• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The lady with a pet dog

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast paper Identical Titles - Different Authors Reading plays a very important role in the life of people. It educates a person, enriches his intellect. Books help to make a person's character, from his moral values. Besides, books bring pleasure and delight in our life. It's a wonderful way of spending spare time. Sometimes I read the same book again and again. Thanks to books I learn to express my thoughts and feelings more exactly. It can be put aside and taken up again at any moment. There are books and authors which have been our favorites since childhood. One of my favorite writers is Anton Pavlovich Chekhov. In my opinion, he is the greatest Russian dramatist and short-story writer. I'm never tired of reading and rereading his plays and humorous stories. Not long ago I discovered one American short story with almost the same title as "The Lady with the Pet Dog". The author is Joyce Carol Oates. The two versions of "The Lady with the Pet Dog," by Anton Chekhov and Joyce Carol Oates are similar in the theme but the endings of the stories couldn't be more different in connotation. ...read more.


She was known only as the lady with the pet dog. Finally he was given the chance to approach her in a public garden. Slowly the affair progressed to intimacy and they fell in love. Anna had to return home to her husband. After Anna left, Dimitry could not deny his love for her. He went to Moscow to try and ease the loneliness he felt for her. They began to have an affair again not sure of what would come next. Joyce Carol Oates is an American writer who was raised in upstate New York. Also she is a writer who likes to write from a realistic point of view. In 1972 Oates revised the short story "The Lady with the Pet Dog" making it American and more modern. The dialogue is simpler. Also the time in which the story takes place is different. Unlike original version by Chekhov, Oates writes from the woman's perspective. She tells what Anna thinking and what she felt. Little is told of what the lover thinks and his life with his children. In Oates version the story starts off with the affair already in existence. The lover is never given a name and Anna is never given a last name. ...read more.


She resents her lover and herself for being married to one man and loving another. He is sure of his love for Anna and is ready and willing to marry her. She refuses and decides to take her life to end the unhappiness and pain in her life. All of a sudden she gains a certain sense of thankfulness and gratitude. She is grateful to have him in her life no matter what will be the end of this affair. I am unsure if they decided to get married or just continue the affair. In the original they decide to continue the affair but both are unsure of what they are going to do. I like Chekhov's story because Anna is a pretty lady with dignity and proud. Anna in Oates story is not a strong woman. She talks about suicide and murder. It seems that it's not the same woman we knew from Chekhov story. I did not like Oates story because she makes Anna look like simple women with out respect for her, a woman insane with love. Chekhov tells his story from eyes of a man looking at a beautiful woman. It is a very interesting how authors describe affairs and being unfaithful with different point of views. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Composition section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Composition essays

  1. An essential element of a short story is its ending. Discuss this statement with ...

    much of a difference the extra money would make and ended up accepting. Madame d' Hubires picked up the screaming child and walked towards the door as others might bear off a coveted bargain from a shop. As the d' Hubires took the child away the Tuvaches stood on their doorstep, grim faced, probably regretting they had said no.

  2. Samantha was seated on a chair reading her prized book.

    Samantha moved the seat back and closed her eyes. She did not like the takeoffs so she always tried to make people around her believe that he was sleeping in order to avoid people asking her things. However, this time she fell asleep, she opened first one eye and saw that old woman reading a pale green coloured book.

  1. English short story.

    There was no protest for anyone of them, just like Cassie hoped. That was the best thing to do in their situation, for Cassie had lived the closest to this house and would be the quickest to get there. Immediately she grabbed her self phone and pressed in her mother's mobile number.

  2. An Inspector Calls

    Sheila feels a lot of remorse for Eva Smith being sacked she says, "I think it was a mean thing to do. 'But these girls aren't cheap labour - they're people'." She means that if Mr Birling hadn't of sacked her then she would have not committed suicide.

  1. article in third person

    From the time Adrian, Army and herself where playing Frisbee and Gladys tripped over, it resulted in her cutting her chin and having to go to the hospital. "Adrian dropped us off at the Hospital and then went off to see Jo", Gladys said to me with tears running down her cheeks.

  2. An inspector calls

    Mr Birling appears to use his social status to acquire respect and nobility from Gerald. It is also ironic that he asks his family not to 'get into police court or start a scandal' since that is exactly what appears happens in the play, and this can ironically foreshadow the future events.

  1. Lone Wolf. He reached into a pocket. BANG! Goraz the ape man had ...

    Nothing but the wilderness and the open road. "Ah, no matter what happens there is one thing that remains the same: the beauty of nature," Jonah sighed again and carried on walking. He walked on for a good many miles until, at last, he collapsed due to his fatigue.

  2. I loved the book To Dance With The White Dog, by Terry Kay. When ...

    How's he doing? Is he bearing up? What should we do? What?" (pg.24) Even though the children's presence sometimes annoyed Sam, he knew his loving wife Cora was responsible for their caring ways and he took comfort in that. I can really relate to their worrying and overreacting as I

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work