"The Accident" By Mavis Gallant

Authors Avatar

The Accident” By Mavis Gallant

From: Harsh Kothari

To: Mrs. Montalbanno

Due Date: 26/9/05

        The passage from “The Accident” written by Mavis Gallant reflects on the different opinions the characters have as to how life is to be lived based on Shirley’s narration. The passage also reflects Shirley’s feelings towards Pete’s death. Gallant achieves this by developing the identities of the characters through literary tactics like symbolism, characterisation and some foreshadowing.  

        Shirley’s in-laws, Mr and Mrs. Higgins have differing views on life from Shirley. Shirley is more of a philosophical person who isn’t as materialistic as the Higgins are. This is expressed when Shirley says, “The destination of a soul was of no interest. The death of a voice – now, that was real.”(l.8-9) Shirley doesn’t express this to anyone and keeps it to herself since she was “careful” not to offend anyone during the funeral of Pete. On the contrary, Mr and Mrs. Higgins were pragmatists because materialistic aspects of life such as money was an issue for both since they often conversed about money, “ ‘It that’s a check on a bank at home, it might take too long to clear’, said his wife. ‘After all Shirley’s been through, she needs a fair-sized sum right away” (l.35-36). Mr. Higgins was aware that he could die at any time now, and that Shirley would need something to survive on, so he gave some money to Shirley. She narrates this by saying; “ He gave me the envelope that had been close to his heart until now.” On the other hand, the Higgins aren’t entirely materialistic and money minded since they value the presence of Shirley in the absence of Pete. Mr. Higgins says, “Then Shirley is all we’ve got left”(l. 33) However, Shirley fails to understand the emotional feeling of Mr. Higgins because she says, “…and I thought they seemed bankrupt, having nothing but me.” (l.33-34) It seems as though Shirley perceives Mr and Mrs. Higgins as only money-minded people who don’t really feel the value of human presence. According to the reader, Shirley’s views on the Higgins are rather false since the Higgins seem rather concerned for Shirley and her well-being and her happiness, in fact they also consider Shirley as someone close to them. This feeling is conveyed by Mr. Higgins when he says, “You’re our daughter now” (l. 11).

Join now!

        The characters in this passage have their unique features of behaving. For example, Mr. Higgins, in this extract has a somewhat arrogant and domineering attitude that is covered by his sympathy towards Shirley. “ ‘I’m fixing something up for you, just the same,’ said Mr. Higgins hurriedly, as if he would not be interrupted by women.” (L. 18-19) This quotation expresses the willingness of Mr. Higgins to arrange something for Shirley so that she would be self-sufficient, but at the same time his natural arrogance and domineering attitude is shown as well. Mr. Higgins in some occasions is somewhat rude ...

This is a preview of the whole essay