• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The American Civil War is a topic which many poets have addressed in verse. What separates Lowells For The Union Dead from the scores of other Civil War poems is not only the complex interweaving of period and contemporary events in order to make

Extracts from this document...


BASED ON YOUR READING OF THE CRITICAL ANTHOLOGY, ARGUE THE CASE FOR YOUR SELECTION OF POEMS WHICH YOU VIEW AS HAVING VALUE The American Civil War is a topic which many poets have addressed in verse. What separates Lowell's 'For The Union Dead' from the scores of other Civil War poems is not only the complex interweaving of period and contemporary events in order to make a social commentary on change, which give the poem a strong modern-day resonance, but also the precise and polysemic lexis Lowell employs in order to link different timeframes. In 1964, four years after he first read 'For The Union Dead' in public, Lowell stated in a letter: "In my poem For The Union Dead, I lament the loss of the old Abolitionist spirit; the terrible injustice, in the past and present, of the American treatment of the Negro is the greatest urgency to me as a man and a writer.". By describing the "loss" of such a spirit, Lowell also reveals what has replaced it in modern Boston; a vulgar fixation with consumerism. His juxtaposition of the unselfish and heroic sacrifice of Colonel Shaw and his all-black 54th Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry against the moral decline of modern Boston, of a rose-tinted past against a dystopian present, is a continual theme in the poem. ...read more.


Lowell also presents continuity regarding the fact that despite the American Civil War was won by the Abolitionists, segregation was still existent at the time of writing; he conveys disgust at the fact that while America's fragile sense of heritage and culture is bulldozed in the name of technological 'advancement' (the steamshovels and cars), racism remains. The fact that the Boston Common garage is geographically close to the bronze memorial for the 54th Massachusetts Volunteers Infantry means that the link between the two is justified and founded in reality, the link being that although the garage would suggests advancement, it actually represents a backward step for Boston, and the memorial's place in an America which still instigates segregation shows that America is still stuck in its prejudiced past. Lowell's layering of images, juxtapositions and parallels across various timeframes, and the split between historical and personal, allows the poem to be a complex collection of ideas contributing to the same central twin destinations concerning inequality and transience. A "complex interweaving... of ideas" which denotes value, then, can be clearly identified in Lowell's poem. Another feature of 'valued' literature, alongside complex ideas, is complexity in language and word choice. There can be little doubt that Lowell has chosen to place certain words in certain places in the poem, that he is a "craftsperson... ...read more.


who repeat over and over the message which the text itself failed to tell", that these critics make up for a poet's lack of precision in craft. However, the ignorance of the reader cannot diminish the value of a poem; it is the reader's responsibility to fill in gaps in their knowledge and thereby fully comprehend the value and complexity of the poem. Foucault also doubts that the writer is in complete control of the writing, arguing instead that certain "literary traditions... economic and literary pressures" influence the text. Again, if Foucault's position is to be believed, this would show that Lowell is not a "craftsman... in command of (his) writing", and therefore that his poetry is not 'valuable'. However, while these pressures undoubtedly shape certain decisions concerning issues like structure and subject matter (for instance, the construction of the underground garage in the vicinity of the memorial and the on-going civil rights movement led Lowell to consider Colonel Shaw and his Infantry's bravery and the futility of their sacrifice), the artistry and poetic technique exhibited by the poet requires a great deal of control. These pressures, if anything, form a vague outline of a work which must be defined and filled by the poet's imagination; Lowell does this magnificently, using the intricate entwining of themes and ideas and precise word choice to create a work of true value. ?? ?? ?? ?? ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Poets section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Poets essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Understanding Place and Language in Olive Senior's "Gardening in the Tropics"

    5 star(s)

    Senior implies that she was able to clarify much of her identity issues through the help of the works of Rhys. She states: "Right now I'm as divided as you were by that sea. But I'll be able to find my way home again for that craft you launched is

  2. The Glass Jar (Gwen Harwood) Analysis. The Glass Jar, dedicated to Vivian Smith, ...

    A further allusion to Christ is evident in the imagery of lines five-six of the first stanza. On the night before his arrest and crucifixion Christ went with his disciples to the Garden of Gethsemane to pray. His disciples slept, 'the sun's disciples cloaked in dream', while Christ experienced great anguish anticipating the physical suffering of his road to Calvary.

  1. Wagan Watsons poetry is often read as a representation of race and racial tensions, ...

    heartbeat of this captured landscape,' the last of which could be interpreted as the city being built on stolen, from both nature and natives (who he may view valued the land more than the settlers do), or 'captured' landscape, the heartbeat representing the death of this natural land into industrialization, which will be discussed later.

  2. Social and literary background to Mirza Ghalib's works. Mirza Asadullah Beg Khan known ...

    He was charged with keeping a gambling establishment at his house, was convicted and spent three months in jail. More painful to him even than this was the way in which all his friends and admirers deserted him at this crisis.

  1. What methods does Browning use to tell the poem The Pied Piper of Hamelin ...

    The noise of the magic pipe became worse as it was changing from muttering to grumbling and from grumbling to rumbling. Browning has used onomatopoeia to show the readers the strong images of the noise which were coming out from the pipe.

  2. Commentary on The Lost Heritage by Heather Buck

    This severely contrasts to the previous thought that we have all but forgotten our heritage, which is just another value that was created by another person. The second stanza brings forth the image of the ancestors who had created our heritage.

  1. How does Dickinson mock puritan values in her poems?

    breaking through-' this makes the puritans seem like they have no sense since she say 'sense was breaking through' its like she is implying that finally they are understanding. This line ends with a dash implying that the puritans are having some result and maybe that there is hope ,

  2. The Romantic Period and the poems of Blake

    figures suppress the growth of the society by burdening it with manifold sufferings and turning a deaf ear to the protests of the people. Unfortunately, the troubles of London are not limited to a socio-political sphere. If so they could have been righted by revolution.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work