• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Winter's Tale - Paulina and Hermione

Extracts from this document...


Critics have said that in the first movement (Acts I-III): "Hermione and Paulina are models of feminine strength" and "Hermione's passivity is dwarfed by Paulina's dynamism" * How do you respond to these different views of Hermione and Paulina? * What is your opinion of the impact of the two characters on an audience? These two views present conflicting arguments with regards to Hermione (King Leontes' wife) and Paulina (Hermione's assistant). The first argues that the pair display equal amounts of grit whereas the second proposes that Paulina's confrontational approach is more effective than Hermione's dignified docility. On the one hand, it is true that Paulina's dynamism is particularly effective. Her entrance in Act II is both bold and striking. She confidently command's: "the keeper of the prison, call to him. Let him have knowledge who I am". She continues to use imperatives as she takes control of the situation, "conduct me then", "call her" and "withdraw yourselves". Her succinct orders have particular effect due their concise and straightforward nature, which contrasts with the lengthy speeches of the previous scene. ...read more.


She begins with a torrent of rhetorical questions showing her confusion over the inequality of the situation ("What wheels? Racks? Fires? What flaying? Boiling? In leads or oils?"). The repeated use of the hard consonant "t" has a particularly cutting and irate effect. Her fury here is out of control. This unprecedented resistance would have a huge impact for the audience as it is the first time the King's irrational madness has been truly addressed and it follows such a poignant and shocking series of events. Her speech, similar to Leontes' speech which ended "she's an adultress", seems to build up to an almighty crecendo. In performance the rage and pace of the diction would build until the ominous and threatening final blow: "vengeance for't not dropped down yet". On the other hand, Hermione's approach is, although very different (as the first statement suggests) an equally effective display of strength. As with Paulina, Hermione's initial diction should be focussed on. She speaks eloquently and cleverly. ...read more.


It takes considerable strength for her to be so selfless in the face of such damning accusations. When she is officially accused in front of the courts in Act III, she continues to use calm and rational language: "To say, 'not guilty'; mine integrity, Being counted falsehood, shall, as I express it, Be so received". Despite the overwhelming poignancy (and irony as daughter of "the Emporer of Russia") of her position, she is collected, valuing her "honour" and "dignity". She shows particular courage when she refuses the be afraid of "the bug which you would fright me with" (death) as she has lost the love of her husband and is "barred" from her children. She goes so far as to claim that she actively death is something she would actively "seek". The Winter's Tale is remarkable for presenting women as the strongest characters in the play. Paulina has a striking impact on the audience as she displays her strength like no other character, through aggressive resilience. Hermione's collected and dignified display has an equally surprising impact, but she shows equal strength through humanity and honour. It is this that makes her death quite so poignant. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level The Winter's Tale section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level The Winter's Tale essays

  1. How do relationships succeed or fail in the Winter's Tale?

    We do not see Hermione and Leontes in a private setting but in public they are quite formal where Paulina and Antigonus are not. The idea of marriage being forever, as marriage is for love can only be corrupted when one of the couple disregards their love for something else.

  2. Character Analysis of Queen Hermione

    to tell him he is, in fact mistaken in the lines: "Should a villain say so The most replenish'd villain in the world He were as much more villain: you, my lord, Do but mistake" Furthermore to affirm her wit and luminosity is her way of comforting others on not

  1. The Winter's Tale: Tragedy in Acts 1-3.

    However through Paulina, Shakespeare has created much dramatic effect and added a very heartbreaking moment to the story. As said before tragedy is most evident in Leontes, this is exemplified further by his actions in this scene. Leontes says how he will kill Antigonous if he does not follow his orders.

  2. Examine Act 3 Scene 2 and consider its importance in the development of the ...

    Hermione's intelligence seems to emphasise the stupidity of Leontes. "All I know of it Is that Camillo was an honest man; And why he left your court the gods themselves ...Are ignorant" In conclusion, Hermione appears in this scene to be controlled, rational and intelligent, a stark contrast to Leontes.

  1. Some critics have claimed that the structure of "The Winters Tale is clumsy - ...

    Y'are very welcome" Plants are being handed over to suit the customer, in this case Camillo. He has been given flowers that rise in mid-summer which represents his age. In this play, Location is tightly linked with chronology . This is the period of time passed within the play and before it.

  2. An exploration of Shakespeare’s presentation of the different forms of love in 'The Winters ...

    He later uses the metaphor of a "pond" for women showing he has no respect for his wife or any other woman and reiterates his claim that all women are treacherous. Leontes passionate, obsessive personality causes problems in his relationships as he seems to react violently to everything, without considering the effects of his actions on others.

  1. It has been said that The Winter's Tale falls into two distinct halves. What ...

    - A savage clamour', which precedes the apparent death of Antigonus, pursued by a bear and Perdita left to face the elements. The exit of Antigonus, pursued by a bear, could be interpreted as comic rather than tragic, however whichever interpretation is chosen, it marks the change in tone.

  2. The Winter's Tale - Bohemian Scenes

    His peculiar syntax ("what comes the wool to?") would lead a director to using a West Country accent, further emphasising his rural background. In Sicilia, the language is much more formal. Polixenes pleads: "press me not, beseech you". This stilted diction is commonplace and the various members of the court refer to each other formally as "sir".

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work