• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The strength of Much Ado About Nothing lies in its balance of contrasting elements

Extracts from this document...


The strength of Much Ado about Nothing lies in its balance of contrasting elements. Do you agree? Much Ado about Nothing is a romantic comedy which depicts a story of love, tragedy and mistaken identity. The story is told with a typical comic edge which incorporates witty wordplay with simple slapstick situations; however it also has contrasting elements of potential tragedy which completely contradict the otherwise romantic stance of the story. The balance of these contrasting elements certainly improves the overall effect of the play, adding viewing value in the form of interest and enjoyment. However, does the strength of the play lie in the balance of contrasting elements or the principal comic romanticism? In the sense of Comic Romanticism, Shakespeare takes the same route with Much Ado About Nothing as many modern comedy directors, using the same age old conventions to amuse the audience. However it is in the complex and articulate language he uses to invent and conduct the comic interplay, complex courtships and overall predictability of the story line that makes Much Ado About Nothing so successful in the terms of a romantic comedy. One of the main conventions of romantic comedy is the possibility for potential tragedy. Shakespeare achieves this to a very successful level, incorporating changing levels of tension and still managing to take a comic route. The potential tragedy first occurs in the play with a classic case of mistaken identity. ...read more.


Here Shakespeare uses overhearing for comic and romantic purposes. The concept is also used by Don John and Borachio in order to mislead Claudio and Don Pedro and cause a series of tragic events. Claudio and Don Pedro 'accidentally' overhear a romantic conversation between Borachio and Margaret disguised as Hero and swear to slander Hero at the wedding for revenge. Here Shakespeare uses the convention as a platform for potential tragedy. Finally the concept is used to uncover the series of lies devised by Don John and Borachio and dispel the potential tragedy. Having carried out their plot to convince Claudio of Heros' adultery and stop their marriage from taking place, Borachio converses with Conrade, telling him about their done deed. This is overheard by the Watch, who consequently arrest the villains and reveal the plot. Shakespeare uses the convention as a basis for the storys plot line. Much Ado About Nothing contains a series of contrasting dramatic elements which surprise the reader throughout the play. There are the raw elements of romance and tragedy, the superficial elements of slap stick and sophisticated witty comedy and the pure, unconditional romance of Beatrice and Benedick Romance, however pure and unconditional it sometimes appears, is very closely linked to the element of tragedy. The typical romance in Much Ado' is between Claudio and Hero, whose relationship is the basis for the plays potential tragedy. ...read more.


We find the two characters are on bad terms and take every chance to insult and criticize each other; however this soon changes after a typical case of overhearing finds both Beatrice and Benedick madly in love with each other, although they find they can not admit this to anyone but themselves. The potential tragedy of the play takes their relationship to a new level and is the part of the play where Beatrice and Benedick profess their true feelings to one another. We then see it is a type of unconditional love in which each is willing to die for the other. At the end of the play this love is revealed to all and marriage prevails. Seeing their feelings change and grow throughout Much Ado about nothing assures the audience of the authenticity of the relationship and of their true, unconditional love. It is an element which doesn't incorporate any lies or betrayal, but simply the humane feelings of love. This is what makes the engaging and developing relationship between Beatrice and Benedick the purest dramatic element of the play. The strength of Much Ado about nothing lies in Shakespeare's strength in creating characters that convince and enchant, rather than in the strength of the stereo-typical conventions of a romantic comedy. The romantic comedy conventions are predictable and add nothing especially memorable to the overall play. Beatrice and Benedick do. ?? ?? ?? ?? Sophie Hicks ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

The main strengths of the essay are its persuasive understanding of comedy as a genre and its sense of engagement with the text.
There is occasional lack of clarity in expression, and more attention should be given to technical accuracy in quotation technique and use of apostrophes.

Marked by teacher Val Shore 27/03/2012

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Other Criticism & Comparison essays

  1. An Analysis of the free radio as various symbols and the messages it symbolises ...

    at the time that Rushdie wrote the story, the encouragement of men to give up their manhood in national interest, granting free radios in appreciation, often times these were empty promises of politicians vying for power. Through the use of this policy and the free radio, Rushdie demonstrates the utter

  2. Ambition in "The Duchess of Malfi" and "Paradise Lost"

    Webster's powerful imagery stresses the strong use of adjectives, "rails" to emphasise the intricate nature of a natural emotion which causes our own heavy downfall. The term "he" suggests that ambition is our own madness, based on our own private desires and is not considerate of the effects on others.

  1. Comparative Study - Despite the differences in context, a comparative study of the poetry ...

    of imagination and wildly shifting perspectives, for metaphysical conceit, for wit" further emphasises how Vivian has deconstructed her life to become simpler. However, when conducting a comparative study of Edson's drama and Donne's poetry, the responder will become aware that this is not Vivian forcing herself into simplicity, but her

  2. Unity of Effect in Cask of Amontillado

    In the context of the story, Fortunato is represented by the serpent, while Montresor is represented by the foot crushing the serpent. As the serpent injured the foot by biting it, Fortunato injured Montresor by insulting him and his family, and as the foot crushes the serpent in revenge, Montresor will bring his revenge on Fortunato into effect.

  1. Odysseus: A Beloved Epic Hero

    This proves he has courage because he went back to his home knowing that there were other men living there who would be willing to fight off Odysseus so they could take his wife and his throne. However, he has the courage to risk his life and fight the suitors anyway.

  2. Elaine Showalter argues that Ophelias tragedy is subordinated in the play. Through comparison of ...

    Shakespeare emphasises this in Act One Scene Two, when Hamlet states in his soliloquy, "Frailty thy name is woman" Here, Hamlet presents his perception of women, being people who are emotionally, physically and morally weak and therefore need to depend upon men.

  1. Compare the ways the writers of your texts create a sense of fear in ...

    He allows for Dorian to become mischievous and go against his otherwise usual morals by continuously allowing Lord Henry?s painting to get older and less attractive every time he sins. The painting is referred to as ?the most magical of mirrors.? For a while, Dorian allows the painting to take

  2. Compare the ways in which Larkin and Duffy present the reality of love.

    and multi-syllabic lexis (?silhouette?, ?obscenities?, ?vulnerable?). The mixed register is deliberate, intending to reflect the cognitive dissonance of the persona in the poem as she wakes up to reality, coming to the realisation that her relationship has broken down. ?Disgrace? is presented in a bleak tone, with the sombre mood

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work