• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Winter's Tale - Bohemian Scenes

Extracts from this document...


"The Bohemian scenes are a distraction from the key elements of the play" "The Bohemian scenes provide a welcome contrast to the wintry gloom established before them" How do you respond to these different criticisms of the play? What is your view on the significance of the Bohemian scenes? The two statements agree on the fact that the Bohemian scenes contrast with those based in Sicilia, but offer conflicting views as to the importance and usefulness of the scenes. It is important to highlight these contrasts. The scenes differ in two main ways. First is the natural setting of those in Bohemia with the formal courtliness of Sicilia. The most obvious portrayal of this contrast is through the characterisation and staging of the play. While the Sicilian scenes are based in Leontes' grand court with two kings and Queen Hermione, daughter of "the Emperor of Russia", surrounded by Lords and attendants. In Bohemia the audience is shown a sheep-shearing festival, watched by truly rural characters such as the Shepherd and his son, the Clown. On a more analytical level, this contrast is also made evident through the lines and language of the characters. ...read more.


His analogy with the moon also shows their natural deposition. Equally, Shakespeare's use of "half a kiss" as a unit of measurement is beautifully romantic. This romanticism is certainly no longer present between Leontes and Hermione (in one direction at least). He does refer to his initial love for Hermione when he states that she "never spok'st to better purpose" than when she told him that: "I am yours for ever". This soon deteriorates into maddened jealousy: "Inch-thick, knee-deep, o'er head and ears a forked one! [To Mamillius] Go play, boy, play: thy mother plays" Here is one of the strongest examples of "the infection of his brains". His reference to "a forked one" is him being cuckolded by his wife. The trochaic "inch-thick, knee-deep" gives the speech a trochaic start and a slightly obtuse rhythm, which only emphasises his madness. When he tells Mamillius to play, his mind instantly leaps back to his supposedly adulteress wife. This shows how completely overcome his mind is. Now that these contrasts have been established, we must determine whether or not they are a distraction and whether the contrast is welcome. I feel that the purpose of the Bohemia scenes is to advance the audience's knowledge of (and relationship with) ...read more.


gloomy end to the Sicilian scenes that involved the deaths of both the King's son and wife as well as the episode in which he denounces his innocent newborn daughter to be a "bastard". The turning point between the tragedy and the comedy is the now infamous stage direction "Exit pursued by a bear". Due to the fact that his crosses the borders of both tragedy and comedy, it can be performed to emphasise the sad loss of Archidamus or the humorous ridiculousness of the bear's presence. I feel that the Bohemia scenes are certainly significant as, through their contrast, they highlight the wrongdoings of the scenes that proceeded them, but also invite some sympathy and understanding for Leontes' position, similar to the feelings felt by Paulina over the 16 years skipped in act 4 scene 1 that reach an essential point in act 5 as she feels that he now deserves to have his wife returned to him. Equally, he vitally manages to lift the mood of the play as one based solely in Sicilia would stray from the atmosphere he wished to establish. Through a careful use of characters and themes, which are present in both Bohemia and Sicilia, Shakespeare maintains their relevance while avoiding them becoming a distraction. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level The Winter's Tale section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level The Winter's Tale essays

  1. How do relationships succeed or fail in the Winter's Tale?

    I, an old turtle, Will wing me to some withered bough, and there My mate, that's never to be found again, Lament till I am lost. [5.3.132-135] Paulina wants the revelation of Hermione's survival and also that of Hermione's reunion with Leontes, because Paulina understands Leontes' loss and Hermione's even greater losses.

  2. Winter's Tale Essay on Reference to the Gods and Fate

    Moreover, the line "humbling their deities to love," suggests that their love transcends even the gods, "deities" is another term for gods. Perdita similarly contrasts her pastoral background with Florizel's noble status. The rhetorical question, "how would he look to see his work, so noble, vilely bound up?"

  1. Act 1 of "The Winter's tale",

    However Leontes proceeds to basically ignore this. The fact that he's unwilling to listen to reason is further demonstrating his madness to the audience. He says: "Ha'not you seen...you have or your eye-glass is thicker than a cuckold's horn" Once again, using the image of a cuckold which is showing his obsession.

  2. The painful moment when Polixenes forbids his son's marriage shows that although Bohemia is ...

    The romantic comedy of Florizel and Perdita needs him; his cheerful misbehaviour provides an entertaining counterpoint to their earnest devotion. At the heart rendering moment when Polixenes refuses his noble sons marriage, appearance as the peddler provides both a comic counterpoint to the more serious love-plot.

  1. Parenting is a main element of “The Winters Tale”. Discuss the contrast between Leontes, ...

    "Give me the boy, I am glad you did not nurse him" is a quotation from Leontes that shows his jealously and lack of thought. This lack of thought continues until the jealousy 'switches off' again. Harassment from Leontes continues throughout the next couple of scenes, "away with her to prison" and "she's an adulteress".

  2. The Winter's Tale: Tragedy in Acts 1-3.

    The fact that Leontes wants to kill his life time best friend and also get someone else to do it is very distressing One feels sorry for Camillo as he is torn between what to do:' I must be the poisoner...to a master.'

  1. Discuss the presentation and significance of the relationship between Florizel and Perdita.

    Their relationship is symbolic of the unity between the two courts, as the courts? close relationship has been severed by Leontes? wrongdoings; accusing Polixenes of a ?crime? he did not commit. Their relationship hints the beginning of mending the old friendship between the two kings, symbolizing ?healing.? Florizel and Perdita


    Another view could be that, he probably agrees to carry out the king?s order to please him temporarily with the hidden intention of disobeying him later. Camillo?s sensitive and good nature is so discernible that it does not take much effort for Polixenes to see that he is behaving in

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work