• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

(THIS IN OURSELVES THAT WE ARE THUS OR THUS) IS THE STORY OF OTHELLO ONE OF TRANSFORMATION OR EXPOSURE?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

("THIS IN OURSELVES THAT WE ARE THUS OR THUS") IS THE STORY OF OTHELLO ONE OF TRANSFORMATION OR EXPOSURE? According to Aristotle's views a tragic hero is consistent and therefore should not be subject to sudden change if it does not contribute to the story or if it is not clearly motivated. If Othello is a tragic hero by Aristotle's definition then character must be exposed rather than transformed by Shakespeare. Arguing that the story of Othello is a transformation would contradict Aristotle's belief of consistency. In Act III, scene iii when Othello says 'I'll tear her with all to pieces!" The usage of brutal metaphor, animalistic and hyperbolic language portrays his aggressive character. Furthermore, exclamation underlines the dramatic tone and his seriousness. Through the use of those techniques Shakespeare manifestly exaggerates the brutality of Othello. This gives us the impression of Shakespeare's racism in that the aim of this tragedy might be to convince its audience to have a negative view about the black race. Therefore, the way that Othello humiliates Desdemona through slapping her in front of other characters is inevitable because it is something than Elizabethans would expect. ...read more.

Middle

The usage of animalistic imagery and sexually brutal metaphors clearly suggests that Othello does not enjoy positive attitudes and respect from other characters. Secondly, in Act I, scene III Othello is presented as a well-respected man heavily experienced by his previous struggles as he refers to 'disastrous chances', 'moving accidents' and 'hair-breadth scapes'. It is important to point out that Othello tells a synecdoche using exaggerations and personifications such as 'insolent foe' and 'moving accidents by flood and field' to make sure that the listeners fully acknowledged his courage. This technique is common for Greek tragedies such as 'Oedipus Rex' and other Shakespeare's tragedies such as 'Hamlet' to display events that do not happen in the play directly but revealed by particular characters in their speeches or dialogues. This also rapidly changes our view about Othello. His confidence and high rank as well as his previous experiences hardly affect on the fact that we become to see him as an impressive character. Conversely, Othello lacks in confidence and presents insecurity about his race in one of his very first speeches when he clearly undermines his orator skills ('Rude am I in my speech'). ...read more.

Conclusion

Some might believe that people change by the impact of environment or influence of other characters. However, early presented factors such as Othello's insecurity and the issue of black race need to be considered. This creates the dilemma concerning the time of Othello's possible transformation. Indeed, Othello's reaction on Desdemona's apparent affair was suspiciously quick and that exposure builds quickly whereas transformation takes longer. The final piece of evidence that this is a story of exposure is placed in Othello's death speech in act V, scene ii when Othello says 'Of one not easily jealous but, being wrough, perplexed in the extreme'. The dramatic tone of his declamation proves the fact that he feels ashamed of what he has done. Other than that Othello presents himself as a person who has not been previously jealous and someone has turned him to jealousy. Thus he suggests that he sees himself as transformed rather than exposed. However I would argue that this can be seen as an evidence of his exposure as Othello highly regrets his violent behaviour. Furthermore, he commits suicide which simply contradicts the theory of transformation as someone who has been transformed wouldn't regret his actions. Bibliography F.R Leavis `Diabolic Intellect and the Noble Hero(1952), Casebook Series: Shakespeare: Othello(Palgrave: Basingstoke, 1994), ed. John Wain, pp. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Othello section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Othello essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Different Interpretations of Key speeches from Othello and Iago in Act 1, scene 3

    3 star(s)

    Iago's speech suggests to different things in my opinion; when he is talking to other people he is very manipulative and persuasive in getting what he wants. To do this he uses emotive language and rhetorical questions such as, "Drown Thyself?"

  2. Explore the presentation of the relationship between Othello and Iago

    He starts with a question, which apparently has little importance, "Did Michael Cassio.....know of your love?" but which is deliberately given heavy significance by Iago's reaction to the reply, "Indeed?" He is provoking Othello into a reaction by deliberately appearing to be holding information back.

  1. An Exploration of Imagery in Othello

    Ironically, Othello casts himself here as God's advocate as he sees his wife as a corrupt sinner, whereas in reality he will be 'damned' for her unjust murder. Further evidence of Iago's influence on Othello can be perceived as the imagery of monsters is also used by both Othello and Iago.

  2. How far do we see different attitudes to love presented in Othello?

    But Othello is not the only person who thinks of love as valiant and war-like. Cassio, in his praise for Desdemona, also subscribes to this view (II,1). True it is clearly Petrarchan, yet when he refers to Desdemona as "our great captain's captain" or as "the riches of the ship"

  1. Many definitions of tragedy claim that at the end of the play positives have ...

    can be drawn from the play in the sense that Iago is now a prisoner and we are now satisfied. The lack of satisfaction and catharsis is intensified as Iago's story is left unfinished because nobody says 'why' it happened, even though the "devil" is "a prisoner".

  2. Othello and Desdemonas love at the beginning of the play is built on mutual ...

    Furthermore, similar to us, Lodovico cannot prevent the tangle of evil which will ensue. Iago?s manipulation of Othello is unquestionably the cause of the descent of Desdemona and Othello?s love. Othello?s change of heart is a result of the poisonous deceits that Iago pours into his ears, but there is

  1. Is Othello presented as a tragic hero or as an 'erring barbarian' in the ...

    Without the audience even seeing Othello, hearing Iago say these two insults the Elizabethan audience would of known that Iago's metaphor was used to connote a savage 'Moor'. When animal references are used with regard to Othello, as they frequently are, they reflect the racism both of characters in the play and of Shakespeare's contemporary audience.

  2. How does Shakespeare use representations of speech and other dramatic techniques to explore the ...

    shows that he is expected to know how to kill Cassio, and so Othello is trusting Iago to know the answer. The use of the interrogatives asked, show Othello losing his position as a governor in this scene, he also loses his air of authority as asking questions to Iago shows his weakness.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work