely, and her love for Robert Browning is as pure as her love of God. By referencing "Praise", Browning is comparing her love to be the same as religious worship, unsullied, untainted, innocent and virtuous.

  2. The Historyof War Poetry and the works of Wilfred Owen

    Wilfred Owen puns on the word "exposure." The soldiers are not killed by enemy bullets but by "exposure" to the freezing cold. The poem also "exposes" the lies of the government propaganda which promised the young men who enlisted to join the army a thrilling life of adventure and glory.

  1. Response to texts. Spared, written by Wendy Cope. The Sun has burst the sky, ...

    The author, James Joyce, writes that Eveline struggled to keep "her promise to keep the home together as long as she could," a promise she made to her mother while on her deathbed. As in all of the poems, the person whom the story is about is concerned for loved

  2. How do the introductions to Songs of Innocence and Songs of Experience, Earth(TM)s Answer ...

    The introduction to the Songs of Experience greatly differs from the first introduction. Here we see a Bard being represented, rather than a piper. With an ABAAB rhyme scheme (but with half-rhyme) we see that the regular from met in the Songs of Innocence introduction has been altered and adjusted

  1. Plath and Hughes wrote their last collections for different reasons, different audiences; there are ...

    ?There?s a stake in your fat black heart,? Plath tells her father, confused by her pain about whom he was and who he is. She sees her father now as ?not any less the black man who/Bit my pretty red heart in two?, seeing him as the person responsible for

  2. The lives and works of Elizabeth Barrett Browning and Emily Dickinson may be different ...

    ?Dickinson was a master at grammar, rhythm, rhetoric, and narrative. A master of the inextricable, intricate, intimate and constantly shifting, interrelationship?s among them? (Ryan). ?Emily Dickinson wrote nearly 1800 poems, but only seven were published in her lifetime. When the first posthumous collection of her work appeared in 1890, she was regarded as an interesting but idiosyncratic minor poet.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work