• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'The Knightley brothers embody all that is good in society. They are well-meaning characters who fulfil their responsibilities admirably, yet the reader may find them dull.'

Extracts from this document...


'The Knightley brothers embody all that is good in society. They are well-meaning characters who fulfil their responsibilities admirably, yet the reader may find them dull.' In the light of this statement, examine Austen's presentation of John and George Knightley. Every novel requires a dastardly villain and a shining hero, who falls for the heroine at the end of the story. Mr and Mrs Elton seem somewhat villainous in their treatment of others, with the Knightley brothers - George, the elder, especially - representing such a hero and symbol of good. However, since the Eltons aren't really evil, and the Knightleys are so 'agreeable' and 'cheerful', it can certainly lead to some people considering Emma a dull read. As well as his personality and position, we are informed of Mr Knightley being the hero by his name: George, patron saint of England, twinned with the idea of a 'Knightley' man in shining armour, clears all doubt. As a Jane Austen hero, his purpose is to marry the heroine in the final chapters, after a novel's worth of witty banter. ...read more.


John Knightley, 'a tall, gentleman-like, and very clever man', is a more sombre character; equally as serious, yet lacking the cheerfulness George possesses. The fact that 'his temper was not his great perfection', it occasionally causes friction with the eternally 'easy, cheerful tempered' Mr Weston, and at their Christmas gathering, while the party becomes greatly excited at the sight of 'Christmas weather', John merely complains that: 'I cannot wish to be snowed up a week at Randalls.' This reliably bad temper allows John to seem a more impressive character than George, whose humour only fails when Emma upsets anybody, but he is still a figure of heroism and wholesomeness. While many of Jane Austen's heroes have fairly similar traits, the Knightleys appear to be the most angelic and show the fewest imperfections, although faults do become apparent. They both have the gift of astute judgement, displayed by George throughout, and by John when he observes Mr Elton with Emma: 'he seems to have a great deal of good-will towards you.' ...read more.


However, neither of the brothers is especially jolly, neither enjoying the Christmas atmosphere nor the accompanying dances. Yet despite his displeasure in dancing, George rescues Harriet from Mr Elton's ill manners and Emma notices 'Mr Knightley leading Harriet to the set'. George's greatest flaw is his thinly veiled jealousy for Frank Churchill, whose open flirtatiousness with Emma greatly annoys him; thus at every opportunity, he criticises and condemns the young man: claiming that Frank should perform his 'duty to pay... attention to his father' not by 'manoeuvring and finessing, but by vigour and resolution'. He tends to put part of the blame on Frank's young years, which produces the effect that George is old before his time, condemning the youth for their foolishness. In short, a well-mannered person can sometimes be misconstrued as a dull person, and the lack of dark secrets in the Knightleys can create a boring image indeed, but since the heroine and her sister are so greatly flawed themselves, Mr Knightley and his brother are suitably matched to them, in order to finally restore balance in Highbury. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Jane Austen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Jane Austen essays

  1. Emma is a witty and intelligent woman, trapped in a society which is unable ...

    Martin's proposal, convincing her of Mr. Elton's love for her, and completely confusing the situation of Frank Churchill and George Knightley. The reader gets agitated with Emma, and wonders why she is so interfering; using Harriet as some sort of puppet she can use her spare and bored time on.

  2. How do you as a modern reader, respond to Austen's presentation of Mr. Knightley's ...

    When speaking to Emma, we understand how much he cares for her, though sometimes he may seem quite abrupt. Nevertheless, throughout the novel we see Emma's countless faults. She seems to be inexperienced at the start of the novel, which can be said to 'justify' her childish behaviour.

  1. Using Chapters 23, 24 and 25 Write an Analysis of the Using Chapters 23, ...

    the way he presents himself to others, the way he speaks and his physical appearance, both in height and features. In a society dominated by material issues, Frank is also a gentleman because of his wealth and family connections. Frank is the son of Mr Weston, which means that he

  2. What makes a good detective?

    detective, very secretive, he is very good at solving things, he also appears to have a good sense of humour which is a good point but is serious to at the same time. In all the three stories that I have chose they are all good thinkers, quite quiet detectives, sly, they all use their common sense.

  1. Discuss the Relationship between John and Elizabeth Proctor and its Presentation. In What Ways ...

    However, the trust in this relationship is certainly lacking. The audience is now introduced to Mary Warren. The author uses her as a device to break the arguments between John and Elizabeth. Therefore, Mary Warren becomes a scapegoat, and sometimes finds John shouting at her. When Reverend Hale arrives, he brings news to John that Elizabeth's name was mentioned in court.

  2. The various portrayals of heroines in Jane Austen's novels as well as investigate, who ...

    It has been stated by critic Andrew Wright that Fanny is the antithesis of the conventional heroine. Given the bourgeois origins of the English novel, and the large female reading public, it is not surprising that the Cinderella story should underlie so many works.

  1. Jane Austen said of Emma 'she is a character who no-one but myself will ...

    This is where Emma clings to established ideas only when it suits her but does go against them. People reading Emma in Austen's time would find Emma too headstrong and seems to have no respect. This also links to when Harriet wishes to marry Mr.

  2. Emma Woodhouse and Mr. Woodhouse Analysis.

    People defer to Mr. Woodhouse's fortune and subsequent social standing rather than his intellect or any belief in his being right. The hypochondriac worries that he imposes on others are rarely given any credence because Mr. Woodhouse is never perceived as capable of solid reasoning.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work