The two poems 'To Lucasta, going to the Wars' and 'To Margot Heinemann' were written by men going to war. Discuss them in detail, making reference to subject, style and total impression and comparing and contrasting where you think appropriate.

Authors Avatar

Abby Lambert

L6

The two poems ‘To Lucasta, going to the Wars’ and ‘To Margot Heinemann’ were written by men going to war.  Discuss them in detail, making reference to subject, style and total impression and comparing and contrasting where you think appropriate.

It is generally thought that poems of such nature are sad, and these poems are no exception.  Here, we have two brave men going off to fight for their country, and leaving behind their loved ones.  Poems were usually a let out for the soldiers; it was a way of expressing their feelings without having to say them, when sometimes speaking is not enough.  Here, words speak the soldier’s true feelings, and you can grasp how they feel and what they wish for their loved ones once they are gone.  They know that they are going to die, it is more likely that they won’t return, which is why they are saying goodbye.  But, they may be both saying goodbye, but they do it in very different ways.  Each poem, putting across their feelings in ways which have an affect on the way you feel after you have finished reading them.

The first poem I mentioned in the title uses language which we don’t generally use today.  This doesn’t make it harder to read, but it is obvious that it was written differently to the other poem.  “Tell me not, Sweet, I am unkind.”  This opening line shows you that from the beginning the language is slightly different to how we speak today.  But the line actually isn’t as confusing as you first think.  When I read poems like these, I usually take one look at it and automatically tell myself I won’t understand it.  But really, after I read it you can see that’s not the case.  In actual fact, the soldier is telling ‘Lucasta’, who he is writing to, that she need not worry and not for her to think him mean for saying don’t worry about me.

Join now!

The second of the two poems doesn’t use such confusing language.  It is more conversational, but only compared to the other poem.  The words are in simple sentences, and none of the words are moved around in a strange order like the first poem.  He begins the poem saying “Heart of the heartless world, Dear Heart, the thought of you Is the pain at my side.”  Here I get the feeling he is saying that this world has no heart and he is there because the world is a cruel place.  He doesn’t want to be there obviously, but ...

This is a preview of the whole essay