• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent and in what ways is Fitzgerald purely critical of Gatsby's dreams?

Extracts from this document...


To what extent and in what ways is Fitzgerald purely critical of Gatsby's dreams? One of the main themes of 'The Great Gatsby' is that of dreams, none of which is more noticeable than Gatsby's own dream of five years in his pursuit of Daisy. What is less obvious is how Fitzgerald wants us to react to these dreams, and whether he is being purely critical of them or whether he in fact does also reveal some good in them. In this essay I aim to show that although in a lot of ways Fitzgerald is critical of Gatsby's dreams, for example by ensuring that Daisy can never live up to the vision of herself which Gatsby has created, he is not entirely disapproving and in several cases even goes as far as to suggest that dreaming is what makes us human. One way in which we may be unsure about Fitzgerald's presentation of Gatsby's dreams is whether they are meant to appear romantic or slightly pathetic. At face value it can seem to be extremely romantic that Gatsby has waited these five years and remained so loyal to Daisy, and I think that it this way Fitzgerald wants us to be on Gatsby's side. ...read more.


This makes her seem a lot less human than Gatsby and we empathise with him far more, which I think Fitzgerald wants us to do. This suggests that Fitzgerald is supportive of 'the dreamer' and tells us that he is not opposed to the idea of dreams in general. In fact he associates the illusion with the phrase "colossal vitality" which again evokes the idea that dreams are linked with the essence of being human and that Fitzgerald views Gatsby's dreams with something other than pure criticism. One of the main criticisms which Fitzgerald does have of Gatsby's dreams is the materialism inherent with them. To gain Daisy's affections, Gatsby accumulates extortionate wealth and belongings to attract her, and Daisy herself represents something of the materialistic upper class which Gatsby strives to become a part of. This is very concisely put when Gatsby says of Daisy "her voice is full of money". Daisy's voice has particular prominence as a motif throughout the book but at this point it is almost a leit motif as it gains meaning. All we can judge Daisy by is her voice, we never know her thoughts or what she is really thinking as what she says is usually quite empty. ...read more.


I think that there is also a slight positive side to Fitzgerald's choice of making Daisy an unworthy dream, as it shows that everybody can be loved by someone, however this is not very strong as Gatsby does not love Daisy with her faults, and rather it seems that he is just immune to seeing her flaws. Fitzgerald in fact, is probably somewhere in between these views; he is not directly attacking dreams or even Gatsby's dreams, but he is more in this case attacking Daisy's character. Although it may be a large lack of judgement skills on Gatsby's side, we cannot blame him entirely and again we still feel sorry for him when Daisy does eventually let him down. Overall I think that it is clear that there is a strong sense of ambiguity when it comes to Fitzgerald's attitude to Gatsby's dreams. However, I feel that the main point he wishes to make is that there is nothing wrong with dreaming, you just have to be careful when choosing your dreams that what you are longing for is actually worthwhile and won't end up hurting you more than it can make you happy. In Gatsby's case his aim appears to be more to make us feel sorry that he was so misguided in his choice of dream, rather than to berate him for dreaming at all. ?? ?? ?? ?? Harriet Blair 12EM ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level F. Scott Fitzgerald section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

This essay has some excellent moments and some over-generalised points. The structure is clear and the writing is fluent. Textual knowledge is evident but could be more wide ranging to develop the argument without resorting to vague comments about dreams. This essay has 5 star and 3 start moments!

Marked by teacher Roz Shipway 07/12/2012

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level F. Scott Fitzgerald essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Explore F.Scotts Fitzgeralds presentation of class and wealth in The Great Gatsby and The ...

    4 star(s)

    'The Great Gatsby' by virtue of its representations of wealth and class can be seen as a running criticism of the American Dream and America's obsession with wealth amidst the hedonistic culture of the 1920's. The American Dream had originally been founded on the notion that anyone, irrespective of their

  2. Marked by a teacher

    'The American Dream not only fails to fulfil its promise but also contributes to ...

    4 star(s)

    This undermines the importance of a happy, stable marriage in the eyes of the characters and society itself. Fitzgerald provides a social commentary when detailing the affair; Tom even breaks Myrtle's nose with a 'short, deft movement'. He is careless of her admiration of the dogs at the station and

  1. The significant roles of Tom and Daisy in the Great Gatsby

    Daisy had become materialistic and now desperate to seek love. Fitzgerald portrays this in chapter one when Daisy looks through the window and claims to see a Nightingale, 'Must have come over on the Cunard or White star line.' This is a symbolic indication that romanticism had to adapt to America culture.

  2. The great gatsby essay

    [Leaving] other people to clean up the mess they had made." (pg. 170) They were known as the, 'old rich,' and were therefore believed to be superior and supercilious towards the West Eggers. The contrast of such characters enhances our understanding of how the class-conscious society of the 1920s was

  1. In The Great Gatsby, Fitzgerald captures both the disillusionment of post-war America and the ...

    The Buchanans depict the ruthless vindictiveness of the rich with their "old money" defeating "new money" symbolised by Gatsby. For example, Gatsby "had broken up like glass against Tom's hard malice". The use of a simile and the contrast between fragile glass and the "hard" malice of Tom help to emphasise the idea of the callousness of the rich.

  2. Three characters in The Great Gatsby and the theme of obsession

    Though Daisy might seem like the kind of girl you could take home to your parents, she was nothing of the sort. She was the queen of manipulation. Daisy was obsessed with the notion of another person exuding his/her love for her. She loved attention-whether it was positive or negative.

  1. Examine the characterisation of Jay Gatsby as an admirable yet flawed character.

    Gatsby realises that great wealth alone is not enough to obtain Daisy and completely reinvents himself in order to try and break the social barrier to access her world. He builds an illusion of an eccentric aristocrat by adopting affected phrases such as ?old sport?, dressing in imported English shirts

  2. Gatsby is more of an anti-hero than a hero. With reference to appropriately selected ...

    Finally, it could be argued that Gatsby is a moral hero. A moral hero is a character of good moral values that believes in the dignity and value of humanity. This is reflected in Nick?s observations of Gatsby: ?Gatsby turned out all right at the end.? Of course Gatsby has

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work