• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The First World War - The Stalemate on the Western Front - Source based questions

Extracts from this document...


The First World War The Stalemate on the Western Front Question 1: Source A at first glance doesn't appear to tell us very much about why the war went on for as long as it did. It appears to be poem about two soldiers who met the general and shows at the end how he was responsible for their deaths in his plan of attack. The only reason it seems to show is that the generals should have been defending when they should have been defending because as it says, many men were going to die in the attack which when we look back at it, we see they only gained minimal amounts of land for thousands of lives. This, although it is a good reason for the protracted length of the war, it is not the only one stated in the poem. Looking closely at it you can see that the men had to walk up to the front line. This is another reason as it shows us how hard it was for both sides to move supplies up to the front as no vehicles or trains could get there because firstly of the muddy ground which no vehicles could get through including tanks. ...read more.


it was impossible to make anything more than a "slaughter-house" or salient as it was properly known as when one side created a bulge in the line that was usually fired upon from 3 sides until the attackers fell back. Falkenhayn doesn't openly blame himself and his colleagues for the slaughters but rather tries to pass the blame off to conditions. This may have been true as when he wrote the book, he had the benefit of hindsight. The two points of view in source E are generally blaming the weather and mud for the harsh conditions they were put through. The mud being was blamed for stopping the tanks advance and the flooded landscape for creating disease and cold. It could be seen another way though as it might be the men blaming the Generals for putting their men through such demoralizing conditions. Source E also shows us how the Germans had it just as badly as the Allies. The advantage of these sources is that they are first-hand accounts (primary sources). Source F show George admitting that the Generals weren't very good at fighting this new kind of war but also that they were the best men at the time to try. ...read more.


It is basically a French version of something you would see in a Punch magazine. People mocking the way the leaders of their government run the country. The final Source, M, is an aerial photograph of part of the trench line on the western front. It shows lots of shell holes and a detailed view of the layout of the trenches. In the middle, there is a big white area, this could have been an explosion but it is more probably the chalk that used to be under the mud but has now been uncovered by the intensity of the explosions. This source doesn't really relate to the Generals in any way but it does give an indication of the extent of the conditions along the line. Overall, looking through the sources, we can see that although the Generals may have been to blame for the failure to breakthrough the western front, there were a lot of other reasons that contributed. These included elements such as the weather and the bogginess of the ground, the amount of arms and supplies available to both sides because of the introduction of mass production in the factories. Overall though to gain a clearer picture, we would need to have a lot more sources which covered a whole range of things, photos from all along the line, and accounts from many people through the line and all through the war. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level War Poetry section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level War Poetry essays

  1. Conscientious Objection Sources Questions

    'Public opinion during the war was uniformly hostile to the conscientious objectors.' Do these sources show this to be true? During the war a lot of men refused to fight for their country for various reasons - some claiming exemption due to their important roles in industry (and refused to fight), others because their conscience wouldn't allow them to.

  2. History Coursework - World War One Sources Question

    or that he is "sick/wounded", the postcard not allowing the discussion of the pain or suffering of the writer, and while it was left to individual officers to censor letters in general going home, these would probably not permit such emotional weaknesses either.

  1. "Poems and stories; official accounts. Which of these give a more accurate picture of ...

    This photo, although subject to censorship gives me an idea as to what the conditions in the trenches were like. The floor of the trenches is covered in mud, which is up to the soldiers knees in some parts; this could lead to conditions illnesses such as trench foot.

  2. Is source a more reliable than source b for a study of the Effect ...

    Sassoon enlisted on 2 August 1914, two days before the British declaration of war, and initially joined as a trooper in the Sussex Yeomanry. However, after a riding accident whilst doing some field-work (he had put his horse at a fence blind with summer vegetation and a hidden strand of

  1. Why Did the Stalemate on the Western Front Occur?

    However, though they were demoralised, the French killed nearly as many Germans as the Germans killed the French. Another important reason for the stalemate (but no the most important) was the type of weapons used in the First World War.

  2. New technologies and their effect on the stalemate on the Western Front.

    Although it was an effective means in killing the enemy, it did not substantially break the stalemate. The Germans released a chlorine gas from 520 cylinders (168 tons of the chemical was used). The cloud drifted over to the French and Algerian trenches where it caused wide spread panic and death.

  1. The war on the western front.

    The source was written during the war so it's a primary source. Sassoon was an infantry officer and is famous for his poetry. He used his poetry as an art to express his feelings, he wrote many poems which were about war.

  2. The war on the Western Front

    By doing this he has gained a more complete picture with different facts and opinions. As a result this source seems to be more reliable even though it is a secondary source. Also Craig Mair has no reason to lie about the artillery bombardments.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work