• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent do Shakespeare and your writer present harmony and reconciliation as possible endings to the various conflicts within the play?

Extracts from this document...


Saturday, 17 May 2003 Jad Salfiti A2 English Literature To what extent do Shakespeare and your writer present harmony and reconciliation as possible endings to the various conflicts within the play? 'The Tempest' written by William Shakespeare and 'Translations' written by Brian Friel both share allot of common ground. Thematically, they both explore the idea of hegemony; one culture supplanting another. Both plays demonstrate the impact of colonisation, in Translations, Hugh shows how economic advancement and cultural integrity can collide, whereas Caliban shows how Prospero has forced Caliban into a linguistic straightjacket. Parallels can be drawn between Caliban and the people of Ireland; both are misunderstood and underestimated, Caliban's original language is reduced and stigmatised. Miranda calls it "babble", Caliban recites the most beautiful lines in the play, and clearly he is not the "monster" Prospero would like to believe. Equally Yolland finds it "astonishing" that Jimmy Jack and Hugh are so well-educated, this reflects the social/cultural attitudes of the time, in England the Irish were commonly portrayed and thus stereotyped as being 'Paddys' and 'barbaric'. Both the Irish and Caliban must "adjust for survival". This adjustment can be poignant and no doubt the initial harmony is disrupted. However, in both plays there is partial reconciliation, in 'Translations', we see the coloniser and the colonised "leap over the ditch" into a brief exogamous relationship. ...read more.


In reality, however, Yolland is more as a hibernophile than Owen, who seems to be keener on adjusting "for survival" rather than the preservation of tradition. Owen and Yolland blur the distinction between the Irish and the English; he is an Irishman who transcends racial distinction, so much so that he becomes more of an 'Englishman'. He has made the afore-mentioned choice, and opted for economic advancement. Owen is someone who will by the end of the play be reconciled with the culture he left behind, when he takes on Manus' role. In 'The Tempest' Caliban is brutalised and corrupted. 'The Tempest' was written in 1611 during the Jacobean Period, following the discovery of the Bermudas and the colonisation of Ireland. Caliban might be interpreted as a representation of the 'primitive' people who occupied the Bermudas, great debate occurred over whether they Bermudas should be colonised, Rousseau's 'noble savage' myth was the argument used to oppose an imperialist conquest. Prospero's arrival on the island disrupted the harmony. From a modern post-colonial perspective this emphasises the fine line between liberation and colonisation an issue we are confronted with now with the Iraq Crisis. "You taught me language, and my profit on't/Is I know how to curse". He sees Prospero as entirely oppressive; while Prospero claims that he cared for and educated Caliban before he tried to rape Miranda. ...read more.


In the Masque towards the end there is a Reconciliation of the real and the fantastical in the shape of the natural reapers joining with the supernatural nymphs "in a great dance". This symbolises the reconciliation of the pagan (fleshy) and the Christian (spiritual) and the combining of the body and spirit In 'Translations', reconciliation is shown between two the English and the Irish. The first embodiment of this is Owen who takes elements from both and represents the new man. The second is the exogamous inter-racial relationship between Maire and Yolland, although there relationship is brief it shows the potential for future reconciliation between the English and the Irish, the fact that the play uses English language to express Irish characters adds fuel to this argument, however Manus' actions demonstrates that obstacles will stand in the way. Jimmy's words seem to summarise these obstacles "you don't cross these borders casually- both sides get very angry" it is cultural conditioning which separates us as human beings, race is used as a barrier. However the play ends on a note of harmony, when a stubborn Hugh agrees to teach Maire English, this sea change indicates that the problems can be overcome when "both sides" have reached a stage of 'spiritual understanding' and pay no heed to political factions which stand as only as an impediment to human progress. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level The Tempest section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level The Tempest essays

  1. Why is Caliban such an interesting an important character in 'The Tempest' and how ...

    Caliban didn't want to be nurtured as he never sounds sorry for his wrong actions. Prospero may have been unsuccessful in nurturing Caliban because the nurture was intended to control him, not educate or free him. Magic is used kindly when Prospero sets up the plot with Miranda and Ferdinand,

  2. "The role of the teacher can often be a negative one" discuss…

    This Conservative views of 'factory fodder'. Prospero has a fascistic view of education and human nature; he thinks Caliban is innately, genetically bad. From a post-colonial perspective Caliban is analogous to Sarah. Prospero's teaching methods are very right-wing; he clearly sees no hope for an 'uneducateable' Caliban who is viewed as innately bad and therefore cannot be reformed as a character.

  1. The Significance of Colonialism in William Shakespeare's The Tempest (1610/11), Thomas More's Utopia (1516) ...

    succinctly and incapable of bridling his sexual desires, Caliban's punishment is a lifetime of servitude and shame. Thus his failure at education and misdemeanour provides Prospero with rationale for the expropriation and enslavement of Caliban. Patriarchal colonial rule is established upon the isle with Prospero as supreme head of state;

  2. 'To what extent do you agree that the Masque is an "integral part of ...

    Although the masque serves as a tool to augment some of the narrative aspects of the play, it also serves greater purposes; those of spectacle and symbolism. The play was Shakespeare's last and at the time of writing he would have probably known this.

  1. With reference to two or three episodes, explore Shakespeare's dramatic use and presentation of ...

    therefore has no reason to lie about what Caliban is really like, yet his description of Caliban is still very negative, "a born devil, on whose nature nurture can never stick; on whom my pains...lost". Therefore Shakespeare is presenting Caliban as being inevitably evil - due to the fact that

  2. The real monster in The Tempest is Prospero rather than Caliban

    Although Caliban has committed a foul act against Miranda, in my opinion this does not give Prospero the right to mistreat Caliban in such a way. The apparent lack of empathy for Caliban on Prospero's part seems somewhat cold-hearted. With a young daughter of his own, he should be able to sympathise with Caliban.

  1. Is Prospero a magnanimous ruler or an oppressive coloniser?

    However can we trust Ariel about what she says after all she is just an air spirit and does not have a brain and might not be able to think like humans. "...mine would sir were I human..." But Ariel does show some humane qualities like when she convinces prospero to forgive his enemies instead of taking revenge.

  2. The Tempest has been read by some as a Christian allegory. Examine how Shakespeare ...

    The Tempest is literarily similar to the Gospel of Mark in many regards, with a forthright, active and brief style. Moving on, another area of the play that could be considered allegory is Act 3 Scene 3, which explores the nature of sin.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work