• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Theories Of Language Development - Chomsky and Skinner

Extracts from this document...


Theories Of Language Development 10/10/03 Skinner Vs Chomsky Emma Smith Many psychologists have studied and researched into how we acquire language. Some have concluded that the ability to learn language is a genetically inherited skill. Others believe that language is learnt following birth and is due to environmental factors. This is part of the nature vs. nurture debate. One of the main psychologists who supported the nurture side was B.F Skinner. Skinner is an empiricist. He put forward the idea that children learn language because of the influence of the environment. Skinner believed that parents would provide more attention and pleasurable reactions when the infant made correct sounds or utterances. This way the child would gradually learn to speak and use language. The child would respond to the smiles and approval of the parents. Skinner explained this as operant conditioning; the reinforcement of a random response by a reward. By trial and error the child would learn to communicate. The child would repeat verbal behaviour that was rewarded and drop sounds or speech that did not work in terms of getting a pleasurable response. This is selective reinforcement. Pavlov and his dogs were and excellent example of operant conditioning. Pavlov rang a bell when it was time for the dogs to eat; eventually the dogs associated the bell with food. Each time the bell rang the dogs salivated. ...read more.


is proved to be a very successful form of teaching. Speech is simplified and clarified through tone, pace and pitch. Rhymes are also used to draw attention to and provide interest in word. For example "Doggy-woggy". Although this is more the input and social approach and is not quite what skinner had in mind, it does support the idea that environmental factors are important to language acquisition and development. * A psychologist called Rheingold found that a programme of reinforcement and non-reinforcement of three-month-old babblers affected the frequency of their vocalisations. * The learning theory also explains the acquisition of the meaning of words. Criticisms Against Skinner's Theory Very few people now believe that Skinner's learning theory completely explains how language is leaned. Therefore there is no surprise that the theory was widely criticised and just like any other theory developed some cracks. * Evidence from observational studies does not support Skinner's theory. Children seem to be able to learn and understand grammar despite the exposure to incorrect grammatical sentences. * Brown found that parents do not correct or reinforce grammar, but respond more to the truth of sentences. For Example, if the child says "he a girl" the mother would reply "Yes. That's a girl". * Trial and error learning cannot explain the rapid acquisition of language and the huge overall language comprehension that young children learn. ...read more.


* Learning has to play a role in correcting errors (such as "goed"). Chomsky's theory ignores the active role of parents in teaching language to their children. * The case of Genie provides mixed evidence for the role of innate language acquisition abilities, but does seem to encounter the idea of a critical time period (also known as the sensitive period) for acquisition as proposed by Lenneburg. Genie was deprived of proper verbal stimulation for thirteen years because she had been locked in a room away from human contact since birth. Although she was able to learn language she never developed completely normal linguistic abilities. This implies that humans have a sensitive period for normal language acquisition early in life. * Sachs reported the case of Jim, whose parents deaf but who was surrounded by spoken language from the television and radio in the hope that he would learn normal language. Jim showed no signs of learning language until a speech therapist took up his case at the age of three. Without the human interaction with the speech therapist there was no sign that Jim would have learned to speak. He needed the interaction before his language ability could develop. * If language development was innate, surely it would develop soon after we are able to control our voices, which is soon after one year of age. It does not explain why language takes a few years to develop. * Chomsky's theory also doesn't explain why there are such large variations in the rate children learn language. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Language: Context, Genre & Frameworks essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Investigating how language has changed in children's literature; in relation to interaction between ...

    5 star(s)

    "Professor Dumbledore" and "Darrell" is approaching "Miss Potts" with an enquiry, which changed the focus in relation to power. A further aspect of context (in relation to language and power change over time) was the influence of school culture. There are generally unspoken codes that students do not interrupt teachers, and that conversations should be conducted in a prescribed manner.

  2. Innatist and Interactionist theories and their teaching implications

    (Lightbown and Spada.) The theories which influence me most in my future teaching career None of the theories can stand alone to explain second language acquisition. Despite of this, the Interactionist theories are most influential to my future teaching. I agree with many recent researchers such as Hatch and Long

  1. Critically evaluate one theory of language development. Chomsky argues that language is a formal ...

    to make a word plural add 's') and finally tests these newly formed words by using them in spontaneous speech. These words are the either rejected or accepted. This theory can be applied to any language and will acquire the grammar of that language. Fowler and Swenson (1979, in Gross, 1999)

  2. Investigation into Gender Differences in the Language of Personal Profiles on Dating Websites

    Eating out and sharing laughs with those I love. Like TV, cinema and theatre, music (all sorts),visiting stately homes, seeing the country. Love the sea. my ethnicity: Born in the outskirts of London and have mostly lived in the suburbs.

  1. Describe and discuss the Nativist and Behaviour theories of language acquisition, using examples to ...

    Noam Chomsky a linguist believes that all languages have the same basic grammatical features such as consonants, vowels, syllables, nouns and verbs irrespective of the final language the child will learn. This is known as linguistic universal. Nativist's believe all children are born with a Language Acquisition Device (LAD)

  2. Extended response to journeys.

    The powerful image created in the simile "Like a guillotine-cutting us off from the space of eyesight" symbolises the final cut between the present and the past. It defines the point where "there is no going back" to the past life they once knew if they take upon this journey.

  1. Language development in exceptional circumstances: Auditory Impairment

    Maestes and Moore found evidence of 'parentese' displayed towards the child. They discovered how deaf parents used a form of 'motherese' as a means of social interaction with child. The children studied were in fact too young to be signing, but it was apparent that 'motherese' was being used and deliberate shaping of signing was found.

  2. Translation Studies

    relations it has with the language structure as a whole. Moreover, within the secondary modelling system there is one type of associative relation and the translator, like the specialist in advertising techniques , must consider both the primary and the secondary associative lines.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work